L&M Coal Holdings Limited v Bathurst Resources Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2016-485-1007

[2018] NZHC 3121

BETWEEN

L&M COAL HOLDINGS LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

BATHURST RESOURCES LIMITED

First Defendant

BULLER COAL LIMITED

Second Defendant

On papers

Judgment:

29 November 2018


JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

[Costs]


[1]                 In my substantive judgment of 17 August 2018, I indicated a provisional view as to the plaintiff’s (L&M) costs entitlement, and invited memoranda if the parties were unable to agree.

[2]No agreement has been reached and memoranda have been filed:

·for L&M dated 28 September 2018;

·for the defendants (Bathurst) in response dated 19 October 2018;

·supplementary memorandum in reply for L&M dated 7 November 2018; and

·for Bathurst in response dated 15 November 2018.

L&M COAL HOLDINGS LTD v BATHURST RESOURCES LTD [2018] NZHC 3121 [29 November 2018]

Defer determination?

[3]                 Bathurst is pursuing an appeal from my judgment and has indicated that it anticipates a hearing in the Court of Appeal in March or April 2019. In those circumstances, Bathurst opposes a costs determination until the appeal has been resolved.

[4]                 It is submitted for Bathurst that the work involved in determining costs at this stage is unwarranted. Arguably, the range of potential outcomes following a Court of Appeal determination involves the real likelihood of a need to revisit at least parts of a costs determination that reflects the outcome of my substantive judgment. Bathurst points out that, in addition to its appeal challenging my findings, L&M has filed a notice of intention to support the judgment on other grounds, to enable L&M to argue that I erred in rejecting its final ground for the claim against Bathurst.

[5]                 Further, Bathurst advises that agreement has been reached that L&M will not take any steps to enforce the terms of my substantive judgment pending a determination of the appeal. Assuming the same arrangement would apply to a costs order, there will therefore be no fiscal consequences for the parties from a costs determination made before the outcome of the appeal is known.

[6]                 As against those considerations, there is an interest in achieving finality of all aspects of the proceedings, at least at the High Court stage. Further, the differences between the parties on the extent of costs entitlement is such that a challenge to my determination cannot be ruled out. In the event of any appeal on costs, it would be desirable for the parties and the Court of Appeal to have the option of dealing with it at the same time as the appeal from my substantive judgment.

[7]                 I have accordingly decided to proceed with quantifying the costs consequences of my substantive judgment.

Costs claimed

[8]                 The parties agreed at the outset of the proceeding that it was a complex one that was to be allocated category 3 for costs purposes. L&M’s claim for costs is largely

according to scale, with most steps allocated band B but some band C, and in one case a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read L&M Coal Holdings Limited v Bathurst Resources Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 3121
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

L&M Coal Holdings Limited commenced proceedings against Bathurst Resources Limited in the High Court of New Zealand, seeking relief for alleged breaches of contract. The dispute centred around the interpretation of a commercial agreement and the conduct of the parties involved. Bathurst Resources Limited contested the claims, leading to a complex litigation process. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate costs to be awarded to the parties, including the allocation of costs between the substantive and interlocutory proceedings.

The primary legal issues the court had to address were the scale and nature of costs incurred by L&M Coal Holdings Limited during the litigation process and whether certain costs were justified. L&M sought costs on a higher scale, arguing that the complexity of the case warranted such expenses. Bathurst Resources Limited opposed this, contending that the costs claimed were excessive and not reflective of the actual work done. Additionally, the court needed to determine if a reduction in costs was appropriate due to L&M's lack of success on one of its claims and if Bathurst was entitled to costs for certain interlocutory applications.

The court held that while some of the tasks undertaken by L&M were complex and warranted higher scale costs, others did not justify the higher scale claimed. Specifically, the inspection of documents and preparation for the hearing were deemed sufficiently involved to warrant higher scale costs, but other tasks like the preparation of briefs and affidavits did not. The court also found that a reduction in costs was appropriate to reflect L&M's lack of success on an alternative claim, but the reduction should be 20% rather than the 50% proposed by Bathurst. Regarding Bathurst's entitlement to costs on interlocutories, the court allowed an offset for the success on the application for further and better particulars but denied costs for the application to adduce a document during the hearing. The court further examined the disbursements claimed by L&M, capping certain expert witness fees and travel costs while allowing others in full. The court concluded that L&M was entitled to costs of $109,052, subject to the reductions, and allowed certain disbursements with some limitations.

The final orders of the court were that L&M Coal Holdings Limited was entitled to costs of $109,052, reduced by 20%, and certain disbursements as outlined in the judgment. GST was applicable to the approved disbursements, subject to certain conditions. No costs were awarded for the preparation of memoranda on costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established