Lee v Ricketts HC Auckland CIV 2006-404-7888

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2006-404-007888

BETWEEN  SARAH LEE Appellant

ANDGLENN RICKETTS Respondent

Hearing:         2 July 2007

Appearances: B Henry for Appellant

J Long and C Wilson for Respondent

Judgment:      23 August 2007 at 11:00am

(RESERVED) JUDGMENT OF ANDREWS J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Andrews on

23 August 2007 at 11:00am

pursuant to r 540(4) of the High Court Rules.

…………………………………… Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:  ………………………

Solicitors/Counsel:

B Henry, PO Box 4070, Auckland (for Appellant)

Lee Salmon Long, PO Box 2026, Shortland Street, Auckland (for Respondent) D J Gates, PO Box 222, Whangaparaoa (for Appellant)

S LEE V G RICKETTS HC AK CIV 2006-404-007888  23 August 2007

[1]      Ms  Lee  and  Ms  Gillan  were  the  shareholders  in  a  company  ITmaniacs Limited.  Ms Lee owned 60% of the shares and Ms Gillan 40%.  On 24 March 2003 they signed a “Memorandum of Understanding” with Mr Ricketts, under which he would provide management consulting services to the company and in return each of them would transfer 5% of their shares in ITmaniacs to Mr Ricketts, and Mr Ricketts would be paid an agreed share of the company’s profits.

[2]      Ten percent of the shareholding in ITmaniacs was transferred to Mr Ricketts and he was appointed a director.   However, over time, differences arose and Mr Ricketts was removed as a director in or about August 2004.

[3]      In March 2005 Mr Ricketts issued proceedings claiming $142,841.77, which he alleged is owed to him as a profit share.  He sought summary judgment against Ms Lee.  Ms Lee had by this time bought out Ms Gillan’s interest in the company.

[4]      Ms  Lee  filed  a  statement  of  defence.  Later,  she  filed  an  application  for summary judgment by defendant. She was required to apply for leave. Her application for leave, and for summary judgment, was dismissed in a reserved judgment of Judge Joyce QC given in the District Court at Auckland on 1 December

2006.

[5]      The Judge held that he was not satisfied that Ms Lee had a clear and complete answer to Mr Ricketts’ claim.  The issue in this appeal is whether he was wrong in so holding.  Mr Henry argued that the Judge was wrong, and that Mr Ricketts’ claim could not possibly succeed because Ms Lee was not the proper defendant, and Mr Ricketts  was  not  the  proper  plaintiff.    The  basis  of  this  argument  lay in  three questions:

a)        Is the Memorandum of Understanding a binding contract?

b)If  it  was,  then  was  ITmaniacs,  rather  than  Ms  Lee,  the  proper defendant in the proceeding?; and

c)       Was there a novation, such that a company owned by Mr Ricketts, Lionfire International Limited, rather than Mr Ricketts, was the proper plaintiff?

Summary judgment for defendant

[6]      Under r 152(2) of the District Courts Rules, the Court has a discretion to grant summary judgment against a plaintiff if a defendant can satisfy the Court that none of the plaintiff’s causes of action can succeed.  Ms Lee was required to satisfy…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lee v Ricketts HC Auckland CIV 2006-404-7888 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NZHC 2032
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sarah Lee appealed against the dismissal of her application for summary judgment in proceedings brought by Glenn Ricketts. The appeal was heard in the High Court of New Zealand. The core of the dispute was whether a Memorandum of Understanding signed by Ms Lee, Laurel Gillan, and Mr Ricketts constituted a binding contract, and if so, whether the company, ITmaniacs, or Ms Lee, was the proper defendant in Mr Ricketts' proceeding. Additionally, there was a contention regarding whether there had been a novation, such that Mr Ricketts' company, Lionfire International Limited, rather than Mr Ricketts, was the proper plaintiff.

The central issue was whether the Memorandum of Understanding was a binding contract. Mr Henry argued on behalf of Ms Lee that the Memorandum was not a binding agreement, as there was no common intention by the parties to create legal relations immediately. Instead, he argued, it was an "agreement to agree". The court considered the factual matrix and the terms of the Memorandum but found that the dispute over the facts and the interpretation of the Memorandum could not be resolved on affidavits. The court held that the Memorandum of Understanding was a binding contract because it outlined future obligations, and there was no indication that the parties intended to be bound only upon the execution of a further agreement.

The next issue was whether ITmaniacs, rather than Ms Lee, should have been the defendant in Mr Ricketts' proceeding. Mr Henry argued that the company should have been the defendant because the consultancy services were to be provided to ITmaniacs. The court found that this issue depended on the intention of the parties, which could only be determined at trial. Therefore, it was not appropriate to decide this on a summary judgment application.

Finally, the court considered whether there had been a novation, such that Lionfire International Limited, rather than Mr Ricketts, was the proper plaintiff. Mr Henry argued that the invoices and payments provided objective evidence of a novation. However, the court held that without an express agreement for novation, the use of Lionfire could be explained in other ways. The court found that the Judge was correct in not finding a novation based solely on the invoices and payments.

The appeal was dismissed, and Mr Ricketts was awarded costs. The court found that Ms Lee had not established a clear and complete answer to Mr Ricketts' claim, and thus, the Judge was not wrong in dismissing her application for summary judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established