McGrath v Minister of Justice

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

ORDER PROHIBITING PUBLICATION OF NAME(S), ADDRESS(ES), OCCUPATION(S) OR IDENTIFYING PARTICULARS OF VICTIM(S) OR COMPLAINANT(S) LOCATED IN NEW ZEALAND OR AUSTRALIA. SUPPRESSION ORDERS MADE BY THE DISTRICT COURT REMAIN IN PLACE, PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THAT COURT

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2014-409-580 [2014] NZHC 3279

BETWEEN

BERNARD KEVIN MCGRATH

Plaintiff

AND

THE MINISTER OF JUSTICE Defendant

Hearing: 1 December 2014

Appearances:

P N Allan for Plaintiff
M J Lillico and C J Hurd for Defendant

Judgment:

17 December 2014

JUDGMENT OF MANDER J

[1]      The  Commonwealth  of  Australia  seeks  the  extradition  of  the  plaintiff, Mr Bernard McGrath, to face trial on 250 charges of sexual offending.  The offences are alleged to have been committed against 35 complainants whilst Mr McGrath was employed […] in Australia, between 1977 and 1986.   The complaints were made between 2001 and 2007.  Mr McGrath is a New Zealand citizen.

[2]      Requests  by  Australia  for  extradition  are  governed  by  Part  4  of  the Extradition Act 1999 (the Act).  Broadly, this part of the Act provides for a simplified extradition procedure, reflecting the high degree of comity between New Zealand

and Australia.1   Part 4 is designed to provide a streamlined procedure for extradition,

1      Countries must be designated by Order in Council: Extradition Act 1999, s 40.  See for example the Extradition (United Kingdom and Pitcairn Islands) Order 2003 which brings within the rubric of Part 4 the “United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland” and the “British Overseas Territory of the Pitcairn, Henderson, Ducie and Oeno Islands”.

MCGRATH v THE MINISTER OF JUSTICE [2014] NZHC 3279 [17 December 2014]

whereby a person will be eligible for surrender if a warrant for the arrest of the person issued in a designated country complies with the requirements of the Act.  If the Court is satisfied that the person is an extraditable person in relation to the extradition  country and  the  offence  is  an  extradition  offence  in  relation  to  that extradition country, the person is eligible for surrender.2

Procedural background

[3]      In November 2012, Judge Farish endorsed the Australian warrants for the arrest of Mr McGrath, and in June the following year found Mr McGrath eligible for surrender under s 45 of the Act.3   In September 2013, the matter was referred back to the District Court as a result of an appeal by Mr McGrath regarding Judge Farish’s assessment of her discretion under s 48(4) to refer the case to the Minister of Justice (the Minister) because of compelling or extraordinary circumstances relating to the affected person.4    Whata J was concerned that Judge Farish may have unduly restricted her analysis of Mr McGrath’s personal circumstances by reference to the Australian judicial system.5

[4]      In April 2014, Judge Farish delivered her decision regarding the issue of whether Mr McGrath’s case should be referred to the Minister.6    It appeared to the District Court that because there were compelling or extraordinary circumstances it would be unjust or oppressive to surrender Mr McGrath, and she exercised her discretion…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McGrath v Minister of Justice and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 3279
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In McGrath v Minister of Justice, the Court was required to consider the validity of the Minister’s decision to surrender Mr McGrath to the Commonwealth of Australia. Mr McGrath, a New Zealand citizen, was subject to extradition proceedings on 250 charges of sexual offending allegedly committed against 35 complainants in Australia between 1977 and 1986. The complaints were made between 2001 and 2007. The Court’s task was to examine whether the Minister’s decision was unreasonable, whether there were material errors of fact, whether the Minister breached the principles of natural justice, and whether there was an appearance of bias.

The Court found no evidence of actual bias or apparent bias on the part of the Minister. It concluded that the Minister was entitled to consider the principle of comity and the fact that the Australian system is equipped to examine the issues raised by Mr McGrath. The Court also found no material errors of fact, noting that the Minister was entitled to conclude that Australia would make adequate provision for state-funded legal assistance and the recognition by its Courts of the centrality of the right to counsel in criminal trials. The Court found that the Minister’s decision was not unreasonable, as the Minister had considered the factors put forward by Mr McGrath and concluded that they did not give rise to compelling or extraordinary circumstances that would make it unjust or oppressive to surrender him to Australia.

The Court therefore declined the application for review, concluding that the Minister made no reviewable error in making her decision that Mr McGrath be surrendered to the Commonwealth of Australia. The application for review is declined.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established