Land Trust Limited v WAM Property Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA425/2019
 [2019] NZCA 573

BETWEEN

LAND TRUST LIMITED
First Appellant

STEPHEN ROBERT KELLY and CITILOFTS (TRUSTEE) LIMITED AS TRUSTEES OF THE 44 KEMPTHORNE TRUST
Second Appellants

WESTMINSTER FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED as trustee of The 44 Kempthorne Trust
Third Appellant

AND

WAM PROPERTY LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

8 October 2019

Court:

Brown, Simon France, Hinton JJ

Counsel:

M G Locke for Appellants
D K Wilson for Respondent

Judgment:

20 November 2019 at 12.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.

BThe order made in the High Court refusing to reinstate the appellants’ claim is quashed; the claim is reinstated and the orders of Whata J are also quashed, subject to the conditions set out below.

(i)        The appellants are to pay security for costs to the Registrar of the High Court at Auckland in the sum already ordered of $35,000, within one week of the date of this judgment.

(ii)The appellants are to pay further security for costs into the High Court in the sum of $35,000 within three weeks of the date of this judgment, unless they confirm in writing before then that their claim is limited to return of the deposit, interest and costs.  In that event, the further security is reduced to $20,000, inter alia to reflect a reduction in estimated hearing time from four to two days.

(iii)The appellants must ensure that the trust has validly appointed trustees within four months of this judgment, obtaining an order from the High Court if necessary.

C    If any of these conditions is breached, the claim is dismissed and the orders of Whata J reinstated. 

D    Costs on the appeal are to lie where they fall. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Hinton J)

  1. The appellants breached an unless order, resulting in dismissal of their claim.  In a Minute dated 23 August 2019 Associate Judge Bell refused their interlocutory application for reinstatement.[1]  The appellants appeal against that refusal.

Background

[1]Land Trust Ltd v WAM Property Ltd HC Auckland CIV-2017-404-1014, 23 August 2019 [Reinstatement decision].  We use “appellants” throughout this judgment to refer principally to the first and second appellants, who were involved in this litigation from the beginning.

  1. The first appellant agreed to purchase the respondent’s Eden Terrace commercial property at a price of just over $6 million.  It then nominated the second appellants, the trustees of The 44 Kempthorne Trust, as purchasers.  A deposit of $600,000 was paid and several extensions of time for settlement agreed. 

  2. On 8 June 2016 the appellants gave notice to cancel the agreement on the basis of an alleged misrepresentation by the respondent’s agent that the property had 46 carparks when only eight had legal access.

  3. On 23 June 2016 the respondent gave notice to cancel the agreement on the basis of the appellants’ non-compliance with its settlement notice.  The respondent says that the first appellant bought with knowledge of the carparking issue and the appellants’…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Land Trust Limited v WAM Property Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZCA 573
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Land Trust Limited, Stephen Robert Kelly, and Citilofts (Trustee) Limited as trustees of the 44 Kempthorne Trust (appellants) sought to appeal a decision by the High Court of New Zealand, which had refused to reinstate their claim against WAM Property Limited (respondent). The appellants had entered into an agreement to purchase commercial property from the respondent but later cancelled the agreement, claiming misrepresentation by the respondent. The respondent then cancelled the agreement and sought to retain the deposit paid by the appellants. The appellants issued proceedings, but their claim was dismissed due to their failure to comply with an unless order to pay security for costs. The appellants argued that they should be allowed to reinstate their claim.

The central legal issue was whether the Court should grant the appellants' application to reinstate their claim, which had been dismissed due to their non-compliance with an unless order to pay security for costs. The Court considered the relevant principles for granting relief from the consequences of breaching an unless order, drawing from the decision in SM v LFDB.

The Court found that while there had been a breach of the unless order, it was not a deliberate flouting, and the appellants had attempted to remedy the breach within a week of the deadline. The Court considered the public interest in ensuring that justice is administered without unnecessary delays and costs, the interests of the injured party, and any injustice to the defaulting party. The Court held that the Associate Judge had placed too much weight on the likely adjournment and Mr Kelly's history with the courts and had given insufficient weight to the overall justice of the case. The Court concluded that reinstatement should have been allowed, albeit on strict conditions to offset the prejudice to the respondent and ensure proper representation of the appellants.

The appeal was allowed, and the order made in the High Court refusing to reinstate the appellants' claim was quashed. The claim was reinstated and the orders of Whata J were also quashed, subject to the following conditions: (i) the appellants are to pay security for costs in the sum of $35,000; (ii) the appellants are to pay further security for costs in the sum of $35,000, unless they confirm in writing that their claim is limited to return of the deposit, interest, and costs, in which case the further security is reduced to $20,000; and (iii) the appellants must ensure that the trust has validly appointed trustees within four months of the date of this judgment. If any of these conditions is breached, the claim is dismissed, and the orders of Whata J are reinstated. Costs on the appeal are to lie where they fall.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established