McGuire v Wellington Standards Committee (no 1)

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA26/2015
[2015] NZCA 163

BETWEEN

JEREMY JAMES MCGUIRE
Appellant

AND

WELLINGTON STANDARDS COMMITTEE (NO 1)
First Respondent

THE LAWYERS AND CONVEYANCERS DISCIPLINARY TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

Counsel:

Appellant in person
T J Mackenzie for First Respondent
P J Gunn and M McKillop for Second Respondent

Judgment:

(On the papers)

12 May 2015 at 3.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF COOPER J
[Review of Registrar’s decision]

AThe application for a review of the Registrar’s decision is dismissed.

BSecurity for costs in the sum of $5,880 must be paid by Wednesday 3 June 2015.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

  1. By letter dated 9 April 2015, Mr McGuire has sought a review of the Registrar’s decision not to waive some or all of the security for costs payable on his appeal.

  2. The appeal was filed on 21 January 2015 and relates to a decision of Mallon J in the High Court delivered on 2 December 2014.[1]

  3. Security for costs was fixed by the Registrar pursuant to r 35 of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005 (the Rules), in the sum of $5,880.  Mr McGuire was advised of that in a letter dated 22 January 2015, which also advised that under r 35(7) any application for an order under r 35(6) needed to be made within 20 working days of the filing of the notice of appeal.

  4. Mr McGuire applied for security to be dispensed with or reduced in a letter dated 12 March 2015.  In his letter he noted that he was a sole practitioner with a modest practice in Palmerston North, that fees had been waived in the High Court and that he would find it “very difficult to pay security for costs of $5,800 [sic] in all of the circumstances.”

  5. The Registrar advised the respondent of the applicant’s letter.  Wynn Williams, acting for the respondent, opposed Mr McGuire’s application in a letter dated 19 March.

  6. On 7 April 2015 the Registrar wrote to Mr McGuire.  Her letter quoted r 35(6) and (7) of the Rules, noting that the requirement of the latter is that an application to reduce or dispense with security must be made and served within 20 working days after the notice of appeal has been filed.  She pointed out that since the appeal had been filed on 21 January 2015, an application under r 35(6) should have been made by 19 February 2015.  It was not in fact received until 16 March 2015, almost a month outside the time stipulated by the rule.  She said that since the application was out of time, she had no discretion to accept or consider it.

  7. The Registrar’s approach was in accordance with the decision of this Court in Orlov v The National Standards Committee No 1.[2]  In that case, Wild J confirmed the mandatory nature of the requirement that such an application be filed within 20 working days. Because in that case the application had…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McGuire v Wellington Standards Committee (no 1) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZCA 163
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand considered an application for review of a Registrar's decision in the matter of McGuire v Wellington Standards Committee (No 1). Jeremy James McGuire, the appellant, sought a review of the Registrar's decision not to waive or reduce the security for costs payable on his appeal. The appeal was against a decision of Mallon J in the High Court, which was delivered on 2 December 2014. The appeal was filed on 21 January 2015, and the security for costs was fixed at $5,880 by the Registrar under rule 35 of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005. Mr McGuire applied for the security to be dispensed with or reduced in a letter dated 12 March 2015, citing his financial situation and modest practice. The Registrar declined to consider the application as it was made outside the 20 working-day period stipulated by the rule.

The legal issues the court had to decide included whether the application to reduce or dispense with security for costs was timely and whether the appellant had provided sufficient evidence of his financial position. The court noted that Mr McGuire's application was submitted almost a month after the deadline, and there was no basis to depart from the strict compliance with the rules. Additionally, the court highlighted that the application was not accompanied by satisfactory information regarding the appellant's financial standing. The court further added that, had it been necessary to reach the issue, it would not have been persuaded that the appeal was one that a solvent appellant would reasonably wish to prosecute.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the application for a review of the Registrar's decision, confirming that Mr McGuire must provide security for costs in the sum of $5,880. The time for payment of security was extended to Wednesday 3 June 2015, and Mr McGuire was directed to make the payment by that date. The court did not grant Mr McGuire's request to enlarge the time for paying security to within three working days of the hearing date, as it would have been contrary to the purpose of the requirement for security.

Background

Background to the litigation

Jeremy James McGuire, the appellant, filed an appeal on 21 January 2015 against a decision made by Mallon J in the High Court on 2 December 2014. The appeal is against the Wellington Standards Committee (No 1) as the first respondent and the Lawyers and Conveyancers Disciplinary Tribunal as the second respondent. Security for costs was fixed by the Registrar in the sum of $5,880. McGuire, a sole practitioner with a modest practice in Palmerston North, applied for the security to be dispensed with or reduced on 12 March 2015, citing his modest practice and difficulty in paying the amount. The Registrar declined the application on 7 April 2015 as it was made outside the 20 working days stipulated by rule 35(7) of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005.

The case was brought before the Court of Appeal of New Zealand as an appeal against the decision of Mallon J in the High Court. On 21 January 2015, McGuire filed an appeal relating to the decision delivered on 2 December 2014. The appeal was heard on the papers, and judgment was delivered on 12 May 2015. McGuire sought a review of the Registrar's decision not to waive some or all of the security for costs payable on his appeal by letter dated 9 April 2015. The Registrar had previously declined the application for reduction or waiver of security on 7 April 2015, finding it was made outside the 20 working days stipulated by rule 35(7) of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the application for a review of the Registrar's decision not to waive some or all of the security for costs payable on the appeal should be successful.
2. Whether the time for payment of security for costs should be enlarged to within three working days of the date of the hearing.

Held
1. The application for a review of the Registrar's decision not to waive some or all of the security for costs payable on the appeal is dismissed.
2. The time for payment of security for costs is enlarged to within three working days of the date of the hearing, specifically to Wednesday 3 June 2015.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered Mr. McGuire's application to review the Registrar's decision on the security for costs. The appeal in question was filed on 21 January 2015, and the Registrar fixed the security for costs at $5,880, a decision made in accordance with Rule 35 of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005. Mr. McGuire's application for a waiver or reduction of security was submitted on 12 March 2015, which was outside the 20 working days stipulated by Rule 35(7). The Registrar correctly noted the mandatory nature of the time requirement and declined to consider the application, following the Court's decision in Orlov v The National Standards Committee No 1, where Wild J confirmed the strict adherence to the time limit for such applications.

Further, the Court found that Mr. McGuire's application lacked satisfactory information regarding his financial position, particularly as it did not address his income for the relevant period. Additionally, the Court was not persuaded that the appeal met the criteria for a solvent appellant to reasonably wish to prosecute, as outlined in Reekie v Attorney-General. Consequently, the Court upheld the Registrar's decision, confirming that Mr. McGuire must pay the security for costs in the specified sum.

Although Mr. McGuire requested an extension for payment of the security to within three working days of the hearing date, the Court refused this request as it would undermine the purpose of requiring security. However, the Court did extend the payment deadline to Wednesday 3 June 2015. This decision aligns with the principle that security for costs serves to protect respondents from incurring costs without the assurance of payment, while also considering the practicalities of the appellant's financial situation within reasonable bounds.