McCullagh v Robt Jones Holdings Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2013-404-3475 [2016] NZHC 1221

UNDER

Sections 292, 294 and 295 of the

Companies Act 1993

IN THE MATTER OF

the liquidation of Northern Crest
Investments Limtied (in liquidatation)

BETWEEN

ANTHONY JOHN MCCULLAGH AND STEPHEN MARK LAWRENCE Applicants

AND

ROBT. JONES HOLDINGS LIMITED Respondent

Hearing: 23 May 2016

Counsel:

B Keene QC for Applicants
D Chesterman for Respondent

Judgment:

8 June 2016

JUDGMENT OF DUFFY J

This judgment was delivered by me on 8 June 2016 at 3.00 pm pursuant to

Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/ Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Anthony Harper, Auckland

Gillespie Young Watson, Lower Hutt

Counsel:

David Chesterman, Auckland

Brian Keene QC, Auckland

MCCULLAGH AND LAWRENCE v ROBT. JONES HOLDINGS LIMITED [2016] NZHC 1221 [8 June 2016]

[1]      The applicants, who are the liquidators of Northern Crest Investments (in

liquidation)  (“the  liquidators”)  seek  recall  of  the  judgment  I  delivered  on  24

February 20161 insofar as that judgment makes a determination awarding costs to the

respondent, Robt Jones Holdings Ltd (“RJH”). The recall application is opposed.

[2]     The  substantive  proceedings  relating  to  the  present  interlocutory applicationare brought by the liquidators who seek an order under s 292 of the Companies Act 1993 setting aside payments by the company in liquidation to RJH on the ground the payments are voidable transactions.

[3]      The judgment of 24 February 2016 dealt with two interlocutory applications, each of which was brought by RJH.   They were: (a) an application to amend the notice of opposition to the originating application brought by the liquidators; and (b) an application for leave to adduce further evidence in support of RJH’s application for  High  Court  review  of  a  decision  of  Bell AJ.    RJH  was  successful  in  both applications, which were strenuously opposed by the liquidators.   At [45] of the judgment I found that as the “successful party RJH [was] entitled to costs.” I then gave the parties leave to file memoranda on the quantum of the costs award.

[4]      The liquidators’ written submissions in support of their opposition to RJH’s two applications included a request for an award of “wasted costs” by which the liquidators meant indemnity costs.  They also requested that the Court set a timetable for filing further submissions on costs.

[5]      The liquidators sought indemnity costs because RJH had withdrawn two of its  grounds  in  its  notice  opposing  the  originating  application.    The  abandoned grounds of opposition were: (a) this court lacked jurisdiction to determine if the relevant payment was a voidable transaction; and (b) the appropriate law for determining if the payment was a voidable transaction was Australian law.   The liquidators never said in their submissions that they sought an award of indemnity

costs even in the event that they were unsuccessful.

1 McCullagh v Robt Jones Holdings Ltd [2016] NZHC 263.

[6]      At  the  hearing  of  the  recall  application  it  became  clear  to  me  that  the liquidators believe that by deciding to award costs to RJH I had left their costs application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McCullagh v Robt Jones Holdings Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1221
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, the liquidators of Northern Crest Investments Limited (the "liquidators"), sought to recall a judgment awarding costs to the respondent, Robt Jones Holdings Limited (RJH). The liquidators opposed RJH's two interlocutory applications, one to amend the notice of opposition to the originating application and the other to adduce further evidence in support of RJH's application for review of a decision of Bell AJ. The liquidators sought indemnity costs for the wasted costs incurred in responding to the now abandoned grounds of opposition. Duffy J found that the liquidators had no basis to appeal the decision awarding costs to RJH, as the dismissal of their costs claim was implicit in the decision. The court held that the liquidators' application for recall did not qualify under the well-established tests for recalling a judgment, and that the liquidators had not suffered any special circumstances warranting recall.

Duffy J considered whether there were any proper grounds for recalling the decision to award costs to RJH. The court held that the liquidators' application for recall was premature, as no costs order had been formally made. The court found that the liquidators should have made submissions on the quantum of costs before seeking recall or appealing against the costs order. The court also noted that the liquidators' request for indemnity costs was not supported by the circumstances of the case, as the abandonment of the legal grounds of opposition saved the liquidators from having to face those arguments when the originating application came to be heard.

Duffy J dismissed the liquidators' application for recall, finding that there was no proper basis for recalling the decision to award costs to RJH. The court held that the liquidators had not suffered any special circumstances warranting recall and that the dismissal of their costs claim was implicit in the decision to award costs to RJH. The parties were granted leave to file memoranda on costs.

The court's decision highlights the importance of considering the overall result of a case when determining costs. The court found that the liquidators' request for indemnity costs was not supported by the circumstances of the case, and that the abandonment of the legal grounds of opposition saved the liquidators from having to face those arguments when the originating application came to be heard. The court also noted that the liquidators' application for recall was premature, as no costs order had been formally made. The decision underscores the need for parties to carefully consider their costs applications and to seek recall or appeal against a costs order only when there are proper grounds to do so.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.