Mak v Lumenosity Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2022-404-1080

[2023] NZHC 2386

BETWEEN

SUZANNA MAK AND ASA DENTON

Plaintiffs

AND

LUMENOSITY LIMITED

First Defendant

AMBER MARIE NAVEIRA
Second Defendant

VICTOR NAVEIRA
Third Defendant

THE GRANARY LIMITED

Fourth Defendant

Hearing:

29 May 2023

Plaintiffs’ chronology and defendants’ chronology 8 June 2023

Counsel:

G Williams for Plaintiffs

No appearance for First Defendant
C Hadlee and S Thirayan for Second, Third and Fourth Defendants

Judgment:

30 August 2023


JUDGMENT OF HINTON J


This judgment was delivered by me on 30 August 2023 at 10.00 am, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date: ………………………….

Solicitors:           Sinclair Black, Auckland

Hudson Gavin Martin, Auckland

MAK v LUMENOSITY LIMITED [2023] NZHC 2386 [30 August 2023]

[1]This judgment addresses two interlocutory applications in this proceeding.

Introduction

[2]        In late 2021 the plaintiffs and second and third defendants (the Naveiras) informally agreed that they would enter into a business venture relating to the establishment and operation of a virtual production studio. They took various steps in that direction until February 2022 when the relationship broke down.

[3]        The terms of the agreement are unclear. It seems to have been intended, and this is the agreement as relied on by the defendants, that the venture would be run through an existing company, being the fourth defendant (The Granary) which was owned by the Naveiras, and the plaintiffs would acquire a 49 per cent shareholding in that company. The Granary already owned intellectual property (IP) relating to a virtual production studio but had no ability to fund the venture. It had also applied for a grant from the Ministry of Culture and Heritage (MCH). The intention was that the plaintiffs pay either NZD 1.5 million approximately (according to the plaintiffs) or USD 1.5 million (according to the defendants) for the shareholding in The Granary. For convenience only, instead of transferring The Granary shares, the parties incorporated the first defendant (Lumenosity) and the shares in that company were issued 51 per cent/49 per cent to the Naveiras and plaintiffs respectively.

[4]        Before Lumenosity was incorporated, the plaintiffs purchased and paid for virtual studio equipment (VPE), comprising screens and accessories, a camera and two workstations.1 Payments for the VPE and for other outgoings were made by the plaintiffs down to the relationship breakdown in February 2022. The VPE payments were USD 737,329.70, AUD 202,470 and NZD 54,635.96. In addition, the plaintiffs paid NZD 3,468.74 for two boards. They also incurred net further expenditure of NZD 73,418.96.

[5]        Following the relationship breakdown, the plaintiffs say that they are the owners of the VPE and boards. They say it was intended that ownership would ultimately be transferred by them to Lumenosity, either by way of sale or in return for


1      At the request of the Naveiras, these are not further described.

Lumenosity’s agreement that it would reimburse the plaintiffs for the costs they had incurred. They say the transfer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mak v Lumenosity Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 2386
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the case of Mak v Lumenosity Limited revolves around the ownership of virtual production equipment (VPE) and other assets, following a failed business venture between the plaintiffs, Suzanna Mak and Asa Denton, and the Naveiras, Victor and Amber Marie Naveira, and The Granary Limited, a company owned by the Naveiras. The plaintiffs claimed ownership of the VPE and sought a declaration to that effect or, alternatively, that they were owed money by Lumenosity Limited, the new company formed by the parties. The Naveiras argued that the plaintiffs had no ownership interest in the VPE, which they claimed was part of the consideration for the plaintiffs' 49% shareholding in Lumenosity. The case involved two interlocutory applications: the plaintiffs sought leave to commence summary judgment proceedings and for certain questions to be tried separately.

The court considered the plaintiffs' request for summary judgment, which would have resolved the ownership issue quickly. However, the court found that the plaintiffs' case was not sufficiently clear to justify summary judgment, as the emails cited by the plaintiffs did not constitute admissions of ownership. The court also rejected the plaintiffs' request for certain questions to be tried separately, noting that the issues were intertwined and that separate trials could lead to inconsistent decisions. The court highlighted the need for the parties to address the uncertainties in their agreements and consider mediation to resolve their disputes.

The court ordered that the application for summary judgment be dismissed and that the application for separate questions to be tried be adjourned for a tele-conference to allow the parties to report on settlement and address the outstanding issues. The court emphasized the importance of resolving the matter expeditiously and urged the parties to negotiate with a commercial mediator.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established