Messenger v Stanaway Real Estate Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-007205 [2015] NZHC 1795

BETWEEN

JAMES MESSENGER and JUNE MARY

MESSENGER Plaintiffs

AND

STANAWAY REAL ESTATE LIMITED Defendant

AND

GARY MESSENGER First Third Party

REALTY NZ LIMITED Second Third Party

SIMPSON WESTERN Third Third Party

Hearing: 15 September - 3 October 2014 and 20 - 22 April 2015

Appearances:

G Blanchard and MHL Morrison for the Plaintiff
M Ring QC and K Burkhart for the Defendant
GB Lewis and LLC Cooney for First Third Party and Second
Third Party
P Fee and VS Wethey for the Third Third Party

Judgment:

31 July 2015

JUDGMENT OF WOOLFORD J

This judgment was delivered by me on Friday, 31 July 2015 at 3:30 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules 1985.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

……………………………………

MESSENGER & ANOR v STANAWAY REAL ESTATE LIMITED & ORS [2015] NZHC 1795 [31 July 2015]

INDEX

Paragraph

Introduction ..............................................................................................................[1]

Factual background .................................................................................................[4]

Issues .......................................................................................................................[25] Defendant........................................................................................................[25] First and Second Third Parties.......................................................................[25] Third Third Party ............................................................................................[25]

Terms of the agreement .........................................................................................[26] Stanaway’s duties ...................................................................................................[68] Casual connection to losses....................................................................................[93] Measure of damages.............................................................................................[100] Was there contributory negligence by Mr and Mrs Messenger?..................... [114] Claim by Stanaway against Gary Messenger and Realty NZ Limited ...........[127] Claim by Stanaway against Simpson Western ..................................................[136] Result .....................................................................................................................[164]

Introduction

[1]      In proceedings first filed on 30 November 2012, James Messenger and his wife, June Messenger (Mr and Mrs Messenger), claim that Stanaway Real Estate Limited (Stanaway), the real estate company which acted as their agent in the sale of a beachfront property at 29 Muritai Road, Milford, Auckland, (the property), was negligent in relation to a failed sale of the property in 2006 to John Goodman and Deborah Rattray.  They claim a total of $2.77 million for the loss on the resale of the property together with interest and legal costs.

[2]      Stanaway applied for orders joining Mr and  Mrs  Messengers’ son,  Gary Messenger,  as  first  third  party;  his  real  estate  company,  Realty NZ  Limited,  as second third party; and the law firm which acted for Mr and Mrs Messenger on the failed sale of the property in 2006, Simpson Western, as third third party.  Stanaway asserts that if they are liable to Mr and Mrs Messenger, then they are entitled to a contribution or indemnity from the third parties, who they say were also negligent.

The applications for joinder were granted on 22 November 2013.1

[3]      There have also been a number of other interlocutory applications which have prolonged the proceedings.  The trial itself commenced on 15 September 2014.  The evidence was completed on 3 October 2014, after three weeks of hearing time.  The proceedings were then adjourned for submissions, which took place over four days, on 20 - 22 and 24 April 2015.  The evidence and the submissions were both very extensive and  covered  every aspect  of the failed  sale and  all  conceivable legal arguments.   It is, however, not possible in this judgment to refer to every issue…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Messenger v Stanaway Real Estate Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1795
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the plaintiffs, James Messenger and June Messenger, claim against the defendant, Stanaway Real Estate Limited, for losses on the resale of a beachfront property. The plaintiffs claim a total of $2.77 million for the loss on the resale of the property together with interest and legal costs. The defendant applied for orders to join Mr and Mrs Messengers’ son, Gary Messenger; his real estate company, Realty NZ Limited; and the law firm which acted for Mr and Mrs Messenger on the failed sale of the property in 2006, Simpson Western, as third parties. The applications for joinder were granted. The main issues for determination were whether Stanaway breached its duties to the plaintiffs, whether the breaches were causative of the plaintiffs’ losses, the proper assessment of the plaintiffs’ losses, whether the plaintiffs were contributorily negligent, and whether the third parties owed any duties to the plaintiffs. The court held that Stanaway was liable for all the foreseeable consequences of its negligence. It was foreseeable that the market would fall, that Mr Goodman and Ms Rattray would place a caveat on the property, that Mr and Mrs Messenger would continue to incur interest costs, and finally, that litigation would ensue between Mr and Mrs Messenger and Ms Goodman and Ms Rattray. The court found that the losses claimed by the plaintiffs did flow from the breaches as pleaded against Stanaway. Had Stanaway not breached its duties, the plaintiffs would have instead sold the property later in 2006 or in 2007 at the market value prevailing at that time. In this way, they would have avoided the very significant fall in the market caused by the global financial crisis later in 2007 and the interest holding costs that they in fact experienced. The court found that the plaintiffs were contributorily negligent in failing to obtain legal advice. The court held that neither Gary Messenger or his company, Realty NZ Limited, owed a duty of care to the plaintiffs. The court held that Stanaway’s claim against Simpson Western was not made out. Judgment was given in favour of the plaintiffs against the defendant. The applications by the defendant for a contribution or indemnity against the third parties were dismissed. The sums claimed were reduced by 20 per cent to take account of the plaintiffs’ contributory negligence. The successful parties were entitled to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.