IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV-2010-404-7652
BETWEEN MCVEAGH FLEMING Plaintiff
ANDEMMA JANE GARNETT Defendant
Hearing: 22 June 2011
Appearances: Mr G Wadsworth for plaintiff
Ms Murray granted leave to withdraw
Judgment: 28 June 2011 at 4:00 PM
JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE J P DOOGUE
This judgment was delivered by me on
28 June 2011at 4 pm, pursuant to
Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.
Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Date……………
Solicitors:
Kennedys, P O Box 3158, Auckland : by email: g.wadsworth@kennedys-law.co.nz
Ms Davina Murray – Davinamurray@criminallaw.co.nz
MCVEAGH FLEMING V GARNETT HC AK CIV-2010-404-7652 28 June 2011
[1] This was an unopposed summary judgment application. The approach that I intend to take is that, notwithstanding that it was unopposed, it is necessary for me to be satisfied that there is no arguable defence available to the defendant.
[2] The defendant stole money while she was employed by the plaintiff. It is alleged that the defendant stole $188,673.80. She was prosecuted, tried and sentenced on those charges. No restitution was ever forthcoming.
[3] The plaintiff has now sued the defendant to recover various losses. The causes of action are breach of fiduciary duty, breach of contract and conversion. The plaintiff also seeks to recover what might be termed some indirect losses. The first is the internal time costs of $71,080.44 which was the cost of the time that was lost and which the plaintiff could have charged out at professional rates had members of the firm not been involved in investigating the defalcation, dealing with the Police and the Law Society and also the clients. $71,080.44 is claimed under this head.
[4] As well, the plaintiff seeks to recover accountant’s costs of $8,325. These were costs incurred by one of the clients, Rice Trusts Partnership, on their behalf and investigating their loss. The plaintiff, commendably, agreed to pay this amount without legal steps being taken against the defendant to recover it. Further, the plaintiff seeks amounts invoiced to it by a criminal barrister who it retained to observe the criminal proceedings, obtain name suppression and generally represents its interests in the sentencing process and on the matter of reparation. The plaintiff also seeks interest under the Judicature Act.
[5] There is no doubt that the defendant is subject to onerous obligations to meet the plaintiff’s losses. In Bank of New Zealand v Guardian Trust Company Limited Tipping J, in his separate judgment said this:[1]
[1] Bank of New Zealand v Guardian Trust Company Limited, 1999 [1 NZLR 664].
The approach of the law to the linked questions of causation and remoteness is influenced by the nature of the wrong which the defendant has committed. If it is a wrong engaging in a conscience of the wrongdoer, what has sometimes been called fraud in equity, a strict approach is justified. That corresponds with the position when there is fraud in the common law sense,
at least some of the more recent authorities are concerned. In such cases…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read McVeagh Fleming v Garnett HC Auckland CIV-2010-404-7652 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] NZHC 607
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the defendant had any arguable defence to the plaintiff's claims, and if not, whether the plaintiff was entitled to summary judgment on all or some of the claims. The court also needed to determine whether the defendant was liable for interest and the costs associated with the criminal proceedings.
In its judgment, the court found that the defendant had no credible or arguable defence to the plaintiff's claims. The court held that the losses incurred by the plaintiff were a direct result of the defendant's actions and therefore recoverable. The court found that the claim for internal time costs was not adequately proved in terms of quantum, but the claims for accountant's costs and the criminal barrister's fees were recoverable. The court also allowed the claim for interest as it was deemed an appropriate and sustainable claim under the Judicature Act. The court granted summary judgment for all claims except the internal time costs and ordered that the proceeding be adjourned for a mention to determine the plaintiff's intentions regarding the claim for loss of time.
In summary, the court granted summary judgment for the plaintiff on all claims except for the internal time costs, and ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff the amounts claimed, together with interest and costs on a 2B basis.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi