Matenga v Coroners Court at Dunedin

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV-2014-412-196 [2014] NZHC 2994

BETWEEN

PERERO FREDERICK ALEXANDER

SHARMON MATENGA Applicant

AND

THE CORONERS COURT AT DUNEDIN

Respondent

Hearing:

27 November 2014

(At Christchurch)

Counsel:

J A Farrow for Applicant
R K P Stewart for Fairfax Media Limited

Judgment:

27 November 2014

JUDGMENT OF THE HON JUSTICE KÓS (Application for interim non-publication orders)

[1]      Mr Matenga applies on an urgent Pickwick basis for interim orders, in effect under s 74(b) of the Coroners Act 2006 (the Act), that his name not be made public. I have determined that it is not appropriate to grant the application.   Time today permits only very brief reasons for that decision to now be given.

[2]      Mr Matenga is a Corrections Officers at Milton Prison.  He is scheduled to give evidence this week in the Coroner’s inquest into the death of prisoner Jai Davis in February 2011.   Mr Matenga is being called as a witness because he was the Corrections officer who was checking Mr Davis periodically while he was in the At Risk Unit, in the period immediately prior to his death.

[3]      An application was made yesterday under s 74(b) of the Act the Coroner

conducting the inquest, Coroner Crerar, that Mr Matenga’s name (and those of two

other Corrections officers) not be made public.  The major ground of the application

MATENGA v THE CORONERS COURT AT DUNEDIN [2014] NZHC 2994 [27 November 2014]

was a perceived risk to the applicants’ personal safety if their names were publicised. The secondary ground was a risk to fair trial rights should the names be made public, and the applicants were then prosecuted.

[4]      Section 74 provides:

If satisfied that it is in the interests of justice, decency, public order, or personal privacy to do so, a coroner may prohibit the making public of—

(a)       any evidence given or submissions made at or for the purposes of any  part  of  the  proceedings  of  an  inquiry  (for  example,  at  an inquest); and

(b)       the  name,  and  any  name  or  particulars  likely  to  lead  to  the identification, of any witness or witnesses.

[5]      The application before Coroner Crerar failed.  He held that the evidence as to perceived risk to personal safety was speculative and unproven.  It amounted to no more than the applicants’ own assertions.   The prospect of a prosecution of the applicants was remote.   The police had no such intention following their own investigation.

[6]      Mr Matenga has now filed a statement of claim in the High Court seeking judicial review of the Coroner’s decision.  The other applicants before the Coroner have not pursued the matter further.   It is alleged that the Coroner’s decision is wrong; that he failed to consider the difficulties of providing direct evidence of increased risk; that it was irrelevant that few prisoners from 2011 were likely still to be at Milton (as the risk lay from any prisoner potentially); that the prospect of a prosecution could not be gauged until the Coroner’s findings…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Matenga v Coroners Court at Dunedin and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2994
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Perero Frederick Alexander Sharmon Matenga applied for an interim non-publication order to prevent the disclosure of his name in connection with the coroner's inquest into the death of prisoner Jai Davis. Matenga, a corrections officer at Milton Prison, was scheduled to give evidence in the inquest as he was the officer who was checking Davis periodically while he was in the At Risk Unit, in the period immediately prior to his death. Matenga argued that the disclosure of his name would put his personal safety at risk and could also prejudice his fair trial rights should he be prosecuted. The coroner had previously declined to make an order prohibiting publication of Matenga's name.

The court was required to determine whether the coroner's decision was correct and whether the court should grant the interim non-publication order sought by Matenga. The court noted that section 74 of the Coroners Act 2006 provided that a coroner may prohibit the making public of the name of any witness if satisfied that it is in the interests of justice, decency, public order, or personal privacy to do so. The coroner had found that the evidence of risk to Matenga's personal safety was speculative and unproven, and the prospect of a prosecution of Matenga was remote. The court agreed with the coroner's decision and found that the application for interim relief was not appropriate in the circumstances. The court made a temporary order prohibiting publication of Matenga's name in connection with the inquest or these proceedings, to facilitate any appeal that may run from this decision.

The court's reasoning was based on several factors. Firstly, the court found that the primary ground of the application, the risk to Matenga's personal safety, was speculative and unproven. The coroner's evidence on this matter was sufficient. Secondly, the names of two other original applicants were now public knowledge, and it was difficult to determine whether any risk Matenga faced would arise from that publication or from any further publication of his own name and involvement. Thirdly, if there was indeed a physical risk to Matenga as a result of disclosure of his involvement, that was a matter which his employer, the Corrections Department, would need to take into account in his assignment to duty. Finally, the risk to Matenga's fair trial rights in the event of prosecution was overstated. Such prosecution was highly unlikely on the evidence before the court. The court was not satisfied that it was reasonably necessary to make the orders sought, and the temporary order made would expire at 1pm on Friday 28 November 2014.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established