Manchester Securities Limited v Body Corporate 172108

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA131/2013
[2013] NZCA 515

BETWEEN

MANCHESTER SECURITIES LIMITED
Appellant

AND

BODY CORPORATE 172108
Respondent

Hearing:

22 July 2013; 26 September 2013 (telephone conference); (further submissions received 3 October 2013)

Court:

Ellen France, Ronald Young and Cooper JJ

Counsel:

M C Harris for Appellant
T J Allan for Respondent

Judgment:

23 October 2013 at 12.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BNo order as to costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Ronald Young J)

  1. Manchester Securities Ltd (Manchester) owns the top floor of a 12 storey apartment building on Hobson Street in Auckland.  The other 11 floors are divided into 39 individual apartments.  The building was affected by weathertightness problems.  It leaked.

  2. In 2009 remedial work was planned.  The body corporate sought High Court approval for a remediation scheme under s 48 of the Unit Titles Act 1972.  A series of judgments from the High Court followed.  Heath J concluded that Manchester could (with limits) determine the scope of the work for the 12th floor and pay for this work.[1]  The work for floors one to 11 would be undertaken by the body corporate.  The total remedial cost for the building (all 12 floors) would be ascertained and Manchester would pay 11.88 per cent of that total.  At the time of Heath J’s judgment the 11.88 per cent was expected to cover all of the 12th floor remedial costs and provide a contribution by Manchester to the body corporate costs.

    [1]Body Corporate 172108 v Meader (2011) 12 NZCPR 101 (HC); and see Body Corporate 172108 v Meader (No 2) HC Auckland CIV-2009-404-6868, 19 August 2010.

  3. The body corporate, as it was entitled to, levied all the building owners in the interim to enable the remedial work to begin.  Manchester challenged the levy advising the body corporate that it was calculated on an improper basis.  The body corporate did not agree.  Manchester refused to pay.

  4. Clause 13.1 of the s 48 remediation scheme provided that where an owner objected to a levy (amongst other matters) the body corporate shall refer the matter to arbitration.  And at cl 13.3 no owner was entitled to withhold a levy on the basis that a dispute had been referred to arbitration (a “pay now argue later” clause).  When the body corporate received Manchester’s challenge to the levy, it referred the dispute to arbitration.  But it did not accept (based on cl 13.3) that Manchester was entitled to withhold payment of a levy in the meantime.

  5. The body corporate issued a statutory demand for the remedial levy and an ordinary levy both unpaid by Manchester.  Manchester applied to the High Court to set aside the demand.

  6. Associate Judge Bell found that the “pay now argue later” clause in the s 48 scheme meant exactly that.[2]  He considered that Manchester’s challenge was effectively a challenge to the merits of the levy which the s 48 agreement required to be arbitrated.  Thus, it was for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Manchester Securities Limited v Body Corporate 172108 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZCA 515
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, Manchester Securities Limited, the owner of the top floor of a twelve-storey apartment building on Hobson Street in Auckland, appealed a decision of the High Court against Body Corporate 172108, the body corporate of the building. The underlying dispute between the parties centred on a statutory demand issued by the body corporate for unpaid remedial levies in respect of weathertightness problems affecting the building. The body corporate sought High Court approval for a remediation scheme under section 48 of the Unit Titles Act 1972. Following a series of judgments from the High Court, an Associate Judge concluded that Manchester could determine the scope of the work for the 12th floor and pay for this work. The total remedial cost for the building (all 12 floors) would be ascertained and Manchester would pay 11.88 per cent of that total. The body corporate, as it was entitled to, levied all the building owners in the interim to enable the remedial work to begin. Manchester challenged the levy advising the body corporate that it was calculated on an improper basis. The body corporate did not agree and referred the dispute to arbitration. The body corporate issued a statutory demand for the remedial levy and an ordinary levy both unpaid by Manchester. Manchester applied to the High Court to set aside the demand. The High Court dismissed the application and Manchester appealed. Manchester said the statutory demand should have been set aside because the remedial levy which gave rise to the debt was an unreasonable and therefore unlawful levy. There were two grounds on which it said the levy was unreasonable. First, because the body corporate failed to take into account Manchester's estimate of the remediation cost of the 12th floor and secondly, the body corporate’s estimate for the 12th floor repair cost was not assessed on the same basis as the estimate for floors one to 11. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal. The Court noted that the substantive issues before this Court had been canvassed in the arbitration and ruled on by the arbitrator. The Court concluded that a merits based judgment was no longer called for or appropriate in the circumstances given the issue before the Court was now moot. The appropriate course was for the Court to dismiss the appeal. The Court accepted in these circumstances that the appellant would suffer some potential financial loss given the costs order made against it by the Associate Judge. In this appeal the Court considered that costs should appropriately lie where they fell and accordingly made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established