Maranathan Charitable Trust v Cawthray Motors Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2014-404-3240 [2016] NZHC 1069

BETWEEN

MARANATHAN CHARITABLE TRUST

Plaintiff

AND

CAWTHRAY MOTORS LIMITED First Defendant

TITUS ELCANA PINTO Second Defendant

JOHN BARRY MASSAM Third Defendant

Hearing: 17 May 2016

Appearances:

P J Wright and G E Schumacher for the Plaintiff
A Barker and M C Kilham for the First and Second Defendants
I C Bassett for the Third Defendant

Judgment:

17 May 2016

ORALJUDGMENT NO 1 OF MUIR J (Recall of Witness)

Solicitors/Counsel:

P J Wright, Barrister, Auckland
G E Schumacher, Barrister, Auckland

A Barker, Barrister, Auckland

M C Kilham, Anderson Creagh Lai, Auckland

I C Bassett, Malloy Goodwin Harford, Auckland

MARANATHAN CHARITABLE TRUST v CAWTHRAY MOTORS LIMITED [2016] NZHC 1069 [17 May

2016]

Background

[1]      By memorandum dated 16 May 2016 the plaintiff seeks recall of its witness

Mr Hasmukh Magam Ranchhod.

[2]      Mr Ranchhod  gave evidence on Thursday 12  May 2016  commencing at approximately 3.00 pm.  He was the final witness for the plaintiffs.  His evidence-in- chief consisted  of a  one and  a half  page  written statement  which  he  read.    In paragraphs 1-8 he described his background with the Maranathan Trust, previous employment with the Challenge weekly Christian newspaper run by Mr Massam and the genesis of his involvement in what he refers to in para [9] as “the present disputes”.

[3]      Paragraph [9] was in terms:

My  first  involvement  with  El  Pinto  with  respect  to  the  present disputes was when I attended a meeting on 29 January 2014 at the Maranathan offices with Grant and El Pinto….

[4]      When Mr Ranchhod came to read this paragraph of his brief of evidence he read the date 29 January 2014 as 29 January 2013.  That elicited cross-examination from Mr Barker in terms:1

QMr Ranchhod, just a couple of questions, just at paragraph 9 of your evidence you talk about a meeting on 29 January 2000 (sic) and, well it said 14 in the written one and you changed it to 13.  I just wanted to confirm that with you and if you go to the bundle.

A        Oh sorry, let’s have a look.

Q        Is it 2013 you mean there or 2014?

[5]      At that point I intervened and reminded Mr Ranchhod that he had indeed read it as 2013.  He acknowledged that he had done so.  He then stated:2

A        But I am actually, can I just your Honour, I just need to clarify it because they are actually, there was the meeting in 2013 when we met El Pinto and also there was the 29 January 2014 when we met

1      NOE 259/10.

2      NOE 259/24-28.

when he and first started talking about getting the donation letters sorted out.

[6]      In  the  event,  Mr  Ranchhod  did  not  give  any  evidence  in  relation  to discussions with Mr Pinto in 2013.  Nor, although the documentary record indicated email exchanges by Mr Ranchhod with Mr Pinto in 2013, were such documents or the background to them referred to.

[7]      At the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maranathan Charitable Trust v Cawthray Motors Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1069
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand considered the application by the Maranathan Charitable Trust to recall its witness, Mr Hasmukh Magam Ranchhod, after he inadvertently omitted to testify about significant events from 2013. The Trust sought to introduce this omitted evidence to support its claim that commitments made in original donation letters were novated in favor of the Trust. Cawthray Motors Limited and other defendants opposed the recall, arguing that any new evidence from Mr Ranchhod would be unreliable and prejudicial. The Court had to determine whether to allow the recall under the Evidence Act 2006 and if doing so would cause unfair prejudice to the defendants.

The Court found that the plaintiff's brief of evidence was deficient for not covering discussions and communications from 2013, which were relevant to the novation claim. The error seemed to stem from the briefing process rather than any deliberate choice by Mr Ranchhod. The Court considered that while the situation was less than ideal, denying the plaintiff the opportunity to present potentially important evidence would be unjust. The Court reasoned that any prejudice to the defendants could be mitigated by allowing them to re-examine Mr Ranchhod and possibly recalling other witnesses. The Court granted the recall with strict limitations on the scope of the additional evidence.

The Court granted the plaintiff's application to recall Mr Ranchhod, subject to the conditions that his additional evidence be strictly limited to the 2013 discussions and correspondence with Mr Pinto. The Court also awarded costs to the defendants for the time spent on this issue, payable immediately.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.