Libra Developments Limited v Clark HC Dunedin CIV-2002-412-000039

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV-2002-412-000039

BETWEEN  LIBRA DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED First Plaintiff

AND  RUSSELL ERNEST HYSLOP Second Plaintiff

AND  LINDSAY ALLAN CLARK First Defendant

Hearing:         6, 7, 8, 9 and 21 December 2010

Appearances: P B Churchman and L Beecroft for Plaintiffs

L A Andersen for Defendant

Judgment:      21 March 2011

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF CHISHOLM J

A.       The questions asked in the joint memorandum of counsel are answered in this judgment.

B.       Further steps are to be taken in accordance with [245] – [247]

C. Costs are to be determined in accordance with [248].

LIBRA DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED V CLARK HC DUN CIV-2002-412-000039 21 March 2011

INDEX

Introduction [1]
Preliminary legal issues [5]
The earlier judgments [6]
Plaintiffs’ argument [10]
Defendant’s argument [16]
Discussion [24]
St Albans Street [37]
Plaintiff’s approach [40]
Defendant’s approach [42]
Discussion [43]
Answers to specific questions [53]
Law Street [57]
The general approach to disputed invoices [59]
Three particular disputed items [63]
Use of Law Street as security [67]
When should interest cease to run? [71]
Answers to specific questions [72]
Eastbourne Street [75]
Plaintiff’s approach [77]
Defendant’s approach [79]
Discussion [80]
Answers to specific questions [91]
Haggart Alexander Drive [94]
Plaintiff’s approach [97]
Defendant’s approach [98]
Discussion [99]
Answers to specific questions [102]
Cargill Hotel [105]
A brief history [106]
Issues [118]
Refurbishment [119]
Benefit to other organisations associated with Mr Clark [148]
Colin Thom [155]
Material removed from Cargill House [158]
“Preliminary expenses” [161]
Valuation of partnership’s interest in CH 2002 [172]
Valuation of “A” shares [174]
Valuation of “B” shares [179]
Director’s fees [180]
Holding costs and interest [182]
Answers to specific questions relating to Cargill House [190]
Interest [200]
What was a reasonable time for winding up the partnership? [206]
Answers to specific questions [216]
Wages [223]
Tax losses [231]
Valuation of plant [237]
Date of valuation/taking account [240]
Four sider machine [241]
Further steps [245]
Costs [248]

REASONS

Introduction

[1]      By judgment delivered on 4 February 20051 I declared that between February

1997 and October 2002 a partnership involving five development projects existed between the first plaintiff and the defendant.  On 10 June 2008 an order was made for the taking of accounts and subsequently Price Waterhouse Coopers (PWC) were appointed to  undertake  that  role.   This judgment  responds to  approximately 40 questions contained in a joint memorandum of counsel that need to be resolved before accounts can be taken.

[2]      After  the  judgment of  this Court  was delivered  on 4  February 2005  the defendant unsuccessfully appealed to the Court of Appeal2  and then unsuccessfully sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court3.  Following those appeals orders were made by this Court concerning the scope of the partnership assets, directing that accounts be taken,  and  ordering particular  discovery4.   A further  appeal  by the defendant against that decision was struck out by the Court of Appeal5.

[3]      Much of the time between the second Court of Appeal decision in 2008 and the time the matters currently before the Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Libra Developments Limited v Clark HC Dunedin CIV-2002-412-0... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 625
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case was heard in the High Court of New Zealand at the Dunedin Registry. The case involved a dispute between Libra Developments Limited, Russell Ernest Hyslop, and Lindsay Allan Clark. The case was primarily concerned with the resolution of approximately 40 questions contained in a joint memorandum of counsel that needed to be resolved before accounts could be taken. The court was required to decide on various legal issues, including the scope of the partnership assets, the obligations of the parties following the dissolution of the partnership, and the valuation of partnership interests in various projects.

The court found that the defendant had breached his fiduciary duties owed to the plaintiffs, and that the partnership assets included not only the bricks and mortar but also the opportunities arising from the partnership projects. The court held that the defendant was obliged to account for all profits made as a result of the opportunities arising from the partnership projects. The court also found that the defendant's relatively narrow approach to his obligations following the dissolution of the partnership was incorrect, and that the principles discussed in Chirnside v Fay were applicable.

The court provided detailed directions on how accounts should be taken for each of the five partnership projects, taking into account the specific circumstances of each project. The court also addressed various specific questions raised by the parties, including the valuation of partnership interests in Cargill Hotel 2002 Limited, the treatment of interest payable to the defendant, and the apportionment of Mr Hyslop's wages between partnership and non-partnership activities.

The court concluded that interest should cease to run on 30 June 2010, and that all valuations relating to the Cargill House project should be completed as at that date. The court also reserved leave for the parties to apply further should the need arise, and indicated that costs should be reserved until after the accounts have been taken and any further involvement of the Court has been completed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.