McKenzie v The Co-Operative Bank Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA787/2024
 [2025] NZCA 318

BETWEEN

ANGUS EDWARD MCKENZIE
Appellant

AND

THE CO-OPERATIVE BANK LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

15 May 2025

Court:

Thomas, Fitzgerald and Eaton JJ

Counsel:

Appellant in person
No appearance for Respondent

Judgment:

15 July 2025 at 11.00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

The appeal is dismissed.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Eaton J)

Introduction

  1. Angus McKenzie appeals the 27 November 2024 decision of Gwyn J striking out his claim against the respondent under r 5.35B of the High Court Rules 2016.[1]

Background

  1. On 20 November 2024, Mr McKenzie filed a statement of claim alongside a document entitled “Summery of Facts” in the High Court at Wellington.  The named defendant is The Co‑operative Bank Ltd (the Bank).  Although difficult to follow, there appear to be four causes of action pleaded.

  2. The first alleges that, since 2015, the Bank had been deceitful and misleading in its failure to provide proof of transactions in accordance with s 135 of the Banking (Prudential Supervision) Act 1989.

  3. The second alleges that, between 2021 and 2023, Mr McKenzie was scammed multiple times, leading to a six-figure depletion of his bank account.  It alleges the Bank failed to carry out wellness checks and failed to provide care and skill under the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993.

  4. The third alleges the Bank made misrepresentations “such as providing statements that show transactions being on the wrong day and providing another form of transaction history that has been inconsistent with printed statements”.  It alleges the Bank has lied in emails and voicemails and that Mr McKenzie has been contacted by “false aliases” representing the Bank.  This cause of action alleges breaches of the Fair Trading Act 1986.

  5. The fourth alleges the Bank has deceitfully provided fraudulent transaction logs in breach of the Crimes Act 1961.

  6. For each of the four causes of action, Mr McKenzie seeks relief in the sum of $466 million with reliance on either “the basis of The Sentencing Act 2002 Part 2” (for the first, third and fourth causes of action) or the Consumer Guarantees Act (for the second cause of action).  The relief sought is seemingly quantified as “roughly $1000 compensation for every $1” in respect of which Mr McKenzie has been “ripped off and gaslit”.

  7. The accompanying summary of facts is 14 pages, incorporating images of Mr McKenzie’s bank statements and screenshots of his bank account, and advances a narrative alleging deceit or fraud by the Bank.  The summary focuses particularly on the dates on which direct debits or payments were recorded as being deducted from Mr McKenzie’s bank account in what are said to be discrepancies reflecting a “fraudulent manipulation” of his account.  The summary refers to a notice to surrender shares held in the Bank as a result of his account having been closed.  Mr McKenzie appears to allege the Bank stole his closing balance…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McKenzie v The Co-Operative Bank Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZCA 318
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Angus McKenzie appeals the decision of Gwyn J to strike out his claim against The Co-Operative Bank Limited under r 5.35B of the High Court Rules 2016. The appeal was heard by Thomas, Fitzgerald and Eaton JJ in the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. McKenzie's claim alleges multiple causes of action, including deceit, failure to carry out wellness checks, misrepresentations, and fraudulent transaction logs, all against the Bank. The relief sought is a total of $466 million, based on various Acts, including the Sentencing Act 2002 and the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993. The appeal hinges on whether the original statement of claim was an abuse of the Court's process and whether the amended version sufficiently addresses these concerns.

The Court of Appeal considered whether McKenzie's claim was an abuse of process and whether it was manifestly unfair for the Bank to be required to respond. The appeal was assessed under a two-pronged test that requires consideration of whether it would be manifestly unfair to the respondent to be required to respond and whether it would be perceived by right thinking people as poor control of the Court’s processes. The amended statement of claim introduced some changes, such as numbering the causes of action and providing examples of alleged misrepresentations, but these did not address the fundamental issues with the original claim. The reliance on criminal legislation to support the civil claim and the unrealistic relief sought were central to the Court’s reasoning.

