Minister of Education v IT Architects Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

CIV-2012-470-475 [2014] NZHC 1541

IN THE MATTER OF the ROTOTUNA PRIMARY SCHOOL

BETWEEN

MINISTER OF EDUCATION First Plaintiff

SECRETARY FOR EDUCATION Second Plaintiff

BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE ROTOTUNA PRIMARY SCHOOL Third Plaintiff

AND

IT ARCHITECTS LIMITED First Defendant

IAN ANDREW THORN Second Defendant

KUMARA INVESTMENTS LIMITED Third Defendant/ First Fourth Party

CONSTRUCT LIMITED
Fourth Defendant/Sixteenth Fourth Party

AND

CARTER HOLT HARVEY LIMITED First Third Party

HAMILTON CITY COUNCIL Second Third Party

AND

PAUL DAMIAN BARNETT Second Fourth Party

LOBELL CONSTRUCTION LIMITED Third Fourth Party

DENNIS RUSSELL GEORGE SHAW Fourth Fourth Party

LOUIS TASMAN SHAW Fifth Fourth Party

MINISTER OF EDUCATION v IT ARCHITECTS LIMITED & OTHERS [2014] NZHC 1541 [3 July 2014]

OWEN BARLOW ROOFING LIMITED Sixth Fourth Party

OWEN LLOYD BARLOW Seventh Fourth Party

PAUL MAKUCH ROOFING LIMITED Eighth Fourth Party

PAUL ALAN MAKUCH Ninth Fourth Party

WAIKATO WATERPROOFING LIMITED

Tenth Fourth Party

ROBERT GEORGE FURMAGE Eleventh Fourth Party

CHARLES NORRIE GIBBS Twelfth Fourth Party

NATHAN TARANAKI CONSTSRUCTION LIMITED Thirteenth Third Party

NATHAN KYLE TARANAKI Fourteenth Fourth Party

MAURICE ERROL (JOHNNY) AITKEN Fifteenth Fourth Party

Hearing: 30 April 2014

Appearances:

N Whittington and S Navot for plaintiffs
J Q Wilson for first and second third parties

Judgment:

3 July 2014

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE BELL

This judgment was delivered by me on 3 July 2014 at 5:00pm

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

………………………………………….

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

[1]      The first and second third parties have taken a position of deep suspicion that the plaintiffs cannot discover documents properly.  A useful technique when faced with a suspicious attitude is to openly disclose information and show that there is no cause for concern. The plaintiffs have tried that.  It has not worked.

[2]      The plaintiffs filed an affidavit of documents on 4 March 2013.  The third parties were not satisfied.  In August 2013 the first third party applied for further and better discovery. That application sought disclosure of 22 classes of documents. The second third party filed a similar application on 19 September 2013, seeking disclosure of 19 classes  of documents. The plaintiffs filed a further affidavit  of documents on 15 October 2013.  On 23 October 2013 the first third party filed an amended application seeking disclosure of 34 classes of documents.  The plaintiffs filed  a  third  affidavit  of  documents  on  30  October  2013,  a  fourth  one  on

22 November 2013 and a fifth one on 12 February 2014.

[3]        By the time of the hearing on 30 April 2014 the issues had narrowed.  The third parties focused on four classes of documents in the first third party’s amended application (categories 1, 7, 12 and 34).   For these documents, the third parties challenged the plaintiffs’ claims for litigation privilege and sought identification of particular policies and guidelines of the Ministry of Education on its website.  The third parties sought disclosure of those parts of documents that had been covered up on  the  grounds  of  irrelevance.    The  third  parties  also…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister of Education v IT Architects Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1541
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves a claim for damages for water ingress damage to buildings at Rototuna Primary School, Hamilton. The plaintiffs, the Minister of Education, the Secretary for Education and the Board of Trustees of the Rototuna Primary School, are seeking damages of $3,360,062.06 for the costs of remedial works and consequential losses of $426,347.37. The defendants are the architectural practice, IT Architects Ltd; its director, Mr Thorn; a project management company and construction contractors. The architect has joined Carter Holt Harvey Ltd as first third party and the Hamilton City Council as second third party. A significant issue in the case goes to the use of Carter Holt's Shadowclad Texture as an exterior wall cladding. The architect has joined Carter Holt Harvey because it alleges that the product was defective. While it admits manufacturing Shadowclad Texture, Carter Holt Harvey denies that its product was used in the school. It also alleges that any damage attributable to the use of its product arises from errors in design by the architect and errors in installation by contractors. The third parties have taken a position of deep suspicion that the plaintiffs cannot discover documents properly. The plaintiffs have filed a number of affidavits of documents in response to the third parties' applications for further and better discovery. The third parties have challenged the plaintiffs' claims for litigation privilege and sought identification of particular policies and guidelines of the Ministry of Education on its website. The third parties also challenged whether the plaintiffs had been personally aware of their discovery obligations, had carried out adequate diligent searches and had fully complied with their discovery obligations. The court found that the plaintiffs had gone far beyond what they were required to disclose, but only because the third parties had pressed them to do so. The court also found that the plaintiffs had reasonably contemplated that there would be litigation over the water ingress problems at Rototuna Primary School from early 2010. The court accepted the plaintiffs' explanation for the lapse before they started this proceeding. The court found that the plaintiffs had complied with their discovery obligations and there was no basis for setting aside any of the redactions made by the plaintiffs. The court also found that it was not necessary to require the plaintiffs to produce any of the documents in issue for inspection or to file and serve any further affidavits by way of discovery. The court did not make any orders in favour of the third parties on their applications. The parties were invited to confer as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established