McKean v McKean Family Trustee Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE PAPAIOEA ROHE

CIV-2022-454-21

[2024] NZHC 3927

BETWEEN JANET ANNE ABIGAIL MCKEAN and JOHN DUGALD STEWART MCKEAN
Plaintiffs

AND

MCKEAN FAMILY TRUSTEE LIMITED

First Defendant

IAN MACGREGOR STEWART MCKEAN

Second Defendant

CIV-2022-454-71

BETWEEN

MCKEAN FAMILY TRUSTEE LIMITED
Applicant

AND

JANET ANNE ABIGAIL MCKEAN and JOHN DUGALD STEWART MCKEAN

Respondents

Hearing: 9 December 2024

Appearances:

L McKeown for Janet McKean and John McKean V Bruton KC for McKean Family Trustee Ltd

B Murfitt for Ian McKean
S Campbell for Torwood Trustees Ltd

Judgment:

20 December 2024


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SKELTON


[1]                 These proceedings concern the Torwood Family Trust (the Trust). The main assets of the Trust are a farm property and other non-contiguous blocks of land in Rangiwahia together valued at approximately $3.5 million. The proceedings are set

MCKEAN v MCKEAN FAMILY TRUSTEE LIMITED [2024] NZHC 3927 [20 December 2024]

down to be heard together over seven days from 10 February 2025. The proceedings are:

(a)   CIV-2022-454-21 (Removal Proceeding): Janet and John McKean allege misconduct and breaches of duty against McKean Family Trustee Ltd (MFTL) (in its capacity as former trustee of the Trust) and its sole director and shareholder Ian McKean (Ian), and seek various remedies including orders that Ian and MFTL must on a joint and several basis pay Janet and John’s costs of the removal application and reimburse the Trust for costs charged to the Trust fund in the sum of $207,608.75;1

(b)   CIV-2022-454-71 (Directions Proceeding): The new trustee of the Trust, Torwood Trustees Ltd (TTL), seeks directions from the Court as to the sale of farm and the other blocks of land and distribution to beneficiaries, and also seeks the Court’s blessing to issue a statutory demand against MFTL for repayment of the sum of $207,608.75.2

[2]                 The requirement for MFTL to repay the sum of $207,608.75 to the Trust arises from the judgment of Churchman J dated 10 May 2023 (costs judgment).3 At the same time that MFTL commenced the directions proceeding on 13 September 2022, it applied for authorisation that its litigation costs for both proceedings be paid from the Trust’s funds. Justice Churchman found that MFTL was not entitled to a pre-emptive indemnity for its costs on the basis that both proceedings are hostile, and the costs incurred by MFTL were unreasonable or otherwise not properly incurred.4 However, Churchman J found that MFTL should be indemnified for 30% of its costs as costs properly incurred in the administration of the Trust. MFTL was ordered to reimburse


1      Torwood Trustee Ltd (TTL) was appointed trustee of the Trust, replacing MFTL, pursuant to consent orders in the Removal Proceeding (Minute of La Hood J dated 2 November 2023).

2      The Directions Proceeding was commenced by MFTL. TTL was substituted as plaintiff in the Directions Proceeding pursuant to consent orders in the Directions Proceeding and has filed an amended statement of claim. There was also a consent order that MFTL…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McKean v McKean Family Trustee Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 3927
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerns proceedings between Janet and John McKean and McKean Family Trustee Ltd (MFTL) in relation to the Torwood Family Trust. The Trust owns a farm property and other non-contiguous land in Rangiwahia, valued at around $3.5 million. The proceedings involve allegations of misconduct and breaches of duty against MFTL and its sole director and shareholder Ian McKean, and seek various remedies including orders for MFTL to pay costs and reimburse the Trust for costs charged to the Trust fund. Torwood Trustees Ltd (TTL) has been appointed as the new trustee of the Trust and seeks directions from the Court regarding the sale of the farm and other blocks of land and distribution to beneficiaries. TTL also seeks the Court's approval to issue a statutory demand against MFTL for repayment of $207,608.75. MFTL has an obligation to repay this amount to the Trust but is yet to do so and has claimed it is unable to comply as it does not have the funds to pay the order, unless and until it is able to enforce its indemnity. TTL seeks to enforce the 2023 costs judgment as an interlocutory order under r 7.48 of the High Court Rules 2016. TTL seeks an order that, unless MFTL reimburses the outstanding costs within 10 working days, it is debarred from participating in the proceedings. Janet and John support the enforcement application and the proposed order. MFTL and Ian oppose the application. The court found that the proposed order would prevent MFTL from defending itself against the serious allegations of misconduct and breach of duty levelled against it, and from pursuing its affirmative defence/counterclaim for an indemnity, and its counterclaim for reimbursement for work undertaken by Ian. The court found that the irretrievable prejudice to MFTL of being debarred from defending itself including pursuing an indemnity outweighs the prejudice currently suffered by TTL, the Trust and the beneficiaries. The court dismissed TTL’s interlocutory application for orders that MFTL is debarred from participating further in the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established