Longhurst v Ministry of Social Development

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CRI-2019-435-2

[2019] NZHC 1496

BETWEEN

DAVID PAUL LONGHURST

Appellant

AND

MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT

Respondent

CRI-2019-435-3

BETWEEN

STEPHANIE MARY WHITEHEAD
Appellant

AND

MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT

Respondent

Hearing: 18 June 2019

Appearances:

A Mobberley for Mr Longhurst C J Tennet for Ms Whitehead

S Carter for Respondent

Judgment:

28 June 2019


JUDGMENT OF COOKE J


Table of Contents

Factual background[5]

District Court decision[8]

Approach to appeal[17]

Relevant law[19]

Application for leave to apply out of time[22]

Arguments raised by appellants[26]

Jurisdiction[27]

The MSD’s operational policies/officially included error[30]

Inadequacy of reasons[38]

Dishonesty element of offences[44]

LONGHURST v MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT [2019] NZHC 1496 [28 June 2019]

Broad definition of income[47]

The evidence[57]

Requirement for challenge[62]

What was raised in cross-examination?[67]

Ms Whitehead[75]

Conclusion[83]

[1]                  On 13 April 2018 Mr Longhurst and Ms Whitehead were convicted of various charges of benefit fraud before Judge Davidson in a judge alone trial in the District Court at Masterton.1

[2]                  Mr Longhurst was convicted of one charge of wilful omission with intent to mislead,2 and five charges of using a document with intent to obtain pecuniary advantage without claim of right.3 Ms Whitehead was convicted of one charge of wilful omission with intent to mislead.4

[3]                  Mr Longhurst applies for an extension of time to file his appeal, and appeals his conviction principally on the grounds the Judge erred by not taking into account Ministry of Social Development policy, and that the Ministry did not have the authority to bring the prosecution. Ms Whitehead applies for an extension of time for leave to appeal, and appeals her conviction on the same grounds as Mr Longhurst, but also that the Judge erred in failing to provide adequate reasons.

[4]                  For the reasons outlined below I have determined that leave should be granted, and I have also determined that both appeals should be allowed, and the convictions quashed with no order for retrial.

Factual background

[5]                  Mr Longhurst and Ms Whitehead are husband and wife, and are now retired. For a number of years they jointly applied and received a supported living payment, and later New Zealand Superannuation, from the Ministry of Social Development


1      Ministry of Social Development v Longhurst [2018] NZDC 6555.

2      Social Security Act 1964, s 129, maximum penalty 12 months’ imprisonment or fine not exceeding

$5,000.

3      Crimes Act 1961, s 228(1)(b), maximum penalty seven years’ imprisonment

4      Social Security Act 1964, s 129, maximum penalty 12 months’ imprisonment or fine not exceeding

$5,000.

(MSD). Between 2009 and 2016, the appellants received other payments totalling

$149,265.22, but they did not declare this as income to MSD. As a result, the District Court Judge found that the appellants received an overpayment of benefit entitlements of over $50,000.

[6]                  Mr Longhurst faced five charges of using a document for pecuniary advantage. These charges relate to five occasions from 2009 to 2013 where Mr Longhurst submitted…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Longhurst v Ministry of Social Development and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 1496
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

David Paul Longhurst and Stephanie Mary Whitehead appeal their convictions for various charges of benefit fraud before the District Court at Masterton. The charges relate to the appellants’ failure to declare income received from trading activities to the Ministry of Social Development (MSD). The appellants were convicted of wilful omission and using a document with intent to obtain pecuniary advantage. They appeal on the grounds that the Judge erred in not taking into account MSD policy and that the Ministry did not have the authority to bring the prosecution. Ms Whitehead further argues that the Judge failed to provide adequate reasons. The Court allows both appeals and quashes the convictions. The Court finds that the appellants did not understand they were required to declare the income they received from trading activities. The appellants gave evidence that they believed they only needed to declare income if they earned a profit. This was an important consideration in establishing whether they had the mens rea to commit the offences. The Court concludes that the appellants were not fairly challenged on this point in cross-examination. As a result, the findings of the District Court were not justified.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established