McArthur Ridge Investments Limited v Schulz

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV- 2011-409-1680 [2015] NZHC 600

BETWEEN

MCARTHUR RIDGE INVESTMENTS

LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

ROBIN ANTHONY SCHULZ Defendant

Hearing:

27 March 2015

(On the papers)

Appearances:

T Shiels for Plaintiff
M J Wallace for Defendant

Judgment:

27 March 2015

JUDGMENT OF MANDER J

[1]      At the conclusion of my judgment of 12 August 2014, and after finding that an alleged settlement of the dispute had not been reached, I noted that the parties were agreed that costs were to be reserved.  The plaintiff, however, now seeks costs. I have received memoranda from the parties regarding this issue.

Indemnity costs

[2]      The plaintiff has submitted that it has an entitlement to full solicitor-client costs on the basis that it is entitled to indemnity costs as a contractual right. Alternatively, that indemnity costs are justified because the defendant’s actions in requiring the preliminary question to be determined were vexatious, frivolous and improper.1

[3]      The defendant does not dispute that the terms and conditions of the loan agreements ultimately assigned to the plaintiff provide for the recovery of such costs,

1      High Court Rules, r 14.6(4)(a) and (e).

MCARTHUR RIDGE INVESTMENTS LIMITED v SCHULZ [2015] NZHC 600 [27 March 2015]

but submits that, notwithstanding that contractual obligation, the Court must still determine under r 146(1)(b) of the High Court Rules (HCR) that the actual costs incurred by a party were reasonably incurred.  Whether the indemnity costs claimed under  a  contract  are  reasonable  will  involve  the  Court  making  an  objective assessment of whether the tasks undertaken were reasonably necessary and were covered by the contract, whether the charge rate(s) was reasonable and where any other general contract law principles should deny the claimant its prima facie right to

judgment.2

[4]      The indemnity costs sought by the plaintiff are as follows:

  • Counsel’s invoice, 5 August 2014  $17,223.92

  • Solicitor’s invoice, 29 May 2014  $9,569.79

  • Solicitor’s fees, 11 July 2014  $9,929.90

TOTAL  $36,723.61 (GST exclusive)

[5]      Scale costs have been calculated by the plaintiff by application of sch 3. Insofar as the schedule can be applied to the hearing of a preliminary or discrete issue, an amount on a 2B basis of $18,606.50 is claimed in the alternative by the plaintiff.

[6]      I am satisfied that the terms and conditions of the three credit facilities, the rights in respect of which were assigned to the plaintiff, provide for the recovery by the plaintiff of costs incidental to the enforcement of the loan agreements, including legal fees on a solicitor-client basis incurred in connection with the lender’s (the

plaintiff) rights or remedies.

2      Watson & Son Ltd v Active Manuka Honey Association [2009] NZCA 595 at [20], citing Frater Williams & Co Ltd v Australian Guarantee Corporation (NZ) Ltd (1994) 2 NZ ConvC 191,873 at 191,887.

[7]      The defendant challenges the reasonableness of the claimed indemnity costs on the basis that it is not possible to discern from the solicitor’s invoices whether the rates and amount charged is reasonable.  The plaintiff…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McArthur Ridge Investments Limited v Schulz and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 600
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, McArthur Ridge Investments Limited (the plaintiff) brought an action against Robin Anthony Schulz (the defendant) to recover costs following a dispute over a loan agreement. The plaintiff sought indemnity costs under contractual terms, as well as an alternative claim based on the defendant's alleged vexatious, frivolous, or improper conduct. The defendant disputed the reasonableness of the costs claimed, arguing that the invoices provided insufficient information to assess whether the costs were necessary or efficiently carried out.

The court found that the loan agreements provided for the recovery of indemnity costs, including legal fees on a solicitor-client basis. However, the court could not make an accurate assessment of the reasonableness of the solicitor's fees due to the lack of detailed information in the invoices. Consequently, the court awarded indemnity costs in respect of the counsel's invoice and two-thirds of the solicitor's fees, amounting to $30,223.58. The court did not consider the defendant's case to be vexatious, frivolous, or improper and did not award increased costs.

The court ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff indemnity costs in the sum of $30,223.58, with the possibility of a stay of enforcement pending the outcome of the defendant's appeal. The court observed that the defendant could seek a stay of enforcement if considered necessary.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established