Landmark Property Holdings Ltd v Shen Empire Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2019-404-1578

[2020] NZHC 893

BETWEEN

LANDMARK PROPERTY HOLDINGS LIMITED
First plaintiff

SGA INVESTMENT HOLDINGS PTE LIMITED
Second plaintiff

PURE CARE NEW ZEALAND
Third plaintiff

Continued overleaf

Virtual hearing: 30 April 2020

Appearances:

D J Chisholm QC for the plaintiffs

T J Rainey, J Heatlie and J M Wood for the first to ninth defendants

K G Davenport QC and C V Walsh for Mr Rainey and Rainey Law

Date of judgment:

4 May 2020


JUDGMENT OF JAGOSE J


This judgment was delivered by me on 4 May 2020 at 3.00pm.

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

…………………………

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Counsel/Solicitors:

David Chisholm QC, Auckland Kathryn Davenport QC, Auckland Carmel Walsh Barrister, Auckland Timothy Rainey Barrister, Auckland Burton Partners, Auckland

Rainey Law, Auckland

LANDMARK PROPERTY HOLDINGS LIMITED v SHEN EMPIRE LIMITED [2020] NZHC 893 [4 May 2020]

AND  SHEN EMPIRE LIMITED

First defendant

NUZCORP INDUSTRIES LIMITED
Second defendant

ELLETT INVESTMENTS LIMITED
Third defendant

KEGG187 LIMITED

Fourth defendant

BALMERE CAPITAL LIMITED
Fifth defendant

ALLEY VIEW LIMITED
Sixth defendant

QUINN COMMERCIAL HOLDINGS LIMITED
Seventh defendant

LUKE RUSSELL NOLA and SANDRA MARIKO BURGHAM
Eighth defendants

DON LENG and THU CHANG LENG
Ninth defendants

BODY CORPORATE 327853
Tenth defendant

[1]    On the present application, the plaintiffs seek to restrain Rainey Law, Auckland solicitors, and Tim Rainey, an Auckland barrister, (together, the “lawyers”) from acting for the defendants altogether or either the first to ninth defendants or the tenth defendant.

Background

[2]    With the exception of the tenth defendant, the parties to this proceeding each together are all the registered proprietors of eighteen retail, office, and residential units (“unit holders”) in a unit title development at Landmark House in Auckland’s central business district. The tenth defendant is the development’s body corporate, whose

operating functions are delegated to a committee, presently constituted by other defendants.

[3]    The development includes a positive covenant by which unit holders are liable to contribute the body corporate’s outgoings as assessed and levied “by reference to Rentable Areas in lieu of … unit entitlements”. Such is to diverge from the statutory liability to contribute in terms of “unit entitlement”,1 to secure contributions proportionate to the benefits obtained from the outgoings. Unit entitlements are determined by reference to each unit’s value, relative to the others. The plaintiffs’ units each are said relatively to be more valuable than any of the defendants’ units.

[4]    In June 2017, the body corporate obtained legal advice from Minter Ellison Rudd Watts, Auckland solicitors, while it was beyond the body corporate’s statutory power to levy outgoings in accordance with it, the divergent covenant nonetheless was enforceable as between unit holders. In May 2019, the body corporate’s annual general meeting resolved to require unit holders’ contributions to a contingency fund (to provide for unbudgeted expenditure)2 in terms of utility interests.

[5]    In this proceeding, the plaintiffs (comprising ground floor retail holders of 34.5% of the development’s utility interests)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Landmark Property Holdings Ltd v Shen Empire Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 893
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Landmark Property Holdings Limited and others applied to restrain Rainey Law and Tim Rainey from acting for defendants in two proceedings. The plaintiffs sought a declaration that a positive covenant in the unit title development at Landmark House in Auckland was enforceable against other unit holders. Alternatively, they sought orders that particular outgoings be recovered by the body corporate under s 126 exclusively from the other defendants or are not recoverable by the body corporate as levies from the plaintiffs under s 121 of the Unit Titles Act 2010. Rainey Law and Tim Rainey acted for all but the sixth and ninth defendants in the proceedings, and for the body corporate in a related proceeding. The defendants denied the covenant was binding on them and the body corporate pleaded the covenant "is unenforceable". The plaintiffs argued the lawyers were in breach of their duties by acting for parties with conflicting interests. The court considered the applicable law relating to the body corporate's powers and duties, and the lawyers' duties under the High Court Rules and Lawyers and Conveyancers Act. The court found that the body corporate could not have a community of interest with the represented defendant unit holders in resisting claims by the plaintiff unit holders, due to its fiduciary duty to treat all unit holders even-handedly. As such, the lawyers required leave to act for any other party in the proceeding, which was not sought. The court therefore restrained Rainey Law and Tim Rainey from acting for any of the defendants in the proceedings.

The court ordered Rainey Law and Tim Rainey be restrained from acting for any of the defendants in the proceedings. The court directed the proceedings be set down for call in the next duty judge's list, allowing the defendants to arrange alternative representation. The court preliminarily found the plaintiffs were entitled to 2B costs and disbursements on their application, reserving costs for determination if not agreed by the parties.