| For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link |
| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND |
| CA118/2014 [2014] NZCA 554 |
| BETWEEN | MACALISTER MAZENGARB |
| AND | ANNAN LAW |
| Hearing: | 29 September 2014 |
Court: | French, Venning and Dobson JJ |
Counsel: | A B Darroch for Appellant |
Judgment: | 17 November 2014 at 3.00 pm |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe appeal against the finding of liability is dismissed.
BThe appeal as to the extent of liability apportioned to the appellant is allowed. The equal apportionment ordered by the High Court is substituted for an apportionment of 20 per cent to the appellant and 80 per cent to the respondent.
CThe cross-appeal is dismissed.
DThe appellant is entitled to costs on a band A basis with usual disbursements on both the appeal and cross-appeal. The High Court costs order remains in place.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Dobson J)
The appeal
This is an appeal from a decision apportioning liability between two firms of solicitors that successively advised the purchasers of a unit in an Auckland residential development promoted by the Blue Chip group of companies (Blue Chip).[1] The purchasers of the unit, Mr and Mrs William and June Samuel (the Samuels), suffered substantial loss on the transaction following the collapse of Blue Chip.
In June 2012, the Samuels commenced proceedings against the respondent (Annan Law), which firm completed the purchase transaction and associated legal work for them in September 2006. Annan Law issued a third party claim against the appellant (Macalister Mazengarb) in January 2013, in relation to advice that firm had given to the Samuels during the earlier part of their dealings with Blue Chip. Annan Law settled the Samuels’ claim in October 2013 for $512,500 and the claim for contribution from Macalister Mazengarb as a joint tortfeasor was heard in the High Court at Tauranga in December 2013.
In February 2014, Andrews J delivered a judgment in which she found that the solicitor involved at Macalister Mazengarb, Mr Robin Buxton, had breached a relevant duty of care owed to the Samuels in the advice he provided in relation to the transaction.[2] The Judge was satisfied that Mr Buxton’s breach of duty was a contributing cause of the loss subsequently suffered by the Samuels.[3] The Judge apportioned the liability equally as between the two firms of solicitors, with the result that Macalister Mazengarb became liable for one half of the settlement sum.[4]
[2]At [44]–[50].
[3]At [60].
[4]At [65]–[66].
Macalister Mazengarb appealed the finding that it was liable in any respect that contributed to the loss suffered, and also challenged the apportionment of 50 per cent of the liability. It argued either that all liability, or a substantially greater portion of it, should have been attributed to Annan Law.
Annan Law cross-appealed, contending that Macalister Mazengarb ought to have been liable for more than 50 per cent of the settlement sum.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Macalister Mazengarb v Annan Law and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZCA 554
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal found that Macalister Mazengarb's solicitor, Mr Buxton, had breached the duty of care owed to the Samuels by failing to provide explicit advice that they should attempt to avoid the transaction. The Court agreed with the Judge's finding that Mr Buxton's breach of duty was a direct cause of the Samuels' subsequent loss. The Court also agreed with the Judge that the value of the lost chance for the Samuels to extricate themselves from the Blue Chip transaction was the same when both solicitors were acting for them. However, the Court found that the apportionment of liability should not be equal between the two firms. The Court considered the level of negligence, the nature of the opportunities available to provide competent advice, the potential for a claim of contributory negligence, the potential compromising of Annan Law's position because of its interest in a relationship with Blue Chip, and the additional component of the negligence involved in disbursement directly to Blue Chip of the surplus proceeds of the borrowings that had been arranged for the Samuels. The Court concluded that it would be unjust and inequitable to see the requirement for contributions from the firms as being anything like equal.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.