IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE
CIV-2018-404-1087
[2019] NZHC 1509
BETWEEN MAYBELLE KAPETA MATTHEWS
Appellant
AND
ACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION
Respondent
Hearing: 19 March 2019
(Further submissions received 22 and 29 March 2019)
Appearances:
A Beck for Appellant
A Butler for Respondent
Judgment:
1 July 2019
JUDGMENT OF GRICE J
Contents
Introduction [1]
Background [3]
Personal injuries and medical history [3]
ACC applications and proceedings [10]
District Court decision [17]
Standard of appeal [19]
Grounds for appeal [21]
What caused Mr Aria’s inability to work? [25]
Findings [36]
Burden of proof [37]
Conclusion [39]
Costs [40]
This decision [40]
Leave decision [43]
MATTHEWS v ACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION [2019] NZHC 1509 [1 July 2019]
Introduction
[1] Ms Matthews was granted special leave to appeal a 2017 decision of Judge Mathers.1 In that decision she dismissed Mr Aria’s appeal against an Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC) review decision.2 The issue in both decision was Mr Aria’s entitlement to weekly compensation under the Accident Compensation Act 2001 (the Act) following personal injury caused by an insect bite in 2007.
[2] Mr Aria, tragically died in a boating accident in 2016, before the District Court heard his appeal. Ms Matthews, as Mr Aria’s representative, was granted leave to be substituted as the appellant in these proceedings.3
Background
Personal injuries and medical history
[3] In 1974, Mr Aria was involved in a motorcycle accident that caused serious soft tissue and vascular injuries to his right leg. In particular, the internal damage compromised a deep artery known as the popliteal artery in the vicinity of the knee. This affected the blood circulation in the lower leg. He required several surgeries to help correct some of this internal damage.
[4] The first surgery involved an arterial bypass and a skin graft. The healing process was not straight forward and Mr Aria suffered a haematoma and infection. He also underwent a subsequent surgery in which an attempt was made to stretch his Achilles’ tendon. This surgery was necessary as the tendon had shortened causing his ankle and foot to fix in a pointed position (plantar flexion). Following both surgeries Mr Aria was unable to fully extend his right knee (fixed flexion deformity) and his right ankle remained in its fixed position (it was held in an equinus). He spent three to four months in hospital.
1 Matthews v Accident Compensation Corporation [2018] NZHC 2769.
2 Aria v Accident Compensation Corporation [2017] NZACC 38 (DC).
3 Matthews v Accident Compensation Corporation [2018] NZHC 2769 at [2]. I refer to Mr Aria as the claimant throughout.
[5] Mr Aria had to manage around his deformity. He had to walk on the tip of his toes on his right foot. Mr Aria was about 17 years of age at the time of the injury and not employed.
[6] In 1975, Mr Aria gained employment at a meat processing plant. Despite his limp, he worked full time for most of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Matthews v Accident Compensation Corporation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NZHC 1509
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The High Court was required to determine if the 2007 injury could be considered a contributing factor to Mr Aria’s incapacity under s 103 and cl 32 of Schedule 1 of the Act and whether the 2007 injury aggravated the pre-existing injury to cause incapacity. The Court also had to assess whether the District Court Judge applied the correct test or burden of proof in reaching her conclusion.
The High Court found that the 2008 arterial bypass surgery was solely due to the circulation problems caused by the 1974 personal injury, and any aggravation flowing from the surgery was from the 1974, not the 2007, injury. The Court dismissed the argument that the fragility of the skin was a material contributing factor to Mr Aria’s ongoing incapacity. The Court concluded that the District Court Judge did not make any errors on questions of law in reaching her decision. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and no order for costs was made in favour of the successful party, ACC.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.