Messenger v Stanaway Real Estate Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-7205 [2014] NZHC 2090

BETWEEN

JAMES MESSENGER AND JUNE

MARY MESSENGER Plaintiffs

AND

STANAWAY REAL ESTATE LIMITED Defendant

GARY MESSENGER First Third Party

REALTY NZ LIMITED Second Third Party

SIMPSON WESTERN (AS A FIRM) Third Third Party

Hearing: 1 September 2014

Counsel:

RM Cederwell for Plaintiffs
KM Buckhart for Defendants
V Wethey for Third Third Party

Judgment:

1 September 2014

ORAL JUDGMENT OF FOGARTY J

Solicitors:           Lowndes Jordan, Auckland

Kennedys, Auckland

Jones Fee, Auckland

MESSENGER v STANAWAY REAL ESTATE LTD [2014] NZHC 2090 [1 September 2014]

[1]      This is a dispute which centres upon an agreement for sale and purchase of a luxury property.   The terms of the purchase included that the purchase price was

$5,995,000.    The  agreement  was  entered  into  on  or  about  30  November  or

1 December 2006.   The terms of the agreement also included the possession date would be on 18 December 2006. There was no settlement date specified.

[2]      On  18  December,  the  purchasers  were  to  be  paid  $2,750,000,  with  the balance  payable  by quarterly instalments  –  8  x  $61,875  followed  by  a  balloon payment of $2,750,000 on 18 December 2008.   The agreement also provided the vendors could lodge a caveat over the property prepared by the vendors at the purchasers’ expense.

[3]      There has been already quite a bit of litigation arising from this contract.  The original parties to the agreement have litigated this issue to the Court of Appeal.  The contract, it turns out, was essentially not performed at all and the property was resold at a loss.

[4]      In these proceedings now before the Court and a fixture is scheduled for 15

September, the plaintiffs are the original vendors.  The defendants are a real estate agency, Stanaway Real Estate Limited.  The son of the plaintiffs, Gary Messenger, was then joined as a first third party, together with the company he was working for, Realty NZ Limited.  Stanaway also joined Simpson Western,(a law firm) who had been acting for the vendors, as third third party.

[5]      The defendant’s claim against the third third party currently pleads, firstly, that  they were  the  solicitors  who  owed  a  duty  of  care,  which  I assume  is  not disputed.  The essential pleading is that Simpson Western breached its duty to the plaintiffs in exercising reasonable skill and care by failing to advise the plaintiffs that the settlement and possession date was 18 December 2006; that they failed to advise the plaintiffs to issue a settlement notice in January 2007, after the purchasers failed to make payment on 18 December 2006; and that if the terms of the settlement notice were not complied with, to cancel the agreement.  The claim pleads that Simpson Western advised the Messengers to pursue a costly claim in the High Court against the purchasers on the basis that the settlement date was 18 December 2008, rather

than advising them to cancel the agreement at any stage following 18 December

2006.

[6]      The case is set down…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Messenger v Stanaway Real Estate Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2090
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Messenger v Stanaway Real Estate Limited involves a complex dispute arising from the sale and purchase agreement of a luxury property. The plaintiffs, James and June Mary Messenger, sold their property to the purchasers through Stanaway Real Estate Limited. The agreement, dated around 30 November or 1 December 2006, stipulated a purchase price of $5,995,000, with possession to be transferred on 18 December 2006. The payment structure included an immediate payment of $2,750,000 on 18 December 2006, followed by eight quarterly installments of $61,875 and a balloon payment of $2,750,000 on 18 December 2008. The agreement also allowed the vendors to lodge a caveat over the property at the purchaser’s expense. The central issue in this case revolves around the interpretation and enforcement of the agreement, particularly concerning the settlement date and the role of the law firm, Simpson Western, in advising the plaintiffs.

The key legal issues before the court included whether the settlement date was indeed 18 December 2006, as the defendant claimed, and whether Simpson Western breached its duty by not advising the plaintiffs to cancel the agreement or issue a settlement notice when the purchasers failed to make the payment on 18 December 2006. The court had to determine whether the advice given by Simpson Western was negligent and if this negligence led to significant financial losses for the plaintiffs. The court also had to consider the procedural aspect of whether allowing the defendant to amend its statement of defence constituted a new theory of the case or if it was an extension of the existing issues.

The court's reasoning focused on the importance of ensuring a just trial by allowing all relevant arguments to be presented. Fogarty J held that the new particulars did not introduce a fundamentally new theory but rather addressed issues already in contention. The court emphasized the need to allow all available arguments to be heard, referencing the principle that parties should have every opportunity to ensure the real controversy is presented at trial. The judge also stressed the importance of preparing for the trial by having expert witnesses meet early to identify areas of agreement and disagreement. Ultimately, the court granted leave for the defendant to amend its statement of defence and set new deadlines for the exchange of expert briefs, emphasizing the need for a focused trial that addresses the core issues efficiently. The court reserved the decision on costs for the trial judge to determine at the hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.