McNulty v McNulty HC Dunedin CIV 2010-412 000810

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV 2010-412 000810

IN THE MATTER OF     s 68 of the Trustee Act 1956

BETWEEN  AMBER LEE MCNULTY First Plaintiff

AND  CARL MICHAEL MCNULTY Second Plaintiff

AND  BRIAN FRANCIS MCNULTY First Defendant

AND  GCA LEGAL TRUSTEE 2008 LIMITED Second Defendant

AND  PETER AUSTIN GOWING Third Defendant

Hearing:         10 May 2011

(Heard at Dunedin)

Counsel:         D P Robinson and M Dalgleish for Defendants/Applicants

C Luke for Plaintiffs
T J Shiels for McNulty's Investment Ltd and McNulty's Transport

Limited (appearing but then excused) Judgment:  30 September 2011

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

as to defendants’ strike out and summary judgment applications

Introduction

[1]      In this proceeding, the plaintiffs attack a decision of the trustees of what is their grandfather’s family trust.  The decision involved appointing the trust’s major asset to Brian McNulty who was a trustee as well as a beneficiary.

[2]      The  various  defendants  have  applied  for  summary  judgment  against  the

plaintiffs or alternatively an order striking out the plaintiffs’ claims.

MCNULTY V MCNULTY HC DUN CIV 2010-412 000810 30 September 2011

The Trust and its history

[3]      Frank McNulty settled the McNulty Family Trust (“the Trust”) by deed dated

20 January 1995.  The trustees appointed were his solicitor (Evan Moore) and two accountants (Kenneth Fergus and Alexander Laing).   Frank McNulty and his wife were appointed advisory trustees.   Frank McNulty was given the power of appointment of any new trustee during his lifetime or by Will.  He was also given a power to remove trustees for any cause whatsoever and without giving reasons.

[4]      The Trust is a discretionary trust.

[5]      The beneficiaries included the settlor, settlor’s spouse, settlor’s children and remoter issue of those children, spouses of beneficiaries and any charity nominated by an advisory trustee.

[6]      Frank  McNulty  had  two  sons,  namely  Brian  and  Allan  McNulty.    The plaintiffs,   Carl   and   Amber   McNulty,   are   Allan’s   children   (and   Frank’s grandchildren).

[7]      Clause 4 of the Trust deed makes provision for income and capital payments in the following terms –

INCOME AND CAPITAL PAYMENTS The Trustees may at their discretion until the Vesting Day pay or apply the whole or any part of the capital and/or income for or towards  the personal support, maintenance, comfort, education or advancement in life or other benefit of any of the Beneficiaries  then  living  or  in  existence  during  the  trust  period  in  any manner, at any times, in any proportions and subject to any terms and conditions which the Trustees in their absolute discretion may decide.  Any income not paid  to or applied for any Beneficiary during, or within six months after, any income year shall be accumulated and added to the trust fund.

[8]      Clause 9 makes provision for final distribution in these terms –

FINAL DISTRIBUTION On Vesting Day the trust fund shall be divided equally among the Settlor’s Children then living but if any one or more of them has died before the Vesting Day leaving children or remoter issue then the children or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McNulty v McNulty HC Dunedin CIV 2010-412 000810 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1173
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the plaintiffs, Carl and Amber McNulty, challenged a decision made by the trustees of their grandfather's family trust. The decision involved appointing the trust's major asset to Brian McNulty, who was both a trustee and a beneficiary. The various defendants applied for summary judgment against the plaintiffs or, alternatively, an order striking out the plaintiffs' claims. The Court found that the first, second, and fourth causes of action were untenable and struck them out. However, the third cause of action, which alleged breach of duties, was considered arguable, and therefore, the application for summary judgment was dismissed. The Court also struck out the claim against Peter Austin Gowing, who was dismissed from the proceeding as a defendant. The Court reserved costs for later determination.