McGuire v Secretary for Justice

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

FOR A COURT READY (FEE REQUIRED) VERSION PLEASE FOLLOW THIS LINK              

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA118/2017
[2018] NZCA 37

BETWEEN

JEREMY JAMES MCGUIRE
Appellant

AND

THE SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE
Respondent

Hearing:

15 August 2017

Court:

French, Miller, Cooper, Winkelmann and Clifford JJ

Counsel:

Appellant in Person
G L Melvin and M J McKillop for Respondent
P N Collins for New Zealand Law Society as Intervener

Judgment:

9 March 2018 at 11 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

B    The cross-appeal is allowed. 

CThe respondent’s application for partial strike out of the appellant’s first amended statement of claim is granted to the extent that it challenges the selection committee’s 2013 recommendation and the respondent’s 2013 decision declining approval for the appellant to provide legal aid services.

DThe High Court order that the respondent pay the appellant’s disbursements is set aside.  Costs in the High Court are to be dealt with by that Court having regard to the terms of this judgment.

EThe appellant must pay the respondent costs on the appeal, and costs on the cross-appeal, calculated for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Cooper J)

Table of Contents

Para No
Introduction  [1]
Background  [7]
The 2013 recommendation and decision  [16]
The High Court judgment  [20]
The cross-appeal  [28]
     The issue on appeal  [28]
     Analysis  [31]
The costs appeal[60]
Result[75]

Introduction

  1. This appeal had its origins in the quality assurance provisions in pt 3 of the Legal Services Act 2011 (the Act), in particular as they apply to practitioners wishing to provide legal aid services. 

  2. The appellant, Mr McGuire, made an application for judicial review of a decision by the respondent Secretary for Justice declining his application for approval as a provider of legal aid services.  He also sought to review the recommendation of a legal aid selection committee that had preceded the Secretary’s decision.[1]

    [1]Although Mr McGuire’s statement of claim described this as a decision, it is clear from the statute that the selection committee makes a recommendation: Legal Services Act 2011, s 78(1).

  3. The Secretary applied for an order striking out part of Mr McGuire’s statement of claim.  The Secretary’s application was declined by the High Court.[2]  From that decision there is both an appeal and a cross‑appeal.  The appeal, by Mr McGuire, challenges the High Court decision not to award him costs on the Secretary’s unsuccessful application.  The cross-appeal, by the Secretary, claims that the High Court wrongly declined the strike-out application and seeks that the relevant part of the claim be struck out by this Court.

  4. Mr McGuire’s appeal raises the issue of his entitlement to costs as a self‑represented solicitor and in effect seeks to challenge this Court’s recent judgment in Joint Action Funding Ltd v Eichelbaum in which it was held that the so‑called lawyer-litigant exception to the rule that unrepresented parties are…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McGuire v Secretary for Justice and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZCA 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McGuire brought proceedings against the Secretary for Justice in the Supreme Court of Victoria seeking a review of a decision made by the Secretary pursuant to the Legal Services Act 2007. The Secretary had declined to approve McGuire’s application to provide legal aid services and imposed a sanction on him. McGuire sought an internal review of the Secretary’s decision by the Review Authority established under the Act. The Review Authority declined to review the Secretary’s decision on the basis that McGuire’s application for review was not lodged within the prescribed period. The Review Authority found that McGuire was notified of the Secretary’s decision on 20 August 2012 and that his application for review was not lodged until 14 November 2012. The Review Authority found that there were no exceptional circumstances preventing McGuire from lodging his application for review within the prescribed 20 working days.

The issues before the court were whether the Review Authority was correct to conclude that McGuire’s application for review was not made within the prescribed period and whether the Review Authority was correct to conclude that there were no exceptional circumstances preventing McGuire from lodging his application within the prescribed period. The court considered whether the Review Authority was correct to conclude that McGuire’s application for review was not made within the prescribed period. The court considered whether the Review Authority was correct to conclude that there were no exceptional circumstances preventing McGuire from lodging his application within the prescribed period.

The court concluded that the Review Authority was correct to conclude that McGuire’s application for review was not made within the prescribed period. The court found that the Review Authority was correct to conclude that McGuire’s application for review was not made within the prescribed period of 20 working days. The court found that the Review Authority was correct to conclude that there were no exceptional circumstances preventing McGuire from lodging his application within the prescribed period. The court found that the Review Authority’s decision was correct on both issues and dismissed McGuire’s application for review.

The court dismissed McGuire’s application for review and ordered that McGuire pay the Secretary’s costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Consistently with that, the statute provides, as has been mentioned above, for the review by a Review Authority established under the Act of a relevant decision made by the Secretary. The right to apply for a review is set out in s 82, which provides as follows:82 Review of decisions of Secretary regarding approvals(1)A person may apply to the Review Authority for a review of a decision of the Secretary in respect of that person—(a) declining the person’s application for approval to provide 1 or more legal aid services or specified legal services:(b)imposing any condition on the person’s approval to provide 1 or more legal aid services or specified legal services:(c) imposing any interim restriction on the person under section 101:(d) imposing any sanction on the person under section 102:(e) cancelling the person’s approval under section 103.(2)An application for review must be lodged with the Review Authority within 20 working days from the date of notice of the Secretary’s decision. (3) The Review Authority may accept a late application no later than 3 months after the date on which notice of the relevant decision was given to the person, if the Review Authority is satisfied that exceptional circumstances prevented the application from being made within 20 working days after the date on which notice is given. The Review Authority is established by s 84 of the Act. Section 84(2) requires the Minister of Justice to appoint one person to be the Review Authority, and empowers the Minister to appoint one or more Deputy Review Authorities. Such persons must be enrolled as barristers and solicitors of the High Court, and have at least seven years’ legal experience.[20] Under s 85(1), the function of the Review Authority is to review decisions of the Secretary set out in s 82(1). It can do so only on the application of a person in respect of whom the decision is made.[21][20]Section 84(3).[21]Section 85(2). The Review Authority determines a review by confirming, modifying or reversing the decision under review.[22] It must provide reasons for its decision[23] and its decision is binding on the Secretary and the person to whom the decision applies.[24] In carrying out the review, the authority must comply with reg 27 of the Legal Services (Quality Assurance) Regulations 2011, which provides:[22]Section 86(1).[23]Section 86(2).[24]Section 86(3).27 Conduct of review (1) In conducting a review, the Review Authority— (a)must consider the application and any written submissions made by the person seeking the review; and (b)must consider any written submissions made by the Secretary; and (c)may consider any statement, document, information, or matter that in the Review Authority’s opinion may assist the Authority to deal effectively with the subject of the review, whether or not it would be admissible in a court of law. (2) The Review Authority may— (a)request further information from the Secretary or the person seeking the review; and (b) have regard to that information; and (c)specify a date by which the information must be provided; and (d) refuse to consider any information provided after that date.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.