M v Police HC Hamilton CRI 2006-419-22

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

CRI 2006-419-22

M

Appellant

v

NEW ZEALAND POLICE

Respondent

Hearing:         16 May 2006

Appearances: G O'Brien and G J X McCoy for the appellant

J Mackie for the respondent

Judgment:      24 May 2006

JUDGMENT OF ELLEN FRANCE J

[1]      The appellant was convicted of operating a motor vehicle in a manner that caused the vehicle to undergo sustained loss of traction in contravention of s 22A(3) of the Land Transport Act 1998.  This is an offence under s 36A(1)(c) of the Land Transport Act.  The appellant was disqualified from driving for six months.  A fine of $150 plus court costs of $130 was imposed.

[2]      The appellant appeals against his conviction and sentence.

M   V NZ POLICE HC HAM CRI 2006-419-22  24 May 2006

Factual background

[3]      The  incident  giving  rise  to  the  conviction  took  place  about  9.15pm  on

14 September 2005.   Two Police Officers observed a Mitsubishi van in a carpark. Constable Strongman said he observed the van start up.  He said it accelerated and then did a “violent” right-hand turn.   There was a loss of traction, squealing of wheels and the van completed a 360 degree turn before leaving the carpark.   The Constable described this as a “wheelie”.

[4]      The other Police Officer, Senior Constable Warren, also saw the van start up. He said what happened next was “rev, rev, the clutch dropping and turning in a donut.”   The Senior Constable said the vehicle had “careened” to the right.   His evidence was it was clear that it had done a 360 degree turn, or slightly more than that, before leaving the carpark area.

[5]      The appellant called no evidence although there was some cross-examination of the two Police Officers.

Statutory scheme

[6]      Section 36A is headed “Contravention of section 22A”.  In terms of s 36A, a person commits an offence if the person operates a motor vehicle in a race, or in an unnecessary  exhibition  of  speed  or  acceleration,  on  a  road  in  contravention  of s 22A(1); or if the person,

(1)(c)  without reasonable excuse, operates a motor vehicle on a road in a manner  that  causes  the vehicle to  undergo  sustained  loss  of  traction  in contravention of section 22A(3).

[7]      Section 22A reads as follows:

Persons not to engage in unauthorised street or drag racing, or other related prohibited activities on roads.

(1)   A  person  must  not  operate  a  motor  vehicle  in  a  race,  or  in  an unnecessary exhibition of speed or acceleration, on a road unless the operation of the vehicle in that manner is authorised by law.

(2)   A person must not, without reasonable excuse, intentionally pour onto, place on, or allow to spill onto a road –

(a) Any petrol, oil, or diesel fuel; or

(b) Any other substance likely to cause a vehicle to undergo loss of traction

(3)   A person must not, without reasonable excuse, operate a motor vehicle on a road in a manner that causes the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read M v Police HC Hamilton CRI 2006-419-22 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NZHC 558
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant appealed against his conviction for operating a motor vehicle in a manner that caused the vehicle to undergo sustained loss of traction, in contravention of s 22A(3) of the Land Transport Act 1998. The appeal also challenged the sentence imposed. The case was heard in the High Court of New Zealand, Hamilton Registry. The appellant argued that the statutory defence in s 22A(4)(a) should have been available to him, which would have allowed him to operate a motor vehicle in a manner that causes the vehicle to undergo sustained loss of traction if the operation of the vehicle was authorised by law. The respondent, New Zealand Police, contended that the defence was only applicable to s 22A(1) of the Act and not to s 22A(3) under which the appellant was charged.

The court considered the statutory language and the legislative purpose behind the Act, which aimed to prevent dangerous driving behaviours such as "wheelies" and "doughnuts". The court found that the defence in s 22A(4)(a) was specifically tied to the offence described in s 22A(1), which involves an unnecessary exhibition of speed or acceleration. The court also noted that the defences in s 22A(4)(b) and (c), which deal with situations where the road is closed or where the operation is otherwise authorised by law, were not applicable to the appellant's case. Therefore, the court upheld the District Court's decision that the appellant's driving was a sustained loss of traction and contravened s 22A(3) of the Act.

Given that the appeal against both conviction and sentence was dismissed, the original conviction and sentence stand. The appellant was disqualified from driving for six months and fined $150 plus court costs of $130.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established