Liguori v Golden Fund Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2011-404-004878 [2012] NZHC 2253

UNDER  the Insolvency Act 2006

IN THE MATTER OF     the proposal of Alfonso Liguori

BETWEEN  A LIGUORI Insolvent

ANDGOLDEN FUND LIMITED, KNIGHT COLDICUTT LIMITED, K J KNIGHT, K F GOULD, R J WARBURTON T/A WARBURTON, NATIONAL DEBT MANAGEMENT (R J WARBURTON) LIMITED,

WESTMINSTER FINANCE LIMITED, M J MCCARTNEY, P A LIGUORI, D P LIGUORI, S I SAMSA, BROADLANDS FINANCE LIMITED, F BARTOLI,

TSB BANK LIMITED, ASB BANK LIMITED, RICHELIEU INVESTMENTS LIMITED, MALL SUPPLIES & SERVICES LIMITED, F J HAWKE & CO LIMITED

Creditors

Hearing:         29 February 2012, with further evidence and submission on 8 March

2012, 12 March 2012 and 21 March 2012

Counsel:         B M Cunningham for applicant trustee and for the insolvent

G Bogiatto for creditor in opposition

Judgment:      3 September 2012   

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE ABBOTT

This judgment was delivered by me on 3 September 2012 at 3.30pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

Solicitors:

B Coburn, Hesketh Henry, Private Bag 92093, Victoria Street West 1142

G Bogiatto, PO Box 106-120, Auckland

Counsel:

B Cunningham, PO Box 3599, Shortland Street, Auckland 1140

A LIGUORI V GOLDEN FUND LIMITED& ORS, HC AK CIV 2011-404-004878 [3 September 2012]

[1]      This is an application for approval of a proposal made by Alfonso Liguori to his creditors.

[2]      It has an unusual feature in that it is a variant of an earlier proposal that was not approved.1   The proposal is for Mr Liguori to make payments to creditors from the earnings of a hairdressing business that he has recently established.   The first proposal was also for payments to be made out of earnings from a hairdressing business.  The Court declined that proposal, notwithstanding that it was supported by the  requisite  number  of  his  creditors  because  it  considered  that  there  was  a

significant risk that the business could fail causing yet further loss to creditors.  Mr Liguori has changed his proposal to address the risks identified in the previous proposal.

[3]      The new proposal has been approved by all but one of the creditors.  The one creditor still opposing, Mr Francesco Bartoli, contends that the proposal is not achievable, it still represents a risk to future creditors, and it is not in the public interest for Mr Liguori (who is clearly and substantially insolvent) to be allowed to pursue further business activities rather than be put into bankruptcy.  Mr Bartoli also opposes the application on the ground that the matter has been determined by the earlier judgment.

The proposal

[4]      Mr   Liguori   has   eighteen   unsecured   creditors   who   are   owed   nearly

$3,205,000.    He has  declared  assets  of only $1,640.    He has  proposed  that  he contribute $144,000 over three years to a fund for distribution to his creditors.  He says that it is important to him to try to make some restitution to his creditors (even though it will be well short of what he owes).

[5]      The terms of the proposal are:

(a)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Liguori v Golden Fund Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2253
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Liguori v Golden Fund Limited was an application for approval of a proposal made by Alfonso Liguori to his creditors. The proposal was for Mr Liguori to make payments to creditors from the earnings of a hairdressing business that he had recently established. The proposal was approved by all but one of the creditors. The one creditor still opposing, Mr Francesco Bartoli, contended that the proposal was not achievable, it still represented a risk to future creditors, and it was not in the public interest for Mr Liguori (who was clearly and substantially insolvent) to be allowed to pursue further business activities rather than be put into bankruptcy. Mr Bartoli also opposed the application on the ground that the matter had been determined by the earlier judgment. The court was required to decide whether the application was barred by issue estoppel, whether the terms of the proposal were "not reasonable" or "not calculated to benefit the general body of creditors", and whether there was any reason that it was not expedient to approve the proposal. The court found that the present application was not estopped by the judgment on the first proposal, that there was no reason not to approve the proposal on the basis that it was not reasonable, and that there was no reason to decline to approve the proposal on the grounds of expediency. The proposal was approved, subject to the following conditions: the trustee was to investigate and file a report within 20 working days as to whether the business was now (more than six months after the start date) generating sufficient revenue to fund the proposal; Mr Liguori was to file and serve an affidavit, also within 20 working days, confirming that all GST tax returns had been filed up to that date, and that any GST payable had been paid (copies of the GST returns were to be exhibited); and proving the engagement of a chartered accountant to supervise the financial management of the business over the term of the proposal, and to be co-signatory of all cheques. The approval of the proposal will lapse if the business was not now generating sufficient revenue to fund the proposal or if these conditions were not met in any other respect. If the conditions were met, the proposal was to take effect according to its terms.