McCallum Bros Limited v Auckland Council

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2024-404-003058

[2025] NZHC 820

UNDER the Resource Management Act 1991

IN THE MATTER

of an appeal under s 299 of the RMA

BETWEEN

MCCALLUM BROS LIMITED

Appellant

AND

AUCKLAND COUNCIL

First Respondent

MANUHIRI KAITAKI CHARITABLE TRUST

Second Respondent

Hearing: 2 April 2025

Appearances:

M Eastwick-Field and A Wouters for Appellant T Urlich and J Pou for Respondents

Judgment:

8 April 2025


JUDGMENT OF VENNING J


This judgment was delivered by me on 8 April 2025 at 3.00 pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

Solicitors:           Russell McVeagh, Auckland

Rice Spier, Auckland T Urlich, Hamilton

Copy to:            The Interested Parties

MCCALLUM BROS LIMITED v AUCKLAND COUNCIL [2025] NZHC 820 [8 April 2025]

[1]    In a decision delivered on 30 October 2024 the Environment Court ordered McCallum Bros Limited (MBL) to pay costs to Manuhiri Kaitaki Charitable Trust (MKCT) of $450,000.1 The Court also ordered MBL to pay Damon Clapshaw $50,000 in costs.

[2]MBL appeals against the costs order of $450,000 in favour of MKCT.

Background

[3]    The background to the substantive appeals that were before the Environment Court is set out at [1]–[9] of the Court’s decision:

[1]        There were six appeals filed in relation to three applications for consent to remove sand from the seabed within the Mangawhai – Pākiri embayment. The applications related to different bathymetric depths or distances from shore. McCallum Bros Ltd appealed against refusals to both the inshore1 and offshore applications. Four appeals were filed in relation to the grant of the midshore application.

[2]        The situation is somewhat complicated in that the McCallum Bros previously held consent to extract from the inshore area and were exercising rights under s 124 of the Act (continuation of consent provisions) while the appeal was to be determined in relation to the refusal of the consent.

[3]        The inshore consent was surrendered after a negotiated agreement between the parties on the basis of a temporary offshore consent being granted.4 The temporary consent was granted for the offshore area to avoid potential adverse effects recognised by all parties in relation to the inshore area. Costs were reserved.

Changes prior to hearing

[4]        The midshore application, which was granted at first instance, was withdrawn shortly prior to hearing and this was dealt with in a decision issued on 22 June 2023.5 Costs were reserved.

[5]        The appeal on the application for offshore consent went to a full hearing over some 33 days. In the final decision the appeal was refused, and the decision of the Commissioners confirmed.6 Directions as to costs were made.

[6]        At the end of the substantive hearing there was an application by McCallum Bros to strike out Manuhiri Kaitiaki Charitable Trust (MKCT / Ngāti Manhuiri) as a trade competitor. The application for strike out was subsequently heard, and refused in a decision issued on 11 April 2024.7


1      McCallum Bros Ltd v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McCallum Bros Limited v Auckland Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZHC 820
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McCallum Bros Limited (MBL) appealed against a costs order of $450,000 in favour of Manuhiri Kaitaki Charitable Trust (MKCT) made by the Environment Court. The case concerned appeals by MBL against various refusals and grants of consent by Auckland Council to extract sand from seabed areas within the Mangawhai – Pākiri embayment. MKCT sought indemnity costs relating to proceedings that were unsuccessful or abandoned by MBL. The Environment Court awarded MKCT $100,000 for expert costs and $350,000 for legal costs, totalling $450,000.

MBL argued that the Environment Court erred in awarding costs without a sufficient evidential foundation as to the actual costs incurred, took into account an irrelevant matter, failed to take into account relevant matters including the Practice Note 2023 of the Environment Court, and misapplied the legal test for awarding costs under the Resource Management Act 1991. MBL submitted that the Practice Note and case law supported its submission that invoices should form the basis of the claim for compensation and that the Environment Court erred by finding it was reasonable for MBL to be required to pay a costs award of $450,000 without the provision of sufficient evidence supporting the application.

The Court held that while the Practice Note provided guidance only and was not mandatory, the discretion to award costs must be exercised in a principled way. The Court was not satisfied that the Environment Court had exercised its discretion in a principled way. The Court held that the Environment Court erred in failing to require invoices to support the claim for legal costs. In the absence of invoices, it was difficult to determine the reasonableness or otherwise of the claim for legal expenses. The Court held that the Environment Court also erred in relying on the fact that MBL had not provided invoices as supporting the reasonableness of the award. The Court held that the decision of the Environment Court was unreasonable and the appeal was allowed. The matter was referred back to the Environment Court for it to determine the issue of costs again once MKCT had been given the opportunity to provide invoices to support the legal costs and disbursements sought. MKCT was to pay MBL costs calculated on a 2B basis together with disbursements as fixed by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established