Lepionka & Co Investments Ltd v Naldapat Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2019-404-616

[2019] NZHC 2679

UNDER the Land Transfer Act 2017

BETWEEN

LEPIONKA & CO INVESTMENTS LIMITED

Applicant

AND

NALDAPAT LIMITED

First Respondent

LW354 LIMITED
Second Respondent

ELIZABETH O’NEIL
Non-party

NADIA DAPAS
Non-Party

VAUGHAN PETER BOWKETT

Non-Party

Hearing: 17 October 2019 at 10:00am

Appearances:

M G Colson for the Applicant

No appearance for Naldapat Ltd, the First Respondent MKP Sullivan for LW354 Ltd, the Second Respondent,

E O’Neil and N Dapas

No appearance for Mr V Peter Bowkett

Judgment

17 October 2019


ORAL COSTS JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE R M BELL


LEPIONKA & CO INVESTMENTS LIMITED v NALDAPAT LIMITED [2019] NZHC 2679 [17 October 2019]

[1]                  This decision deals with costs following my decision of 27 June 2019 that the caveat by LW354 Ltd be removed and the reasons given in my judgment of 15 July 2019.1

[2]                  The applicant, Lepionka & Company Investments Ltd (the “Lepionka mortgagee”) applies for costs against the second respondent, LW354 Ltd, its director, Ms Elizabeth O’Neil, Ms Nadia Dapas, director of Naldapat Ltd, and Mr Vaughan Peter Bowkett, a former director of Naldapat Ltd. The Lepionka mortgagee applies for indemnity costs. For that it claims $45,000 or $28,544. Failing that, it claims scale costs which it calculates at $14,272.

[3]                  Ms O’Neil, Ms Dapas and Mr Bowkett are all associated with Mr Garth Paterson, who was the man behind the development of the property at Kahuranaki Road, Havelock North. I will refer to Ms O’Neil, Ms Dapas and Mr Bowkett as part of the “Paterson interests”.

[4]                  The Lepionka mortgagee applied to remove two caveats, one lodged by Naldapat Ltd and the other by LW354 Ltd. Naldapat Ltd removed its caveat before the hearing. I did not order it to pay costs.

[5]                  LW354 Ltd lodged its caveat claiming it was a successor trustee to GLW Group Ltd, the registered proprietor which owned the property at Kahuranaki Road on trust. I held that it was arguable that GLW Group Ltd did own the property as a trustee; that it had resigned as trustee before it went into liquidation; and Naldapat and later LW354 Ltd were trustees in turn. But those rights as trustee were subject to the prior rights of the Lepionka mortgagee to complete the sales of the subdivided lots. The Lepionka mortgagee’s rights had been strongly contested. That had been upheld by Fitzgerald J’s decision of 14 December 2017.2 While GLW Group Ltd appealed against


1      Lepionka & Co Investments Ltd v Naldapat Ltd [2019] NZHC 1646.

2      AFI Management Pty Ltd v Lepionka & Company Investments Ltd [2017] NZHC 3116.

Fitzgerald J’s decision, I held that in light of subsequent events, her decision had become final for all practical purposes. GLW Group Ltd had gone into liquidation. The liquidator settled with the Lepionka mortgagee, and the Lepionka mortgagee bought out the interests of the second mortgagee, AFI Management Pty Ltd. GLW Group…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lepionka & Co Investments Ltd v Naldapat Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 2679
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Lepionka & Co Investments Ltd v Naldapat Ltd, Lepionka & Co Investments Limited sought costs from LW354 Ltd, Elizabeth O’Neil, Nadia Dapas, and Vaughan Peter Bowkett following the removal of two caveats. The court was required to determine whether indemnity costs were warranted under the High Court Rules and if so, in what amount, and whether costs should be awarded against the non-parties, O’Neil, Dapas, and Bowkett. The Lepionka mortgagee argued that LW354 Ltd acted vexatiously, improperly, and unnecessarily, and disobeyed an order of the court. It sought indemnity costs of $45,000 or, in the alternative, scale costs plus a 100% increase. The court found that the caveat was lodged to delay the sale of the property, and as such, the misuse of the caveat warranted indemnity costs. However, the court could not fix indemnity costs due to insufficient evidence provided by the Lepionka mortgagee. Instead, the court fixed the costs payable by LW354 Ltd at scale plus a 50% increase. As for the non-parties, the court found that O’Neil was in breach of an undertaking given to the court and should pay costs. Dapas was also in contempt of court for being involved in lodging the caveat, but the court did not find her conduct to be so extraordinary as to warrant a costs order. Bowkett was not found liable for costs as he had not involved himself in the removal proceeding to an extent that could expose him to liability for costs as a non-party. The court made orders for costs against LW354 Ltd and Elizabeth O’Neil for $21,308 plus disbursements of $1,608.77, payable jointly and severally. No orders were made for costs against Ms Dapas or Mr Bowkett.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established