McDonald v Stanley HC Auckland CIV-2011-404-2623

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2011-404-2623

UNDER  the Weathertight Homes Resolution

Services Act 2006

BETWEEN  DARYN PETER MCDONALD Appellant

ANDLUCY NORMA STANLEY AND MELONIE JANE STANLEY Respondents

Hearing:         19 August 2011

Counsel:         J P Scott for Appellant

D J Powell for Respondents

Judgment:      19 August 2011 at 3:00 PM

JUDGMENT OF POTTER J

n application for stay

In accordance with r 11.5 High Court Rules

I direct the Registrar to endorse this judgment

with a delivery time of 3 p.m. on 19 August 2011.

Solicitors:           Martell McKegg, Auckland –  jps@martellimckegg.co.nz

Grimshaw & Co, Auckland – david.powell@grimshaw.co.nz

MCDONALD V STANLEY AND STANLEY HC AK CIV-2011-404-2623 19 August 2011

Introduction

[1]      The appellant has appealed a decision of the Weathertight Homes Tribunal (“the Tribunal”)1  (“the decision”) which  gave judgment against  the appellant in favour of the respondents for the sum of $332,897.  The notice of appeal was filed on 27 April 2011.

[2]      By application dated 28 April 2011 the appellant applied to stay enforcement of the Tribunal’s order pending hearing and determination of the appeal.   The respondents oppose the granting of a stay.

[3]      I heard submissions from the parties on 3 August 2011 and issued a minute on that date in which I adjourned the appellant’s application for stay until 18 August

2011 and directed that the appellant address the provision of security in the vicinity of the sum of $250,000.

[4]      The appellant advised by memorandum of counsel dated 18 August 2011 that he has insufficient funds and assets to offer the security indicated by the Court.

[5]      I resumed the adjourned hearing of the application for stay in a telephone conference with counsel today.   Mr Scott for the appellant confirmed that the appellant pursues his application for stay.  Mr Powell for the respondents confirmed that the respondents maintain their opposition to the application.

Decision

[6]      I have determined that the application for stay should be granted.  I advised counsel of this decision in the course of the telephone conference today.

1   Stanley v North Shore City Council [2011] NZWHT Auckland 20, 31 March 2011.

[7]      The brief reasons for my decision follow.

[8]      It is common ground that in considering an application for stay pursuant to r

20.10 of the High Court Rules the relevant factors for the Court to consider in the exercise of its discretion are those set out in Duncan v Osborne Buildings Ltd2  and Dymocks Franchise Systems (NSW) Pty Ltd v Bilgola Enterprises Ltd.3    The Court must balance the right of the successful litigant to have the fruits of a judgment and the need to preserve the position in case the appeal is successful:

1.       If no stay is granted will the applicant’s right of an appeal be rendered

nugatory?

[9]      The respondents have issued and served on the appellant a bankruptcy notice dated 21 April 2011 in CIV-2011-404-002387.   Mr Powell advised at the hearing that the bankruptcy notice expires on 25 August 2011.  If the stay is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McDonald v Stanley HC Auckland CIV-2011-404-2623 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 923
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand heard an appeal by Daryn Peter McDonald against a decision of the Weathertight Homes Tribunal, which had ruled in favour of the respondents, Lucy Norma Stanley and Melonie Jane Stanley, awarding them $332,897. McDonald appealed the decision, and subsequently applied for a stay of enforcement of the Tribunal's order pending the determination of the appeal. The respondents opposed the stay, and the matter was heard on 19 August 2011. The primary legal issue before the court was whether to grant the appellant's application for a stay of enforcement of the Tribunal's order. In determining this, the court considered several factors, including the potential for the appellant's right to appeal being rendered nugatory if a stay was not granted, the impact on the respondents if a stay was granted, the effect on third parties, the novelty and importance of the question involved, and the overall balance of convenience.

The court held that the application for a stay should be granted, primarily due to the significant risk that the appellant's right to appeal would be rendered nugatory if the stay was not granted. The court found that if the stay was not granted, the respondents could proceed with bankruptcy proceedings against the appellant, which would likely result in the appellant's sole substantial asset being forfeited. The court also noted that while the respondents would be injuriously affected if the appeal was successful, the delay in hearing the appeal was minimal, and the appeal was likely to proceed to hearing on 6 September 2011. Additionally, the court found that there was no evidence that third parties would be injuriously affected by the stay. Therefore, the court concluded that the overall balance of convenience favoured granting the stay.

As a result of the court's decision, the appellant's application for a stay was granted, and the respondents' bankruptcy proceedings against the appellant were adjourned until the hearing and determination of the appeal. Costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established