McArthur Ridge Investments Limited v Schulz

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2011-409-001680 [2012] NZHC 423

BETWEEN  MCARTHUR RIDGE INVESTMENTS LIMITED

Plaintiff

ANDROBIN ANTHONY SCHULZ Defendant

Hearing:         23 February 2012 (Heard at Christchurch)

Appearances: T J Shiels for Plaintiff

D M Lester for Defendant

Judgment:      15 March 2012

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

UPON PLAINTIFF’S SUMMARY JUDGMENT APPLICATION

[1]      The plaintiff – I will refer to it as McArthur Ridge – sues Mr Schulz in relation to debts he guaranteed.  Mr Schulz, in opposition to the summary judgment application, raises some important matters concerning the pleading and evidence of the plaintiff’s mortgagee sale process but Mr Lester, for Mr Schulz, focused attention specifically on the quantum of the plaintiff’s claim.  Liability is not in issue.

The agreed history

[2]      Mr Schulz accepts that the contracts relied upon by McArthur Ridge existed as pleaded.

MCARTHUR RIDGE INVESTMENTS LIMITED V SCHULZ HC CHCH CIV-2011-409-001680 [15 March

2012]

[3]      A number of loan contracts are referred to in McArthur Ridge’s pleadings but only two are sued upon as remaining in debit.  I will refer to them as the “first loan” and “second loan” for convenience (although they had been preceded by an earlier loan, not in issue).

[4]      Southland Finance Limited (Southland Finance) and Central Otago Vintners’ Limited (“COVL”) entered into the first loan contract on 7 March 2008.  Mr Schulz guaranteed COVL’s obligations and (as between Southland Finance and himself) was deemed to be a party to the contract on the same terms as COVL.  The first loan was denominated by Southland Finance as Loan 34007910.

[5]      The second loan contract was entered into by Southland Finance and COVL on  2  May  2008.    The  obligations  of  COVL under  the  second  loan  were  also guaranteed by Mr Schulz.   The second loan was initially denominated as Loan

34008168  although  the  loan  was  subsequently  transferred  (apparently  for  the

lender’s accounting purposes) to a new account denominated as 34010623. [6]        COVL drew down on the loans as intended.

[7]      On  1  October  2008,  Southland  Finance  was  amalgamated  with  South

Canterbury Finance Limited (now in receivership) (“SCF”).

[8]      In July 2011, SCF sold its rights, title and interest in the indebtedness of COVL to SCF (including the associated security documents) to McArthur Ridge for a transfer price of $30,000 (together with a share of any recovery up to $70,000).

[9]      While it held the debt, SCF proceeded with a mortgagee sale of land held as security for the loans.  Mr Schulz accepts that the notices required under the Property Law Act 2007 were duly served by SCF on COVL and on himself.

[10]     Mr Schulz  also  accepts  that  when  McArthur  Ridge took  over the loans, McArthur Ridge duly served the required demands calling for repayment of the loans.  (There is one area of dispute in relation to demands, to which I will return below, and that relates to default interest).

[11]     The demands made by McArthur Ridge upon Mr Schulz, on 16 August 2011, were –

For the first loan…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McArthur Ridge Investments Limited v Schulz and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 423
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McArthur Ridge Investments Limited sought summary judgment against Robin Anthony Schulz for debts he had guaranteed. The court had to decide whether there was any arguable defence to the claim, and if the claim for quantum was established to the required level of proof. The court found that while the defendant had a liability of some level, the plaintiff had not satisfied the court that the defendant had no defence as to the quantum of the claim. The court found that the plaintiff had not satisfied the court that the defendant had no arguable case that the plaintiff had failed to exercise its duty of care to obtain the best price reasonably obtainable for the property at the time of the sale. The court also found that the plaintiff had not satisfied the court that its penalty interest rate did not contain a true penalty element. The court ordered summary judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant on the issue of liability, dismissed the application for summary judgment so far as it related to quantum, and directed a trial of the issue of amount. Costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established