Masterton Investments Limited v Watson

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND MASTERTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA WHAKAORIORI ROHE

CIV-2020-435-19

[2021] NZHC 1681

BETWEEN

MASTERTON INVESTMENTS LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

DENIS ERIC WATSON

Defendant

Hearing: 4 May 2021

Counsel:

S P Maloney for plaintiff K P Sullivan for defendant

Judgment:

7 July 2021


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE JOHNSTON


Introduction and background

[1]                  On 3 December 2019 the parties entered into an unconditional agreement for the sale and purchase of a commercial property in Masterton, whereby the plaintiff, Masterton Investments Ltd (MIL), agreed to sell and the defendant, Mr Denis Watson, agreed to purchase the property for $1.7 million (exclusive of GST). The agreement provided for a deposit of $50,000 to be paid by 13 December 2019, and the balance of the purchase price to be payable on settlement which was to take place on 31 March 2020.

[2]                  It is common ground that Mr Watson did not pay the deposit or settle the transaction.

[3]                  MIL put the property back on the market and eventually sold it to a third party for $1,300.000.00

MASTERTON INVESTMENTS LIMITED v WATSON [2021] NZHC 1681 [7 July 2021]

[4]                  MIL now sues Mr Watson and claims damages reflecting the difference between the sale and purchase price in the original contract and the price at which the company eventually sold the property, and other losses, together with interest and costs. It’s claim totals $453,597.98. MIL applies for summary judgment.

[5]                  Mr Watson opposes that application. He says that he has defences to the claim against him. First, he says that when it appeared that he would not be able to settle the original contract the parties negotiated an alternative agreement whereby MIL would lease the property to him for a year, at the conclusion of which term he would settle the sale and purchase transaction (“lease to buy”). He says that, after the parties reached a  final  agreement,  MIL  sold  the  property  to  the  third  party.  Second, Mr Watson says that MIL failed to take reasonable steps to mitigate its loss, and cannot visit the entire difference between the two sale and purchase agreements on him.

[6]                  On those bases, Mr Watson contends that MIL’s application for summary judgment should be dismissed and that its claim should go to trial in the usual way.

[7]                  Counsel were on common ground in terms of the principles relating to summary judgment. Mr Maloney summarised these in terms with which Mr Sullivan did not take issue:

17.The plaintiff bears the onus of proving that the defendant has no defence to any cause of action in the statement of claim. The words “no defence” require the plaintiff to establish the absence of any real question to be tried, and have been interpreted as:

“no bona fide defence, no reasonable ground of defence, no fairly arguable defence”.

18.However, where the plaintiff’s evidence is sufficient to convince the Court that it is (without more) entitled to the relief claimed, the defendant must respond with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Masterton Investments Limited v Watson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZHC 1681
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Masterton Investments Limited initiated proceedings against Denis Watson, alleging that he failed to fulfil his obligations under a sale and purchase agreement for a commercial property in Masterton. The original agreement stipulated a deposit of $50,000 and a settlement date of 31 March 2020, with a purchase price of $1.7 million. However, Watson did not pay the deposit or settle the transaction. Masterton Investments subsequently sold the property to a third party for $1.3 million and claimed damages for the difference in price, plus interest and costs, totaling $453,597.98. Masterton Investments applied for summary judgment, which Watson opposed on the grounds that he had defences to the claim, including an alleged lease-to-buy agreement and a failure by Masterton Investments to mitigate its losses.

The court was required to determine whether the defences raised by Watson were arguable, which would entitle him to contest the claim at trial instead of granting summary judgment to Masterton Investments. The first defence related to the alleged lease-to-buy agreement, where Masterton Investments would lease the property to Watson for a year, with the sale and purchase transaction to be settled at the end of the lease term. The court found that it was arguable that the parties had reached an agreement for the lease-to-buy arrangement, but it was not conclusive whether the agreement was enforceable under Section 24 of the Property Law Act 2007. The second defence pertained to Masterton Investments' failure to mitigate its losses by not taking reasonable steps to reduce the financial impact of the sale to the third party. The court found that this issue could not be determined based on the untested affidavit evidence before the court.

The court concluded that Masterton Investments had not established that Watson did not have an arguable defence to its claim. Therefore, Masterton Investments' application for summary judgment was dismissed, and the matter must be resolved at trial. Following an unsuccessful application for summary judgment, the convention is that no costs orders follow. However, counsel may come back with memoranda if they wish to contend for another outcome on costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.