Lawson v Wenley, Davies, Willis and Cross

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2010-441-000833 [2012] NZHC 204

UNDER  the Arbitration Act 1996

BETWEEN  MATTHEW BRUCE LAWSON AND BLAIR ROBINSON

Appellants

ANDMICHAEL JOHN WENLEY, ALAN JAMES DAVIES, LAWRENCE WILLIAM WILLIS AND RICHARD IAN CROSS Respondents

Hearing:         22 November 2011

Counsel:         J O Upton QC for Appellants

M J Wenley for Respondents

Judgment:      22 February 2012

JUDGMENT OF THE HON JUSTICE KÓS

Introduction

[1]      A law partnership fragments.  Three of the seven partners resign in the course of three months.  By law, each resignation dissolves the partnership.  By agreement, the remaining partners reconstitute in partnership immediately.   At the third resignation they promote a staff member; the reconstituted partnership includes him also.   By agreement also, retiring partners are entitled to payment of their capital, advances and an agreed proportion of work in progress.   But a clause in the partnership agreement restricts the total payable in any year to 5 per cent of the net income of the continuing partnership.   There is no express provision for interest

should this cap delay the payout.  With three leaving, there will be a delay.

LAWSON AND  ROBINSON v WENLEY, DAVIES, WILLIS AND CROSS HC NAP CIV-2010-441-000833 [22 February 2012]

[2]      Two of the retiring partners contend that the admission of the new partner means the cap can no longer apply.  And if, notwithstanding, it still does apply, then they should receive interest.  An arbitrator disagrees.  By leave, they appeal to the High Court.

Facts

[3]      The firm of Willis Toomey Robinson (WTR) has existed in one form or another for almost 125 years.   It is based in the city of Napier.   The firm is the product of the merger, nearly 30 years ago, of two predecessor firms: Robinson Toomey & Partners and Lusk Willis & Co.

[4]      As  from  1  October  2001  (following  the  retirement  of  Tim  Twist)  the partnership comprised seven men: Russell Robinson, Michael Wenley, Alan Davies, Lawrence Willis, Richard Cross, Matthew Lawson and Blair Robinson (Russell’s son).    On  31  December  2008,  two  partners  retired:  Russell  Robinson  and  the appellant Matthew Lawson.  Mr Lawson had been a partner for over 12 years at that point.  Three months later, on 31 March 2009, the second appellant, Blair Robinson also retired.  Mr Robinson Jr had been a partner for exactly 10 years.

[5]      On 1 April 2009 two things happened:

(a)      the appellants formed a new partnership, called Lawson Robinson;

and

(b)the remaining partners of WTR, the respondents, formed a new partnership.  This included a new partner, previously an employee of the firm, Kevin Callinicos.

[6]      The changing partnership of WTR can be tabulated thus:

01/10/01-31/12/08                 01/01/09-31/03/09        01/04/09-

Robinson Sr* Wenley Davies

Willis Cross Lawson* Robinson Jr

Wenley Davies Willis Cross

Robinson Jr*

Wenley Davies Willis Cross

Callinicos**

*= retires at end of period  **=new partner

[7]      The essence of the dispute between the parties, which I will enlarge on later, is that despite the termination of the WTR partnership on 31 December 2008, and then again on 31 March 2009,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lawson v Wenley, Davies, Willis and Cross and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 204
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lawson v Wenley, Davies, Willis and Cross, the High Court of New Zealand was called upon to consider the interpretation of certain clauses in a partnership agreement and to determine the obligations of the respondents to the appellants in relation to their retirement entitlements. The appellants, Matthew Lawson and Blair Robinson, had retired from the law firm Willis Toomey Robinson (WTR) and sought payment of their capital, current account balances, and a share of work in progress, as per the partnership agreement. The respondents, the remaining partners of WTR, had admitted a new partner, Kevin Callinicos, upon the appellants' departure, and argued that this new partnership affected the application of the partnership agreement's payment cap.

The court considered two main issues: the interpretation of the payment cap clause and the obligation to pay interest on the appellants' entitlements. Regarding the payment cap, the court found that the clause limiting payments to a percentage of the net income of the partnership was correctly interpreted by the arbitrator to include the new partnership formed after the appellants' retirement. The court held that the clause's purpose was to regulate the rate of payment, not to transfer liability or benefit to new partners. It also found that the clause did not unfairly extend the partnership's existence indefinitely or confer benefits on new partners.

As for the interest, the court upheld the arbitrator's decision that no interest was payable. It reasoned that the automatic accruer clause in the partnership agreement converted the appellants' entitlements to a debt upon retirement, and the agreement provided for the method of payment. The court noted that interest is not payable on debts unless there is an express or implied agreement to that effect, and since the partnership agreement did not include such an agreement and the parties had historically not paid interest, the court declined to imply such an obligation.

Ultimately, the court dismissed the appeal, affirming the arbitrator's decisions on both the payment cap and the interest issue, and ordered that costs in the High Court were to lie where they fell.