The Court found that the amended statement of claim did not remedy the fundamental issues with the original claim. The reliance on criminal legislation in a civil proceeding is impermissible, and the relief sought is disproportionate to the allegations. The Court upheld the Judge's decision, agreeing that the claim was an abuse of the Court's process and that it would not be reasonable to require the Bank to respond. The appeal was dismissed, and the Court's decision was affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 20 November 2024, Angus McKenzie filed a statement of claim against The Co-operative Bank Ltd (the Bank) in the High Court at Wellington. The claim, which was accompanied by a 14-page "Summary of Facts," consists of four causes of action. The first alleges that since 2015, the Bank failed to provide proof of transactions in accordance with the Banking (Prudential Supervision) Act 1989. The second alleges that between 2021 and 2023, Mr McKenzie was scammed multiple times, leading to a six-figure depletion of his bank account, and that the Bank failed to carry out wellness checks and did not provide care and skill under the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993. The third cause of action alleges that the Bank made misrepresentations and provided inconsistent transaction histories, and that the Bank lied in emails and voicemails, in breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986. The fourth cause of action alleges that the Bank deceitfully provided fraudulent transaction logs in breach of the Crimes Act 1961. For each cause of action, Mr McKenzie seeks relief in the sum of $466 million. The accompanying summary of facts incorporates images of Mr McKenzie's bank statements and screenshots of his bank account, and advances a narrative alleging deceit or fraud by the Bank.

The High Court at Wellington struck out Mr McKenzie's claim under rule 5.35B of the High Court Rules 2016 on 27 November 2024. Mr McKenzie appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, which heard the appeal on 15 May 2025. The appeal was dismissed on 15 July 2025.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the amended statement of claim sufficiently addresses the concerns raised by the High Court regarding the abuse of process.
2. Whether Mr McKenzie can allege criminal offending and rely on criminal legislation in the context of civil proceedings.
3. Whether the claim under the Consumer Guarantees Act and the Fair Trading Act is viable.

Held
1. The Court found that the amended statement of claim did not sufficiently address the concerns raised by the High Court regarding the abuse of process. The appeal against the striking out of the claim was dismissed.
2. The Court held that Mr McKenzie cannot allege criminal offending and rely on criminal legislation in the context of civil proceedings. The attempt to do so was deemed an abuse of the court's process.
3. The Court concluded that the claim under the Consumer Guarantees Act and the Fair Trading Act was not viable and that it would not be reasonable to require the Bank to respond to such broad and overlapping allegations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court began by outlining the legal principles governing the striking out of proceedings under r 5.35B of the High Court Rules 2016. It emphasised the need to balance the right to bring proceedings against the public and private interests in preventing abuse of court processes. The Court identified a two-limbed test to determine whether a proceeding is an abuse of process, requiring consideration of manifest unfairness to the respondent and whether the court's processes would be poorly controlled if the matter proceeded.

Turning to the amendments made to the statement of claim, the Court noted that while some changes were made to clarify the causes of action, these did not address the fundamental issues. Specifically, the reliance on sections of the Banking (Prudential Supervision) Act and the Crimes Act was misconceived. The Court explained that these provisions do not support Mr McKenzie’s allegations and do not identify a viable claim against the Bank.

Regarding the allegation of criminal offending, the Court firmly rejected Mr McKenzie’s attempt to rely on criminal legislation within a civil proceeding. It clarified that the Crimes Act does not provide a foundation for civil claims, and the Criminal Procedure Act governs the initiation of criminal proceedings. The Court also noted the misapplication of the Sentencing Act, stating that reparation under the Act can only follow a conviction and is not available in civil proceedings.

Lastly, the Court addressed the claims under the Consumer Guarantees Act and the Fair Trading Act. It found that the broad nature of the allegations, particularly the seeking of $466 million in damages, did not constitute a viable cause of action. The Court concluded that the allegations were not such that the Bank should be required to respond, balancing Mr McKenzie’s right to litigate against the broader public and private interests in preventing abuse of court processes.

In summary, the Court held that the amended statement of claim still represented an abuse of process and did not plead a cause of action that the Bank could reasonably respond to. The appeal was dismissed, affirming the High Court’s decision.