IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV2013-404-002797 [2014] NZHC 1817
UNDER the Credit Contracts Act 1981 BETWEEN
JOHN WILILAM NEWTON MAYES Plaintiff
AND
SOUTHERN CROSS FINANCE LIMITED
Defendant
On the papers Judgment:
4 August 2014
JUDGMENT OF ANDREWS J [Costs]
This judgment is delivered by me on 4 August 2014 at 2.30pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.
..................................................... Registrar / Deputy Registrar
MAYES v SOUTHERN CROSS FINANCE LTD [2014] NZHC 1817 [4 August 2014]
[1] Counsel for the parties have filed memoranda as to costs, as directed at [108]
of my judgment delivered on 29 May 2014.1
[2] On behalf of Mr Mayes, Mr Holmes submitted that as the successful party, Mr Mayes is entitled to costs. Costs on a 2B scale totalling $44,377, and disbursements of $2,197.13 are sought. However, Mr Holmes seeks an order for increased costs in the form of an uplift of 15 per cent above scale, on the basis that SCFL contributed unnecessarily to the time and cost of the proceeding. Mr Homes further submitted that SCFL had failed to accept a settlement offer which would have led to a better outcome for it.
[3] For SCFL, Mr Campbell submitted that both parties had each succeeded in part and were thus entitled to costs against the other. Costs should therefore lie where they fell. In the alternative, he submitted that the calculation of Mr Mayes’ costs was incorrect in some respects. Mr Campbell further submitted that Mr Mayes’ entitlement to costs should be reduced to account for the fact that he failed on his first and third causes of action, and only partially succeeded on his second cause of action. This would lead, he submitted, to an award of $13,731 for costs. Finally, he submitted that there were no grounds for an increased award of costs.
[4] The paramount rule on costs is that set out in r 14.1(1), that all matters relating to costs are at the discretion of the Court. Pursuant to r 14.1(2), all subsequent costs rules are subject to r 14.1(1). This case was argued and decided on the basis of identified issues, set out at [25] and [36] of the judgment, rather than on the basis of individual causes of action. Accordingly, I do not accept Mr Campbell’s submission that costs should be calculated on the basis of which parties succeeded on individual causes of action.
[5] While it is correct that Mr Mayes did not succeed on all of his causes of action, he did succeed in his claim based on SCFL’s failure to make proper disclosure, and the penalties ordered against SCFL will have a substantial effect on the amount to be paid to it. Further, SCFL has been held to have overcharged
interest in the first year of the loan, and (as was acknowledged in the dying stages of
the hearing) to have wrongly charged substantial costs and fees…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mayes v Southern Cross Finance Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZHC 1817
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine several key legal issues, including the appropriateness of the costs incurred by both parties, the impact of Southern Cross Finance Limited's conduct on the proceedings, and the accuracy of the costs claimed by Mayes. Specifically, Mayes sought an uplift of 15% on his costs due to what he argued was unnecessary prolongation of the proceedings by Southern Cross Finance Limited. Conversely, Southern Cross Finance Limited contended that both parties should bear their own costs and argued against an increased award for Mayes. Furthermore, they disputed the accuracy of the costs claimed by Mayes.
The court, after reviewing the submissions and the conduct of the parties, concluded that Mayes was entitled to costs on a 2B scale. However, certain adjustments were made to the claimed costs. The court found that Southern Cross Finance Limited's conduct did not warrant an uplift in costs, nor did it accept the argument that rejecting a settlement offer justified increased costs for Mayes. The court also noted that while Mayes did not succeed on all his claims, his success in proving improper disclosure and overcharging by Southern Cross Finance Limited warranted an award in his favour. The court adjusted the claimed costs based on specific items, such as the defence to the counterclaim and the list of documents on discovery, reducing some costs to a 2A scale. Consequently, the final order adjusted Mayes' costs to reflect these changes, while Southern Cross Finance Limited was not awarded any costs.