Minister of Education v McCartney

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2016-441-101 [2017] NZHC 47

BETWEEN

THE MINISTER OF EDUCATION

First Plaintiff

THE SECRETARY OF EDUCATION Second Plaintiff

THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF PARKVALE PRIMARY SCHOOL Third Plaintiff

AND

TANIA MAY MCCARTNEY First Defendant

CRAIG ROBERT MCCARTNEY Second Defendant

Hearing: 12 December 2016

Counsel:

M McFarlane for Plaintiffs
J F McDowell for Second Defendant

Judgment:

31 January 2017

JUDGMENT OF WILLIAMS J

Introduction

[1]      The first defendant was, for some years, a school administrator with access to her employer’s bank accounts and credit card.  During the course of her employment she stole nearly $170,000 from the school.  She was charged and pleaded guilty.  She was then convicted and sentenced for her offending.

[2]      She and her husband, the second defendant, separated in June 2016, largely as a result, it seems, of the revelations over her offending.  The following month they executed a separation and relationship property agreement.  The agreement provides

that  the  only  significant  asset  of  the  relationship,  the  family  home,  is  to  be

THE MINISTER OF EDUCATION & ORS v MCCARTNEY & ANOR [2017] NZHC 47 [31 January 2017]

transferred to the husband.   The home is said, in the agreement, to be valued at

$395,000 though it is subject to a mortgage of $103,000.1

[3]      The school and the Ministry of Education now sue the wife and husband seeking to recover the value of that which she took from the school, external investigation costs, interest and costs.   The wife is sued in deceit and breach of fiduciary obligation as an employee for the sum lost; and both husband and wife are sued for relief (effectively) by way of declaration seeking to set aside the separation and relationship property agreement.  It is argued the agreement is void pursuant to s 47 of the Property (Relationships) Act 1976 (PRA).  Since the agreement takes the family home outside of the wife’s part ownership, it will frustrate the claim by the school and Ministry to the wife’s half of the value of the home.

[4]      Freezing orders were granted on an ex parte basis by Clifford J on 31 August

2016.  These prevented any dealing with the family home until the application could be argued on notice.2

[5]      The wife filed a formal admission of claim on 20 September 2016 in relation to the sum stolen – but not in relation to the application under s 47.  That application therefore remains to be argued.

[6]      The parties have subsequently agreed that the interim orders should remain until further order of this Court, and that in the meantime a preliminary question as to whether the remaining cause of action in relation to the separation agreement can be dealt with in this Court or whether exclusive jurisdiction in that respect belongs to

the Family Court.  I turn now to answer that question.

1      The narrative in the agreement suggests that the exchange is fair because, during the course of the marriage, the wife also extracted approximately $340,000…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister of Education v McCartney and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved the Minister of Education, the Secretary of Education, and the Board of Trustees of Parkvale Primary School as plaintiffs, and Tania May McCartney and her husband, Craig Robert McCartney, as defendants. The plaintiffs sought to recover the money stolen by Tania from the school, along with external investigation costs, interest, and costs. Tania was sued for deceit and breach of fiduciary obligation, while both Tania and Craig were sued for relief by way of a declaration seeking to set aside their separation and relationship property agreement. The plaintiffs argued that the agreement was void under the Property (Relationships) Act 1976 (PRA) and that it would frustrate their claim to Tania's half of the family home's value.

The primary legal issue was whether the High Court had jurisdiction to deal with the remaining cause of action regarding the separation agreement or whether exclusive jurisdiction belonged to the Family Court. The court had to determine whether the High Court could decide relationship property issues as if the PRA governed the dispute, even if it was not the Family Court. The court also had to consider whether the High Court could make declarations regarding the ownership of property claimed by a third party, not in the relationship.

The court found that the High Court had jurisdiction to deal with the matter. The court held that the exclusive jurisdiction of the Family Court was limited to applications covered by s 25(1) of the PRA. Section 25(3) – covering declaratory remedies – was not exclusive to the Family Court in at least two situations involving the rights of third parties: (a) where the property was vested in a third party; and (b) where the property was claimed by a third party not in the relationship. The court also found that s 4(4) of the PRA provided the authority for the High Court to decide relationship property issues. The court concluded that there was no reason for it to defer to the Family Court in setting aside the separation agreement as it was intended to defeat the creditors of one of the spouses.

The court granted the interim orders, allowing them to remain in place until further order of the court. The court also found that it had jurisdiction to deal with the matter and that the interim orders were properly made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established