Love v Batterton

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-2385 [2013] NZHC 742

IN THE MATTER OF     The Estate of Olive Elsie Barnes

BETWEEN  CHERYL ANNE LOVE Plaintiff/Applicant

ANDKAY BATTERTON Defendant/Respondent

ANDCRAIG ANTHONY BARNES Third Party

Hearing:         25 March 2013

Appearances: R S Pidgeon for Plaintiff/Applicant

No appearance for the Defendant/Respondent
E St John for the Third Party

Judgment:      12 April 2013

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF PRIESTLEY J

This judgment was delivered by me on Friday 12 April 2013 at 3.00 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:………………………….

Counsel/Solicitors:

R S Pidgeon, Pidgeon Law, Auckland. Email: Richard@pidgeonlaw.co.nz

E St John, Barrister, Auckland. Email: barrister@estjohn.co.nz

LOVE V BATTERTON HC AK CIV-2012-404-2385 [12 April 2013]

Introduction

[1]      The applications before the Court are unusual.

[2]      In essence the plaintiff/applicant (Mrs Love) wants to sue her brother, the third party (Mr  Barnes), because she  considers  Mr Barnes  needs  to  be held  to account for alleged irregularities in the administration of the affairs of their late mother, Olive Elsie Barnes (the deceased).

[3]      Mr Barnes was never the executor or trustee of the deceased’s estate.  That role was performed by an Auckland practitioner, Phillip Batterton, who is now dead. The defendant, Kay Batterton, is Mr Batterton’s widow and executrix of his estate. Mrs Love does not, however, intend to pursue any remedies against Mrs Batterton and indeed seeks an order under r 4.56(1)(a) of the High Court Rules that Mrs Batterton be removed as a defendant.

[4]      So in essence Mrs Love is not seeking relief against the executor of the deceased’s estate nor is she making any claim arising out of the division and distribution of the estate.  Rather she is focusing on the actions of Mr Barnes whilst the deceased was alive.   Procedurally, therefore, Mrs Love wishes to step into the shoes of the deceased’s executors and bring a claim against Mr Barnes whose position, it is alleged, was akin to an executor de son tort.

Background

[5]      The deceased died in May 2006 aged 90.  Her husband, Harold Barnes, died in 1987.   The couple had three children being Mrs Love, Mr Barnes, and Gayle Patricia Leybourne who died in November 2011.

[6]      The deceased’s will dated 4 May 2001 was unremarkable.  It appointed Mr Batterton as sole executor and trustee.  Except for a bequest of an engagement ring to a granddaughter, the estate was bequeathed to the three children in equal shares with the normal gift over to surviving issue if a child predeceased.

[7]      The evidence, understandably perhaps, does not deal comprehensively with the relationship between the deceased and her three children.  Nonetheless there is sufficient to infer the deceased enjoyed a good relationship with her only son, Mr Barnes, whilst the relationship with her daughters was not particularly close.

[8]      Mrs Love’s statement of claim pleads in some detail her brother’s business expertise and experience.   His various directorships are listed.   I accept that Mr Barnes  (although  there  has  been  no  direct  evidence  on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Love v Batterton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 742
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cheryl Anne Love sought to sue her brother, Craig Anthony Barnes, over alleged irregularities in the administration of the affairs of their late mother, Olive Elsie Barnes. The primary dispute was whether Craig Barnes had misappropriated assets from their mother. Olive Barnes died in May 2006, and her estate was left to her three children, including Cheryl and Craig. Craig Barnes had been financially supporting their mother and managed her affairs during her lifetime. The crux of the legal issues was whether Cheryl Love could step into the shoes of the deceased’s executors to bring a claim against Craig Barnes. The court considered whether there were special circumstances justifying Cheryl’s claim and whether allowing such a claim would protect the interests of the beneficiaries or serve the interests of justice.

The court held that the special circumstances necessary to justify Cheryl’s claim did not exist, as the estate was already insolvent. The court found no evidence suggesting that Craig Barnes had acted dishonestly or contrary to their mother’s interests. The transactions between Craig and their mother, including the sale of their mother's property, were structured to ensure the mother qualified for taxpayer subsidies and to retain money within the family. The court refused Cheryl Love’s applications to join Craig Barnes as a defendant and to bring a claim against him. Costs were directed to lie where they fell.

The court suggested that Craig Barnes should attempt to locate personal items belonging to their mother and communicate their whereabouts to Cheryl. The court hoped that this would promote better communication and understanding within the family.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.