Mayes v Southern Cross Finance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2013-404-10 [2013] NZHC 972

UNDER  Section 145A of the Land Transfer Act

1952

IN THE MATTER OF     Caveat 9224582.1

BETWEEN  JOHN WILLIAM NEWTON MAYES Applicant

ANDSOUTHERN CROSS FINANCE LIMITED

Respondent

Hearing:         3 May 2013

Counsel:         SA Grant for applicant

DS McGill and K White for respondent

Judgment:      6 May 2013

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE FAIRE [on application that caveat not lapse]

Solicitors:           Sharp Legal, PO Box 9686, Wellington

Duncan Cotterill, PO Box 5326, Auckland 1141

MAYES V SOUTHERN CROSS FINANCE LIMITED HC AK CIV-2013-404-10 [6 May 2013]

[1]      The applicant applies for an order pursuant to s 145A of the Land Transfer

Act 1952 that Caveat 9224582.1 not lapse.  The application relates to a property at

2/1 Waitara Road, Glendowie, Auckland.  The property is owned by the applicant’s

mother.

[2]      The caveat claims an estate or interest:

Pursuant to a  cestui que trust  between the registered  proprietor and the caveator contained in a option to purchase dated 17 October 2012.

[3]      The respondent, who is the second mortgagee of the subject property and whose mortgage was registered on 17 May 2001 opposes the order sought.   The grounds advanced in opposition are:

(a)      The  respondent  holds  the  second  registered  mortgage  over  the property as security for loan advances made to the applicant and the applicant’s joint borrower, his mother;

(b)The applicant and his mother have defaulted under the terms of the term loan held with the respondent and have failed, upon demand, to repay moneys due and owing to the respondent;

(c)      As at 3 February 2013, the applicant and his mother were indebted to the respondent in the sum of $203,519.86;

(d)Pursuant to the powers contained within the term loan agreement, the respondent issued Property Law Act notices to the applicant and his mother   on   or   about   15 October   2012,   such   notices   requiring repayment of all outstanding moneys, failing which the respondent would exercise powers of sale under the mortgage;

(e)      The  applicant  and  his  mother  failed  to  remedy  the  defaults  in accordance with the Property Law Act notices;

(f)      On 12 November 2012, the respondent instructed real estate agents to market the property for mortgagee sale;

(g)On 14 December 2012, following a tender process, the respondent entered  into  a  sale  and  purchase  agreement  for  the  sale  for  the property pursuant to the powers held by the respondent as mortgagee;

(h)Settlement of the agreement for sale and purchase of the property was scheduled to take place on 25 January 2013;

(i)The settlement of the sale and purchase agreement has been deferred to 25 May 2013 pending resolution of the applicant’s application;

(j)The respondent has the right pursuant to the mortgage executed in its favour to sell the property and has done so;

(k)The respondent’s right of sale as mortgagee takes priority over the applicant’s claim to an interest in the land pursuant to an option to purchase dated 17 October 2012; and

(l)       The applicant’s caveat should be removed to allow…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mayes v Southern Cross Finance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 972
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant in this case, John William Newton Mayes, sought an order under section 145A of the Land Transfer Act 1952 to prevent the lapse of a caveat registered against a property at 2/1 Waitara Road, Glendowie, Auckland, which is owned by his mother. The caveat was intended to claim an estate or interest under an option to purchase agreement dated 17 October 2012 between the registered proprietor and the applicant. The respondent, Southern Cross Finance Limited, opposed the application. As the second mortgagee of the property, the respondent argued that the applicant and his mother had defaulted on a loan agreement, leading to a scheduled mortgagee sale of the property. The respondent's grounds for opposing the application included the assertion that the applicant's right to an interest in the property was subordinate to the respondent's mortgagee sale rights.

The legal issues before the court were primarily whether the applicant had a reasonably arguable case for the interest claimed in the caveat and if the court should exercise its discretion to sustain the caveat. The principles guiding the court's decision were established in previous case law, which emphasized that the court retains a discretion to remove a caveat even if the caveator establishes an arguable case for the interest claimed. The court must also consider the principles of equitable estoppel and the priority of the respondent's mortgagee sale rights over the applicant's claimed interest.

The court found that the applicant had presented a triable issue regarding whether the initial disclosure made under the Credit Contracts Act 1981 was correctly recorded. Specifically, there was a dispute over whether a $500 funding reserve fee was paid by the applicant, which if true, would have resulted in a different finance rate being disclosed. The court noted that the respondent had not made an election under section 142 of the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003, meaning the Credit Contracts Act 1981 continued to apply. Given that there was a factual dispute that could potentially result in the applicant owing nothing on the mortgage, the court determined that it was appropriate to sustain the caveat. The court imposed a condition that the applicant must initiate proceedings within 21 days to seek a declaration that there is no money due and owing under the mortgage. Costs were ordered in favour of the applicant, as the respondent should have anticipated a triable issue and the necessity to sustain the caveat subject to conditions.

The final orders included sustaining the caveat 9224582.1 pending further order of the court, with the condition that the applicant must file and serve proceedings within 21 days seeking a declaration that no money is due under the mortgage. If such proceedings are not issued and prosecuted diligently, the respondent has leave to apply for the immediate removal of the caveat. Additionally, the court ordered the respondent to pay the applicant's costs on the application based on Category 2 Band B of the High Court Rules, along with disbursements fixed by the Registrar.