Melco Property Holdings (NZ) Limited v Hall

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2020-485-40

[2022] NZHC 2416

BETWEEN MELCO PROPERTY HOLDINGS (NZ) LIMITED
Plaintiff

AND

ANTHONY JOHN HALL

Defendant

Memoranda: Counsel for the Plaintiff – 2 September 2022 Counsel for the Defendant – 16 September 2022

Judgment:

20 September 2022


COSTS JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J


[1]                 A judgment I issued on 25 May 2022 in this proceeding related to a sale and purchase contract whereby the plaintiff purchased from the defendant a commercial property immediately neighbouring the plaintiff’s existing head office and showroom premises in Lower Hutt. At paragraphs 171 and 172 of that 25 May 2022 judgment, I reserved costs but noted that:

My preliminary view on costs, however, is that Melco, as the successful party here, should be entitled to costs from Mr Hall. Counsel and the parties are encouraged to liaise with a view to settling the issue of costs by agreement between them. In the event this is not achieved, then counsel may file memoranda on costs (sequentially) – with these memoranda to be no more than five pages each – and these are to be referred to me for a decision.

[2]                 The parties have been unable to settle costs between them. Counsel for the plaintiff has filed his costs memorandum dated 2 September 2022. Counsel for the defendant has filed his memorandum in response dated 16 September 2022. I now give my decision on this costs question.

MELCO PROPERTY HOLDINGS (NZ) LIMITED v ANTHONY JOHN HALL [2022] NZHC 2416 [20

September 2022]

[3]                 In his memorandum, counsel for the plaintiff seeks costs against the defendant here for costs in this proceeding of $82,903.13 representing category 2B scale costs, plus a 50 per cent uplift. In addition, disbursements totalling $23,224.03 are sought.

[4]                 In his reply memorandum as to costs, counsel for the defendant appears to agree and accept that the plaintiff as the successful party here should be entitled only to simple category 2B scale costs and the calculation by Mr Beck for the plaintiff of this amount at $55,268.75 is agreed. No uplift on scale costs, however, according to the defendant, is considered to be appropriate.

[5]                 So far as the plaintiff’s disbursements at $23,224.03 sought here are concerned, Mr Holloway for the defendant appears to accept also that this claim is in order.

[6]                 The issue before me therefore is whether the plaintiff acknowledged, as the successful party in this proceeding, should receive usual category 2B scale costs only at the figure of $55,268.75, or whether the additional 50% uplift sought by Mr Beck (totalling $27,634.38) should be awarded by way of increased costs as well.

[7]                 Increased costs are regulated by r 14.6(3) of the High Court Rules 2016. Rule 14.6(3) addressing increased costs and indemnity costs relevantly states here:

[3]    The court may order a party to pay increased costs if –

(a)    The nature of the proceeding or the step in it is such…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Melco Property Holdings (NZ) Limited v Hall and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 2416
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the plaintiff, Melco Property Holdings (NZ) Limited, sought to recover costs from the defendant, Anthony John Hall, for a proceeding related to a sale and purchase contract of a commercial property. The plaintiff had purchased the property from the defendant, which was located next to the plaintiff's existing head office and showroom premises in Lower Hutt. The plaintiff had initially sought an order for costs in the amount of $82,903.13, representing category 2B scale costs plus a 50 per cent uplift. The defendant, on the other hand, argued that the plaintiff should only be entitled to simple category 2B scale costs, which were calculated to be $55,268.75, and no uplift was appropriate. The central issue before the court was whether the plaintiff, as the successful party, should receive usual category 2B scale costs or if the additional 50 per cent uplift sought by the plaintiff should be awarded. The court concluded that the defendant's unreasonable rejection of the plaintiff's settlement offer, as well as the defendant's inconsistent, evasive, and contradictory evidence, justified the award of increased costs. The court found that the defendant had failed to act reasonably and had contributed to a significant increase in the time and expense incurred by the plaintiff. Consequently, the court awarded costs to the plaintiff in the amount of $82,903.13, representing category 2B scale costs plus a 50 per cent uplift, together with disbursements totalling $23,224.03. The total amount awarded to the plaintiff for costs and disbursements on this proceeding was therefore $106,127.16.

The court's decision was based on the defendant's unreasonable rejection of the plaintiff's settlement offer and his inconsistent and contradictory evidence. The court found that the defendant's actions had contributed to a significant increase in the time and expense incurred by the plaintiff. The court also noted that the defendant had failed to acknowledge any level of risk in the proceeding and had not engaged in a realistic effort to resolve the dispute. The court concluded that the award of increased costs was justified under the High Court Rules 2016, specifically rule 14.6(3)(b)(ii), (iii), and (v). The court further found that the 50 per cent uplift did not represent any over recovery of the plaintiff's actual costs for the proceeding, which were calculated to be $135,529 (plus GST and disbursements). The court awarded costs to the plaintiff in the amount of $82,903.13, representing category 2B scale costs plus a 50 per cent uplift, together with disbursements totalling $23,224.03. The total amount awarded to the plaintiff for costs and disbursements on this proceeding was therefore $106,127.16.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established