IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY
CRI-2015-441-38 [2015] NZHC 2588
IN THE MATTER of an appeal against sentence BETWEEN
KYLIE ANN MITCHELL Appellant
AND
NEW ZEALAND POLICE Respondent
Hearing: 20 October 2015 Appearances:
P Jensen for the Appellant
MJM Mitchell for the RespondentJudgment:
20 October 2015
ORAL JUDGMENT OF MUIR J
Counsel:
P Jensen, Barrister, Napier
Solicitors:
MJM Mitchell, Crown Solicitor, Napier
MITCHELL v NEW ZEALAND POLICE [2015] NZHC 2588 [20 October 2015]
Introduction
[1] Ms Mitchell pleaded guilty to and was sentenced on one charge of breach of community work to two months’ community detention. She also had $7,820.63 in outstanding fines remitted, with a sentence of three months’ community detention imposed in lieu (to be served cumulatively with the other sentence).
[2] She appeals on the ground that the sentence of five months’ community
detention was manifestly excessive.
Factual background
[3] In September 2014 Ms Mitchell was convicted for the fifth time of driving while disqualified. She was sentenced to 40 hours of community work. By June
2015, she had completed only 20 of those hours. She was charged with a breach of community work and she pleaded guilty.
[4] The pre-sentence report provided to the District Court described Ms Mitchell as working six days a week and someone who found herself too tired after work to complete her sentence obligations. The report noted that a number of allowances had been made in order to support Ms Mitchell in completing her sentence, but she failed to follow through and failed to maintain contact with her probation officer. A decision was made at one point to place Ms Mitchell at a community work centre to complete her sentence, however, she did not show up out of concern, she said, of running into a negative associate from her past, from whom she had managed to distance herself. The report noted that Ms Mitchell suffers from serious anxiety and that this made it hard for her to attend community work, as she apparently goes through periods when she is unable to leave her home.
[5] The report also noted that Ms Mitchell has suffered from alcoholism in the past, but she overcame those problems 15 years ago. Clearly, as Mr Jensen says in his submissions, she has made considerable efforts in many parts of her life.
[6] The fines owing at the time of her sentence were primarily for illegal parking, failure to display vehicle registrations, failure to register household pets and like matters. In total, there had been 42 of them since 2012.
Previous criminal history
[7] Ms Mitchell has four previous convictions for breaches of community work and two convictions for non-compliance with court orders. She has numerous driving convictions. She has previously successfully completed sentences of community detention.
District Court Decision
[8] In the District Court Ms Mitchell accepted that community detention should be imposed in respect of the breach and for her outstanding fines. The Judge noted Ms Mitchell’s guilty pleas and that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mitchell v Police and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] NZHC 2588
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the circumstances of the case, including Mitchell's history of noncompliance with court orders, her failure to communicate her difficulties to relevant authorities, and her admission of no reasonable excuse for her breach of community work. The court considered the principle of manifest excessiveness in sentencing appeals, noting that the High Court will not intervene if the sentence falls within the range justified by accepted sentencing principles. The court also looked at the Crown's argument that there are policy reasons for enforcing fines and that the sentence was within an available range.
In its reasoning, the court found that the sentence of two months' community detention for the breach of community work was not manifestly excessive, considering Mitchell's history of noncompliance and her indifference to her obligations. The court also found that the sentence of three months' community detention for unpaid fines was not manifestly excessive, as the fines had a societal cost and their enforcement was a legitimate purpose of sentencing. The court concluded that there was no error in the District Court's judgment and declined the appeal.
In conclusion, the High Court upheld the District Court's sentence of five months' community detention for Kylie Ann Mitchell, finding that it was not manifestly excessive. The appeal was dismissed, and the original sentence stands.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi