Mackie Law Independent Trustee Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2016-404-003187 [2017] NZHC 1570

UNDER

Section 51 of the Trustee Act 1956 and

s 76 of the Public Trust Act 2001

IN THE MATTER

of the Donald Trust

BETWEEN

MACKIE LAW INDEPENDENT TRUSTEE LIMITED, CARROLL JEAN MUIR AND ANNE RUTH HASTIE AS TRUSTEES OF THE DONALD TRUST Applicants

AND

JOANNE FLEUR CHAPLOW Respondent

Hearing: 2 June 2017

Appearances:

M R Taylor for Applicants
M J Allan for Respondent

Judgment:

10 July 2017

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney on 10 July 2017 at 9.00 am

pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Date………………………

MACKIE LAW INDEPENDENT TRUSTEE LTD & ORS v CHAPLOW [2017] NZHC 1570 [10 July 2017]

Introduction

[1]      Mackie Law Independent Trustee Ltd (MLIT), Carroll Muir and Anne Hastie are the trustees of the Donald Trust, settled by the late Hugh Munro.  The trust’s only asset is a residential property in Point Chevalier, Auckland.  The primary beneficiary is Joanne Chaplow, Mr Munro’s daughter.  Upon Mr Munro’s death in January 2016 the trustees agreed that the property should be resettled on a new family trust for the benefit of Ms Chaplow and her children.  But they insisted that resettlement proceed in accordance with Mr Munro’s memorandum of wishes.   After months of disagreement over the terms of the resettlement and ongoing dispute over payment of the trustees’ legal fees, the trustees now wish to retire and have the Public Trust take over as sole trustee.

[2]      The  trustees  have  applied  for  orders  (1)  removing  them  as  trustees  (2) appointing the Public Trust in their place (3) requiring the legal fees incurred by them to be met from the assets of the trust and (4) costs on the application.

[3]      Ms Chaplow opposes the application save that she accepts that a certain level of fees may properly be paid from the trust.  Ms Chaplow herself has not made any formal application but in her affidavit in opposition she seeks orders (1) that the property be resettled on her family trust (2) that the mortgage granted by the trustees to secure payment of the legal fees be discharged (3) fixing the amount of the legal costs for which the trustees are entitled to be indemnified from the trust assets and (4) costs on the application.  The trustees did not object to the lack of any formal application by Ms Chaplow.

[4]      The various applications relating to the removal/replacement of the trustees, discharge of the mortgage and resettlement of the property are intertwined and I deal with them together.  But I consider the trustees’ application regarding indemnity for legal fees first because, in examining that issue, the factors that indicate how the other applications should be dealt with follow more easily.

[5]      The applications regarding the trustees’ entitlement to have their legal fees indemnified from trust assets raise the following questions:

(a)       What were the trustees’ obligations in relation to the memorandum of

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mackie Law Independent Trustee Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 1570
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the case of Mackie Law Independent Trustee Limited and others v Chaplow involves the administration of the Donald Trust. The trustees of the trust, Mackie Law Independent Trustee Limited, Carroll Muir, and Anne Ruth Hastie, have applied to be discharged and for the Public Trust to be appointed as the sole trustee. The primary beneficiary, Joanne Chaplow, opposes the application but agrees that some level of the trustees' legal fees may be paid from the trust assets. The court must decide several issues, including the trustees' obligations in relation to the memorandum of wishes, whether the trustees were entitled to grant a mortgage over the trust property to secure payment of the legal fees, and the extent to which the trustees are entitled to an indemnity in relation to the legal fees incurred. The court also needs to decide whether the trustees should be removed and replaced, whether the property should be resettled on Chaplow's family trust, and whether any costs of the application should be met from the trust.

The court concludes that the trustees were entitled to have regard to the memorandum of wishes but failed to independently apply their minds to its course, resulting in the wrongful allowance of Qingjuan Lu to occupy the trust property. The trustees also misunderstood the effect of the memorandum of wishes and failed to properly consult Chaplow regarding her wishes about the Point Chevalier property. The court finds that only a portion of the fees incurred are indemnifiable from the trust property as a result of these failings. The granting of a mortgage over the trust property was deemed unnecessary. Although there are grounds to remove the trustees, it is unclear who should be appointed in their place. The court orders that the trustees are entitled to be indemnified in respect of the legal fees incurred to Mackie & Co to the extent of $3,500 plus GST and disbursements and in respect of the legal fees incurred to GM Legal to the extent of $4,200 plus GST and disbursements. The trustees are also ordered to discharge the mortgage over the property forthwith. The court reserves costs pending the resolution of the case.