Linwood Food Bar Limited v Davison

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2014-409-000562 [2015] NZHC 45

BETWEEN

LINWOOD FOOD BAR LIMITED

Appellant

AND

JENNIFER DAVISON Respondent

AND

STUART JOY Second Respondent

AND

PETER SHAW Third Respondent

Hearing: 30 January 2015 (On the papers)

Appearances:

T J Mackenzie and N M McSparron for Appellant
H F McKenzie for Respondents

Judgment:

30 January 2015

JUDGMENT OF DUNNINGHAM J (RE COSTS DECISION)

[1]      In  my  judgment  dated  27  November  2014,  I  rejected  an  appeal  by Linwood Food  Bar  Limited  against  a  decision  of  the  Alcohol  Regulatory  and Licensing Authority declining the appellant’s application to renew its on-licence and extend its closing hours.

[2]      Costs were reserved and I have since received memoranda on that issue. [3]  The respondents seek $15,000 in costs having regard to:

(a)       the fact that the respondents were successful in both an application under s 147A of the Sale of Liquor Act 1989 prior to the substantive

appeal and in the appeal itself; and

LINWOOD FOOD BAR LIMITED v DAVISON AND ORS [2015] NZHC 45 [30 January 2015]

(b)taking into account their calculated entitlement of $18,706 in costs if costs were awarded on a 2B basis.

[4]      The appellant, however, resists an award of costs on the s 147A hearing on the basis that Gendall  J  considered costs but decided not to award them.   The appellant also challenges the appropriateness of the time allocations selected by the respondents for the various steps related to the appeal hearing itself, and suggests that a credit should be afforded to the appellant for the respondents’ late, and largely unsuccessful, application to admit further evidence.

Relevant legal principles

[5]      The  relevant  legal  principles  governing  the  award  of  costs  are  well understood. They are as follows:

(a)      Costs are at the discretion of the Court, although any departure from the prescribed  costs  regime must  be considered  and  particularised exercise of the discretion;

(b)The  following  principles   in   High   Court   r   14.2   apply  to   the determination of costs;

(i)       costs should follow the event;

(ii)an   award   of   costs   should   reflect   the   complexity   and significance of the proceeding;

(iii)costs  should  be  assessed  applying  the  appropriate  daily recovery rate to the time considered reasonable for each step reasonably required in relation to the proceeding;

(iv)an appropriate daily recovery rate should normally be two- thirds of the daily rate considered reasonable in relation to the proceeding;

(v)what  is  an  appropriate  daily  recovery  rate  and  what  is  a reasonable time should not depend on the skill or experience of the solicitor or counsel involved or in the time actually spent by the solicitor or counsel involved or on the costs actually incurred by the party claiming costs;

(vi)an award of costs should not exceed the costs incurred by the party claiming costs;

(vii)so far as possible, the determination of costs should be predictable and expeditious.

[6]      Having regard to those principles, I now consider the respondents’ claim for

costs.

Section 147A hearing

[7]      The appellant unsuccessfully applied under s 147A of the Sale…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Linwood Food Bar Limited v Davison and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Linwood Food Bar Limited, the appellant, appealed against a decision of the Alcohol Regulatory and Licensing Authority to decline the appellant's application to renew its on-licence and extend its closing hours. The appeal was dismissed by the High Court. The respondents sought $15,000 in costs, taking into account their calculated entitlement of $18,706 in costs if costs were awarded on a 2B basis. The appellant resisted an award of costs on the s 147A hearing and challenged the appropriateness of the time allocations selected by the respondents for the various steps related to the appeal hearing itself, and suggested that a credit should be afforded to the appellant for the respondents’ late, and largely unsuccessful, application to admit further evidence.

The relevant legal principles governing the award of costs were considered. The principles include that costs are at the discretion of the Court and that costs should follow the event. The court considered the respondents' claim for costs relating to the appeal itself. The court accepted the appellant's submission that to claim the time allocation for all three of steps 10, 11 and 12, to reflect the preparation and filing of a standard memorandum and participating in a case management telephone conference for this appeal, was too generous. The court considered it appropriate for the respondents to claim the time allocation for steps 11 and 12 for case management of the appeal, being a total of 0.6 of a day. The court also accepted the appellant's claim that .75 of a day was a more appropriate time allocation for the hearing given that the substantive appeal occupied approximately that time after deducting the additional time taken up with the further evidence application.

The court accepted the appellant's submissions that a credit of one day to the appellant when calculating its costs liability was appropriate. The court considered that a costs award based on the following time allocations was appropriate: Step 53: Response to appeal 0.50, Step 54: Case management (being a total of step 11 and 12) 0.60, Step 56: Preparation of submissions 3.00, Step 57: Appearance 0.75. The total was 4.85, less a credit to the appellant of 1.00, leaving a total of 3.85. At the Schedule 2 daily recovery rate of $1,990 per day, that equated to a cost award of $7,661.50. Accordingly, the respondents were awarded costs in the sum of $7,661.50.