MacCabee-Bismark v Police

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY

CRI-2016-454-22 [2016] NZHC 2749

BETWEEN

ADELA MACCABEE-BISMARK

Appellant

AND

NEW ZEALAND POLICE Respondent

Hearing: 8 November 2016 (by AVL)

Counsel:

S N Hewson for appellant
M J Blaschke for respondent

Judgment:

17 November 2016

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

[1]      This is an appeal from  a decision of the District Court to deal with the appellant other than by way of a discharge without conviction, after she had pleaded guilty to a charge of threatening to injure.  On 28 April 2016, Judge Ross entered a conviction against the appellant in the Palmerston North District Court, and ordered

that she was to come up for sentence if called upon within six months.1

[2]      The appellant was represented when the matter was dealt with in the District Court.     However,  having  been  declined  legal  aid  to  pursue  an  appeal,  she commenced one on her own behalf.  When the appeal was called on 23 August 2016, Williams J adjourned the appeal to allow reconsideration of a grant of legal aid for the appellant to be represented.  Mr Hewson has subsequently been retained and has

filed written submissions and appeared in support of them.

1      Police v Maccabee-Bismark [2016] NZDC 10199.

MACCABEE-BISMARK v POLICE [2016] NZHC 2749 [17 November 2016]

[3]      Williams J described the circumstances of the offending in the following terms:2

[4]       On 8 December 2015, Ms Bismark was having what a lay person might call a nervous breakdown.  Her father had died.  She was close to him. Her life had not been going well.  She had nowhere to stay and visited her brother and sister-in-law asking for accommodation.  She was declined.  The police summary says that Ms Bismark became verbally aggressive towards her   brother   and   sister-in-law   and   approached   the   sister-in-law   in   a threatening manner.  The police were called and an altercation ensued.  Ms Bismark then spent six weeks in a mental health ward and has been, by her consent as I understand it, assisted by mental health authorities over the past six months or so.  …

[4]      Counsel appearing for the appellant on sentencing did not seek a discharge without conviction.   Certainly, Judge Ross did not record any consideration as to whether that would be an appropriate outcome.   It is clear that I am substantially better informed about her personal circumstances, and in particular the nature and extent of her mental health issues, than Judge Ross was.

[5]      Consideration of discharging a defendant without conviction is governed by ss 107 and 106 of the Sentencing Act 2002 (the Act).  Section 107 provides:

107      Guidance for discharge without conviction

The court must not discharge an offender without conviction unless the court is satisfied that the direct and indirect consequences of a conviction would be out of all proportion to the gravity of the offence.

[6]      If the test of disproportionality in s 107 is made out, then s 106 recognises the sentencing judge has a discretion as to whether discharge without conviction is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MacCabee-Bismark v Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 2749
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of MacCabee-Bismark v Police, the appellant, Adela MacCabee-Bismark, appealed a decision of the District Court, which had convicted her of threatening to injure and ordered her to be sentenced if called upon within six months. The appellant had been declined legal aid to pursue an appeal but eventually commenced one on her own behalf. The High Court was required to determine whether the District Court had erred in not discharging the appellant without conviction. The legal issues before the court were whether the direct and indirect consequences of a conviction would be out of all proportion to the gravity of the offence, pursuant to section 107 of the Sentencing Act 2002, and if so, whether discharging the appellant without conviction was the appropriate outcome, under section 106 of the Act.

The court found that the appellant’s conduct was at the least serious end of conduct that falls within the contemplation of a charge of threatening to injure. The altercation between the appellant and her sister-in-law occurred during a time of significant mental distress for the appellant, and her brother and sister-in-law had not intended for the Police to be called, nor for criminal consequences to ensue. The appellant’s mental health had been stabilised following the incident, and she had moved to Australia to be near her mother. The court concluded that the appellant’s diminished responsibility for her conduct due to her mental disorder placed the offending at or below the minimum level that justified the intervention of the criminal law. The court also found that the consequences of the conviction, including potential scrutiny by the New Zealand Education Council and additional pressure on the appellant’s attempts to deal with her mental health issues, were out of all proportion with the gravity of the offending. Accordingly, the High Court allowed the appeal, quashed the conviction, and discharged the appellant without conviction.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.