| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA |
| CA33/2024 [2024] NZCA 234 |
| BETWEEN | TEODORICO VAQUEZ LEYCO |
| AND | NEW ZEALAND CUSTOMS SERVICE |
| Court: | Thomas, Fitzgerald and Osborne JJ |
Counsel: | J N Olsen for Applicant |
Judgment: | 18 June 2024 at 10.30 am |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
The application for leave to appeal is granted.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Thomas J)
Mr Leyco pleaded guilty in the District Court to 16 representative charges of possessing, exporting, importing, distributing, and making objectionable publications. He was sentenced by Judge K Maxwell in the District Court to four years and 10 months’ imprisonment.[1] His appeal against sentence was dismissed in the High Court.[2]
[1]New Zealand Customs Service v Leyco [2023] NZDC 19137 [District Court judgment].
[2]Leyco v New Zealand Customs Service [2023] NZHC 3556 [High Court judgment].
Mr Leyco now applies to this Court for leave to appeal against his sentence a second time.[3] The respondent opposes the application.
Factual background
[3]Criminal Procedure Act 2011, s 253(1).
Between October 2017 and October 2022, Mr Leyco:[4]
(a)uploaded (exported) 11 publications (videos) depicting child sexual exploitation material (CSEM) to an overseas social media platform using various usernames and distributed them using private messages and chat groups;
(b)uploaded (exported) 117 publications (115 videos and two photographs) depicting CSEM to an overseas cloud storage provider;
(c)downloaded (imported) 15 publications (videos) depicting CSEM;
(d)made 28 objectionable publications (videos) using a screen recording application to record videos depicting CSEM;
(e)possessed 237 publications (230 videos and seven photographs) depicting CSEM across an electronic device and a cloud account; and
(f)possessed a copy of the video of the Christchurch masjidain attack.
[4]Based on the agreed summary of facts.
These publications included videos of a male child performing fellatio on an adult male, videos of an adult male inserting his erect penis into the anus of a male child, an eight-minute-long video depicting the rape and torture of a male child, a video of an adult male stroking the penis of a male child, and a video of a male child having intercourse with a female child. Of the 408 CSEM publications Mr Leyco variously dealt with, 399 of them were videos that fell within “Category A” of the categorisation adopted by the Sentencing Council for England and Wales — the most serious category — which is defined as involving images of children involving penetrative sexual activity or images involving sexual activity with an animal or sadism.[5]
[5]Sentencing Council for England and Wales Sexual Offences: Definitive Guideline (1 April 2014) at 76. This Court in Wittig v R [2021] NZCA 100 at [34] endorsed to use of the guidelines’ categorisation of CSEM in the New Zealand context in regard to their description of the kinds and relative seriousness of objectionable material.
Mr Leyco pleaded guilty to 16 representative charges as follows:
(a)three charges of knowingly distributing objectionable publications;[6]
(b)one charge of making objectionable publications;[7]
(c)seven…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Leyco v New Zealand Customs Service and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NZCA 234
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue in this case is whether the causative contribution to the offending of Leyco’s childhood sexual abuse was adequately considered by the District and High Courts. Leyco argues that both courts misinterpreted the Supreme Court’s decision in Berkland v R, which established that the appropriate standard is causative contribution rather than an operative or proximate cause. Leyco contends that the material he viewed, which mirrored the abuse he suffered, directly links his background to his offending. The respondent argues that the sentencing Judge did not err in her assessment of the connection between the psychological report and Leyco’s offending and that the high level of offender agency in Leyco’s offending limits any effect of his personal background on his sentence.
The Court of Appeal found that it was seriously arguable that the causative contribution to the offending of Leyco’s childhood sexual abuse was not adequately considered by the District or High Courts. The Court noted that both courts used language that was somewhat ambiguous and did not fully embrace the causative contribution standard as set out in Berkland v R. The Court observed that the psychological report might have been more helpful in addressing this issue but was satisfied that it was in the interests of justice to grant leave to appeal to enable the Court to consider whether a miscarriage of justice may have occurred due to the approach taken by the lower courts.
The Court of Appeal granted Leyco’s application for leave to appeal, allowing him to challenge the adequacy of the consideration of his childhood sexual abuse in the sentencing process. The Court noted that the starting point for sentencing was not excessive and that the other grounds for appeal, such as the level of remorse and rehabilitation prospects, had already been considered and dismissed by the High Court. The case will now proceed to a substantive appeal where the Court will consider whether the sentence was manifestly excessive due to the inadequate consideration of Leyco’s background.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi