Low Volume Vehicle Technical Association Inc v Brett

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2015-404-001925 [2017] NZHC 2846

BETWEEN

LOW VOLUME VEHICLE TECHNICAL

ASSOCIATION INCORPORATED First Plaintiff

AND

ANTHONY PETER JOHNSON Second Plaintiff

AND

JOHN BERNARD BRETT Defendant

Hearing:

31 July and 1 August 2017 with supplementary submissions on

1, 6 and 20 November 2017

Appearances:

D P MacKenzie for the Plaintiffs
J B Brett, the Defendant in person

Judgment:

20 November 2017

JUDGMENT OF PALMER J

This judgment is delivered by me on 20 November 2017 at 4 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

…………………………………….

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

MinterEllisonRuddWatts, Wellington

Party:

Defendant in person

Low Volume Vehicle Technical Association Inc v Brett [2017] NZHC 2846 [20 November 2017]

Contents

Summary ...............................................................................................................[1]

What happened?...................................................................................................[8] Low volume vehicles  [8] Mr Brett as an LVV certifier  [14] The Settlement Agreement  [18] Commencement of proceedings  [22] Undertaking and interim injunction  [23] The hearing  [28] Comment on pleadings and submissions  [30]

Preliminary issue ................................................................................................[32] The issues ............................................................................................................[35]

Issue 1: Can the LVVTA sue in defamation as a body corporate? ................[36] Submissions  [37] Law of bodies corporate suing in defamation  [39] Decision on ability to sue as a body corporate  [40] Issue 2: Were Mr Brett’s statements defamatory? ..........................................[46] Law of defamatory meaning  [47] Submissions  [49] Decision on defamatory meanings  20

Issue 3: Does Mr Brett have a defence of truth or honest opinion? ..............[58] The defences of truth and honest opinion   [58] Submissions       [61] Decision on truth and honest opinion   [63] Issue 4: Does Mr Brett have a defence of absolute privilege? ........................[65] Facts        [65] Law of absolute privilege   [67] Submissions       [69] Does absolute privilege apply here?   [70] Issue 5: Does Mr Brett have a defence of qualified privilege? .......................[75] Law of qualified privilege          [75] Submissions   [81] Decision on qualified privilege   [83] Issue 6: Did Mr Brett breach the Settlement Agreement? .............................[91] Submissions       [91] Was there a lack of consideration or repudiation?   [94] Does the Bill of Rights apply to the LVVTA?   [96] Did the Settlement Agreement breach the Bill of Rights?  [100]

What is the effect of the Settlement Agreement breaching the Bill of Rights?[107]

Issue 7: What remedies should I order?......................................................... [111] The remedies sought  [111] The remedies granted  [113]

Result .................................................................................................................[120]

Summary

[1]      The Low Volume Vehicle Technical Association Inc (LVVTA) has had a long and challenging relationship with Mr John Brett.   Mr Brett used to certify low volume  vehicles  (LVVs)  until  his  authority to  do  so  was  revoked  by  the  New Zealand  Transport Authority  (NZTA)  in  2012.    He  presents  as  an  opinionated individual who has difficulty accepting he is wrong.  Mr Brett continued to maintain a website containing a steady stream of criticism of the competence and integrity of the LVVTA and its Chief Executive, Mr Anthony Johnson.   In 2014 the parties entered a Settlement Agreement (reproduced in Annex 1) over alleged defamation by Mr Brett that governed how Mr Brett would express his opinions in future.  In 2015 the LVVTA and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Low Volume Vehicle Technical Association Inc v Brett and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 2846
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Low Volume Vehicle Technical Association Inc v Brett [2017] NZHC 2846 was a case where the Low Volume Vehicle Technical Association Inc (LVVTA) sued John Brett for defamation and breach of contract. The LVVTA alleged that Mr Brett had made defamatory statements about the LVVTA and its Chief Executive, Mr Anthony Johnson, on his website. The parties had previously entered into a Settlement Agreement governing how Mr Brett could express his opinions in future. The LVVTA and Mr Johnson sought a permanent injunction, damages of $250,000 each for defamation and their legal costs for breach of contract. Mr Brett defended the proceeding in person and sought an apology and costs in return.

The court held that the LVVTA was entitled to sue in defamation as a body corporate on the basis of the opportunity cost of its staff time in dealing with Mr Brett’s statements, which could be reflected in financial accounts. Of the 35 statements complained of, 10 were defamatory of both the LVVTA and Mr Johnson, 11 were defamatory of the LVVTA but not Mr Johnson, five were defamatory of Mr Johnson but not the LVVTA, and nine were not defamatory at all because they did not bear the pleaded meanings or were mere insults (or both). Mr Brett did not succeed in any of his defences of truth and only one defence of honest opinion. However, two of Mr Brett’s statements were contained in an affidavit he made in this proceeding. By hyperlinking to the affidavit, the court did not consider Mr Brett effectively repeated the statements, so they were protected by absolute privilege under s 14 of the Defamation Act 1992.

The court also considered the defence of qualified privilege was available as a defence to defamation about the LVVTA’s performance of its public functions, performed in the public interest to ensure public safety. There is a legitimate interest in an entity performing a public function and bound by the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (Bill of Rights) being subjected to generally-published public criticism which is properly of public concern. Qualified privilege prevents public scrutiny being unduly chilled by defamation proceedings. Mr Brett’s defence of qualified privilege did not succeed in relation to his defamation of Mr Johnson.

The Settlement Agreement purported to require Mr Brett to remove, and refrain from making further, statements on his website that were incorrect. It also purported to require Mr Brett to allow an LVVTA response to be posted on his website about statements that were correct. In those respects, the court considered it was inconsistent with Mr Brett’s right to freedom of expression under s 19 of the Bill of Rights. Accordingly, the court held the LVVTA did not have capacity to enter into a contract containing those clauses, which the court severed from the rest of the Agreement. However, in defaming Mr Johnson, Mr Brett breached the remaining provisions of the Agreement.

The court declared Mr Brett had defamed Mr Johnson in 12 statements and ordered Mr Brett to pay Mr Johnson $100,000 in damages as well as costs. The court also made a permanent injunction that Mr Brett not repeat the defamatory statements for which he had been found liable. The court warned Mr Brett that, if the LVVTA had pleaded and argued ill will, his defence of qualified privilege might not have succeeded.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.