IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE PAPAIOEA ROHE
CIV-2022-454-71
CIV-2022-454-21 [2023] NZHC 482
BETWEEN MCKEAN FAMILY TRUSTEE LIMITED
Plaintiff
AND
JANET ANNE MCKEAN JOHN DUGALD MCKEAN
Defendants
Hearing: 9 March 2023 Counsel:
V D Bruton KC and D I Durovich for Plaintiff L McKeown and A A Sawant for Defendants
Judgment:
13 March 2023
INTERIM JUDGMENT OF CHURCHMAN J
The application
[1] On 13 September 2022, McKean Family Trustee Limited (MFTL) (the plaintiff) applied for authorisation that its litigation costs be paid from the Trust’s funds. The application related to two separate sets of proceedings, these proceedings, CIV-2022-454-71 and proceedings in CIV-2022-454-021 (the removal proceedings).
[2] The plaintiffs in the removal proceedings, which had been commenced on 19 April 2022, were Janet McKean (Janet) and John McKean (John). The defendants in those proceedings were MFTL (first defendant), and Ian McKean (Ian) (second defendant).
[3] The plaintiff sought to cast its role in both sets of proceedings as simply acting in the management and administration of the Torwood Family Trust (the Trust) and
MCKEAN FAMILY TRUSTEE LIMITED v MCKEAN [2023] NZHC 482 [13 March 2023]
doing no more than providing information to assist the Court and abiding the decision of the Court in respect of the removal proceedings.
[4] The application acknowledged the possibility that the removal proceedings could arguably be categorised as hostile litigation and said that for that reason, Ian was separately represented in those proceedings funding his representation at his own cost.
[5] The application also contended that there were “sufficient funds” in the Trust’s bank account for the legal costs to be deducted.
[6] Although not in form a Beddoes application, in substance it had many of the same features.
[7]The application is opposed by Janet and John.
[8] At the conclusion of the hearing on 9 March 2023, I adjourned these proceedings and made directions as to the filing of further evidence.
[9] This interim decision records those directions. However, before setting the directions out I will briefly cover some of the background.
The Trust
[10] On 10 December 2013, the late Flora Marion McKean (Flora) established the Torwood Family Trust (the Trust). The sole trustee of the Trust was the MTFL. Ian was the sole shareholder in and director of MTFL.
[11] The Trust Deed provided for the role of “protector” of the Trust. Flora was the initial protector and on her death the deed provided that the protectors would be John, Janet and Ian. The protectors hold the power of appointment and removal of the trustee.
[12] Flora’s purpose in establishing the Trust was to ensure that the farm which had been owned by the family since 1893 remained as a long-term asset for the family.
The beneficiaries
[13] The Trust Deed provided for both primary and secondary beneficiaries. There were three classes of primary beneficiary. Flora was the principal beneficiary; but the Class B primary beneficiaries were John, Ian, Janet and Stewart…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read McKean Family Trustee Limited v McKean and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NZHC 482
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court also had to determine whether the proceedings were necessary and reasonable. The court noted that the proceedings were of a hostile nature, and in such cases, costs normally follow the outcome. The court also had to determine whether the costs were reasonable. The court noted that it was impossible to establish whether the costs were reasonable based on the information provided.
The court directed the plaintiff to file detailed information explaining what the claimed costs related to and to provide an estimate of future legal costs. The court also directed the parties to consider whether, by consent memorandum, an order can now be made declaring the Trust valid. The court further encouraged the parties to consider whether a judicial settlement conference would be of assistance.
The court noted that the cost of the anticipated litigation would essentially exhaust the entire cash reserves of the Trust, and it was concerned that this would necessitate the sale of the farm. The court's directions were aimed at ensuring that the Trust's assets were not depleted by the litigation costs and that the parties considered alternative dispute resolution methods to avoid further litigation.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi