Lake Hayes Property Holdings Ltd v Petherbridge

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV-2013-412-000451 [2014] NZHC 1673

BETWEEN

LAKE HAYES PROPERTY HOLDINGS

LIMITED Applicant

AND

LOUISE DURANT PETHERBRIDGE Respondent

Hearing: 3 April 2014 and 9 June 2014

Appearances:

J V Ormsby and J-L Day for the Applicant
P J Page and K J Logan for the Respondent

Judgment:

17 July 2014

JUDGMENT OF PANCKHURST J

Introduction ............................................................................................................[1] The issues ...............................................................................................................[4] The factual background ..........................................................................................[6] Is it “just and equitable” to authorise cancellation of the unit plan?....................[22] Jurisdiction  [22] The scheme and purpose of the Act  [23] The competing contentions  [31] The “just and equitable” test  [45] Evaluation – conclusions  [53]

Is an order for sale, purchase, or division of the land appropriate? .....................[58] The jurisdiction to unlock a deadlock  [58] The available options  [65] The contentions relating to the relevant considerations  [72] Evaluation – conclusions  [86] An order for sale or purchase? .............................................................................[91] The evidence       [91] The submissions  [94] Evaluation – conclusions  [97] Result....................................................................................................................[99]

LAKE HAYES PROPERTY HOLDINGS LIMITED v PETHERBRIDGE [2014] NZHC 1673 [17 July 2014]

Introduction

[1]      Ms Petherbridge owns one unit of a former motel complex on Lake Hayes, near Arrowtown in Central Otago.  The unit enjoys a commanding view of the lake. Ms Petherbridge regards Lake Hayes as a place of escape and ideal for her work as an artistic director, actor and scriptwriter.  She uses her unit several times a year to work in peace and to enjoy the surrounds – the mountains, the lake, the simplicity and the peacefulness.  To her it is the aesthetic value, not the monetary value, of the property that is important.

[2]      Lake Hayes Property Holdings Limited (Property Holdings) owns the other eight units on the site.  The directors of the company, Messrs David Smallbone and Kenneth Cummings, consider that the site requires redevelopment.   The units, constructed in the 1960s, are small, outdated, and no longer provide  acceptable accommodation.  A proposal to redevelop the site was initiated, but ultimately did not proceed.  Property Holdings now considers that the property should be sold for redevelopment.   The land  and  units  comprise a unit  title  subdivision under the Unit Titles Act 2010.  Each unit comprises a strata estate in freehold that may be sold individually.  But, to sell the property for redevelopment it would be advantageous to sell the land and all nine units as a whole.

[3]      Accordingly, Property Holdings has applied to the Court to dissolve the body corporate and cancel the unit plan under which the units are presently owned and administered.   It also seeks, in the alternative, an order dividing the land to accommodate Ms Petherbridge’s ownership share, an order requiring it to purchase her unit at a fair and reasonable price or an order for sale of the whole property and division of the proceeds.  Ms Petherbridge opposes Property Holdings’ application, particularly the making of any order whereby her interest in the property is lost. Thereby the aesthetic values of the unit, which she values so much, would be lost to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lake Hayes Property Holdings Ltd v Petherbridge and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1673
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lake Hayes Property Holdings Limited, the owner of eight units on a former motel site, applied to the Court for an order to dissolve the body corporate and cancel the unit plan, so that the site could be sold for redevelopment. The applicant was opposed by Louise Durant Petherbridge, the owner of one unit, who wished to retain her interest in the property. The proceeding raises two main issues: whether it is just and equitable to authorise cancellation of the unit plan, having regard to the rights and interests of all affected parties; and if such an order is made, whether a further order requiring the purchase of Ms Petherbridge’s share, or for the sale of the whole property or division of the land, is appropriate. The Court held that it was just and equitable to dissolve the body corporate and cancel the unit plan, given that the body corporate had been effectively defunct for 30 years and the units were past their economic lifetime. The Court found that the site required redevelopment, and that renovation of the units was not a viable option. The more difficult issue in the case was how Ms Petherbridge’s interest was to be accommodated, but that was a separate issue to be determined under the Property Law Act 2007. The Court found that the parties were deadlocked, and that an order for sale, or purchase, must be made. The Court ordered that Lake Hayes Property Holdings Limited was to purchase the 9.15% share of Ms Petherbridge in the property for the sum of $274,500, and that Property Holdings was to pay Ms Petherbridge 9.15% of the excess if the property was sold within 12 months for a sum greater than $3m.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established