Lochar Estate Limited (in liq) v Donaldson

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2018-485-811

[2019] NZHC 911

UNDER the Companies Act 1993

BETWEEN

LOCHAR ESTATE LIMITED (in liq)

Plaintiff

AND

JAMIE ROSS DONALDSON

Defendant

Hearing: 11 April 2019

Appearances:

K P Sullivan and D A Bleier for plaintiff A J Forbes QC for the defendant

Judgment:

29 April 2019


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE JOHNSTON


Introduction

[1]                   The plaintiff, Lochar Estate Ltd (in liq), through its liquidator, Mr Robert Walker, sues the defendant, Mr Jamie Donaldson, the company’s sole director, to recover a debt that Mr Walker says is owed to Lochar by Mr Donaldson, arising out of a payment made to purchase a parcel of 420 shares in the company.

[2]Lochar seeks summary judgment.

The factual background

[3]The factual background against which the claim arises is not straightforward.

[4]                   Lochar was incorporated on 21 December 2009. On incorporation the shareholders and directors were Mr Donaldson and Mr Owen Jennings. The original

LOCHAR ESTATE LIMITED (in liq) v DONALDSON [2019] NZHC 911 [29 April 2019]

share capital consisted of 1,000 shares. Between them Mr Donaldson and Mr Jennings subscribed for 100 per cent of these shares. The company was incorporated for the purposes of establishing a vineyard in order to facilitate the manufacture of wine to be sold into Asia. The evidence is that Mr Donaldson and Mr Jennings envisaged from the outset that they would attract foreign investors wishing to participate  in  the  New Zealand wine manufacturing industry and – I infer – eventually quit the company.

[5]                   On 16 April 2010, Lochar entered into an agreement to purchase an 18-hectare vineyard in Central Otago from Mr John and Mrs Anne Cook or their interests. The sale and purchase price was $950,000. Lochar was to pay $550,000 in cash. The balance of the purchase price – $400,000 – was to be discharged by the transfer of 420 shares in Lochar, attached to which both parties would have certain rights.

[6]                   Thus, the sale and purchase agreement, and a related shareholder agreement, provided – broadly – that 420 Lochar shares would be transferred to Mr and Mrs Cook at an agreed price of $400.000. At any time during the three years following settlement, Lochar’s other shareholders would be entitled to buy back the shares at the agreed price (the call option). If the call option was not exercised, then, after the expiry of that three-year period, Mr and Mrs Cook would be entitled to require Lochar’s other shareholders to buy back the shares at the agreed price (the put option). The transaction was settled in August 2010. Lochar paid Mr and Mrs Cook $550,000 and 420 shares owned by Mr Donaldson and Mr Jennings were transferred to Mr and Mrs Cook on the terms described.

[7]                   It is common ground that in Lochar’s financial records the call/put component of this arrangement was recorded as a loan from Mr and Mrs Cook to Lochar. It is not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lochar Estate Limited (in liq) v Donaldson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 911
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lochar Estate Ltd (in liq), through its liquidator, sued Jamie Donaldson, the company's former sole director, seeking to recover a debt that the liquidator claims is owed by Donaldson to Lochar. This debt arises from a payment made to purchase a parcel of 420 shares in the company. The plaintiff seeks summary judgment.

The central legal issue in the case is the proper characterization of the transactions between Lochar, Donaldson, and the overseas shareholders regarding the purchase and sale of shares in the company. The court must determine whether Donaldson owes the debt to Lochar and, if so, the amount of the debt.

The court considered the evidence and arguments from both sides. The liquidator argued that Donaldson owed a debt to Lochar in the amount of $380,000, which arose from the purchase of the Cooks' shares. Donaldson, on the other hand, argued that he was holding the shares in trust for the overseas shareholders pending Overseas Investment Office approval. The court found that there were two equally arguable interpretations of the transaction, and the issues involved considerable inference, which should not be engaged in without the benefit of viva voce evidence subjected to cross-examination.

The court dismissed the plaintiff's application for summary judgment and ordered a case management conference to be set down as soon as conveniently possible. Costs were reserved, and counsel may file and serve memoranda in the usual way if any costs issues arise.

This case highlights the importance of properly characterizing transactions and ensuring that financial records accurately reflect the substance of the transactions. It also underscores the need for clear communication and documentation when dealing with complex transactions involving multiple parties and legal restrictions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established