Kuehne + Nagel International AG v Commerce Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA821/2011
[2012] NZCA 221

BETWEEN  KUEHNE + NAGEL INTERNATIONAL AG
Appellant

AND  COMMERCE COMMISSION
Respondent

Hearing:         3 April 2012

Court:             Arnold, Stevens and Wild JJ

Counsel:         I J Thain and C D Stacey for Appellant
J B M Smith and F J Cuncannon for Respondent

Judgment:      31 May 2012 at 11.45 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant must pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band B basis and usual disbursements.  We certify for second counsel.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Stevens J)

Table of Contents

Para No

A protest to jurisdiction  [1]
Factual background  [4]

Corporate structure of the group  [4]
Alleged price fixing agreements  [6]

Applicable law  [10]
High Court judgment  [17]
First issue – a good arguable case for s 90(2) liability?  [23]

Appellant’s submissions  [23]
Submissions for the Commission  [28]
Liability under s 90(2)  [31]
Potential liability under s 90(2) – our evaluation  [44]

Second issue – serious issue to be tried  [62]

WRS 2001 agreement  [69]
UK NES agreement  [73]
US Air AMS agreement  [79]
Italian SAF agreement  [83]
Canadian ACI agreement  [87]

Result and costs  [92]

A protest to jurisdiction

  1. The appellant, Kuehne + Nagel International AG (Kuehne + Nagel), is a company incorporated in Switzerland.  It is the ultimate holding company for a group of companies (including a New Zealand company, Kuehne + Nagel Ltd, which we will refer to as Kuehne + Nagel NZ) that provide freight forwarding services worldwide.  These services involve the logistical arrangements for the international movement of goods from origin to destination.  The appellant provides such services in over 100 countries by way of subsidiaries in the group.

  2. The Commerce Commission (the Commission), who is the respondent, filed a proceeding in 2010 against the appellant and various other companies alleging that Kuehne + Nagel and others had entered into and given effect to agreements involving price fixing in the freight forwarding industry.  The Commission claimed breaches of s 27(1) and (2) of the Commerce Act 1986 (the Act).  The appellant protested the jurisdiction of the New Zealand High Court to hear the proceeding.  Venning J found that the High Court had jurisdiction to hear the causes of action alleging breach of s 27(2) in relation to five of the alleged price fixing  agreements.[1]  Hence the protest to jurisdiction was dismissed and the Commission was directed to file an amended statement of claim.

    [1]Commerce Commission v Deutsche Bahn AG HC Auckland CIV-2010-404-5479, 12 October 2011.

  3. The appellant appeals against the dismissal of its protest to jurisdiction on these five causes of action.  Leave to appeal was granted to determine whether the Commission has established:[2]

    (a)a good arguable case that the acts of Kuehne + Nagel NZ, a New Zealand subsidiary, could be attributed to the appellant pursuant to s 90(2) of the Act; and

    (b)that there is a serious…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kuehne + Nagel International AG v Commerce Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZCA 221
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Kuehne + Nagel International AG, appealed against the High Court's dismissal of its protest to jurisdiction over proceedings brought by the Commerce Commission in respect of alleged breaches of s 27(2) of the Commerce Act 1986 by the appellant and others. The Commission alleged that the appellant and others entered into and gave effect to agreements involving price fixing in the freight forwarding industry. The High Court held that there was a good arguable case that the conduct of Kuehne + Nagel Ltd, a New Zealand subsidiary, could be attributed to the appellant under s 90(2) of the Act, and that there was a serious issue to be tried in respect of each cause of action relating to five alleged price fixing agreements. The appellant's appeal was dismissed. In considering whether the Commission had established a good arguable case that the conduct of Kuehne + Nagel Ltd could be attributed to the appellant under s 90(2), the Court held that the outcome did not depend on the interpretation of the provisions of s 90(2) but rather on the facts. The Court held that there was a good arguable case that the acts of Kuehne + Nagel Ltd could be attributed to the appellant. The Court found that the evidence clearly established that Kuehne + Nagel Ltd engaged in conduct in New Zealand on behalf of the appellant in the sense that it was the representative of the appellant (that is the means by which the appellant secured representation in the relevant freight forwarding market in New Zealand and elsewhere) and conducted the appellant's business, affairs and activities in this country at the direction of the appellant and for its benefit. In relation to the second issue of whether there was a serious issue to be tried in respect of each of the five alleged price fixing agreements, the Court found that the High Court's findings were correct. The Court held that there was a serious issue to be tried in respect of each of the five causes of action.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of this case revolve around allegations that Kuehne + Nagel International AG (Kuehne + Nagel), a Swiss company, and its subsidiaries, including a New Zealand company, Kuehne + Nagel Ltd (Kuehne + Nagel NZ), engaged in price fixing agreements in the freight forwarding industry. The Commerce Commission (the Commission) filed a proceeding against Kuehne + Nagel and other companies, alleging breaches of the Commerce Act 1986. The proceedings were based on five alleged price fixing agreements: the War Risk Surcharge (WRS) 2001 Agreement, the United Kingdom New Export Systems (UK NES) Agreement, the United States Air Automated Manifest System (Air AMS) Agreement, the Italian Security Administration Fee (Italian SAF) Agreement, and the Canadian Advanced Customs Information (Canadian ACI) Agreement. The Commission claimed that Kuehne + Nagel NZ implemented these agreements in New Zealand on behalf of Kuehne + Nagel, by imposing surcharges on freight sent to and from New Zealand, at the direction of other members of the Kuehne + Nagel (KN) Group.

Kuehne + Nagel protested the jurisdiction of the New Zealand High Court to hear the proceeding. The High Court Judge, Venning J, dismissed the protest to jurisdiction for five of the alleged agreements and directed the Commission to file an amended statement of claim. Kuehne + Nagel appealed against the dismissal of its protest to jurisdiction, arguing that there was no good arguable case for attributing the actions of Kuehne + Nagel NZ to Kuehne + Nagel under section 90(2) of the Act, and that there was no serious issue to be tried on the merits of the five agreements.

The matter initially came before the New Zealand High Court where Kuehne + Nagel filed a protest to the jurisdiction of the court. Venning J dismissed the protest to jurisdiction in respect of five of the alleged price fixing agreements, allowing the Commission to proceed with its amended statement of claim. Kuehne + Nagel then appealed to the New Zealand Court of Appeal against the High Court's decision. The appeal was heard on April 3, 2012, and the judgment was given on May 31, 2012, by Arnold, Stevens, and Wild JJ, who dismissed the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there is a good arguable case that the acts of Kuehne + Nagel NZ could be attributed to Kuehne + Nagel pursuant to section 90(2) of the Commerce Act 1986.
2. Whether there is a serious issue to be tried in respect of each cause of action relating to the five alleged price fixing agreements.

Held
1. The appeal is dismissed.
2. The Court found that there is a good arguable case that the acts of Kuehne + Nagel NZ could be attributed to Kuehne + Nagel pursuant to section 90(2) of the Commerce Act 1986.
3. The Court found that there is a serious issue to be tried in respect of each cause of action relating to the five alleged price fixing agreements.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered two main issues in this case. Firstly, whether there is a good arguable case that the acts of Kuehne + Nagel NZ could be attributed to Kuehne + Nagel pursuant to section 90(2) of the Commerce Act 1986. The Court found that a good arguable case was established based on the facts that Kuehne + Nagel NZ engaged in conduct in New Zealand on behalf of Kuehne + Nagel. This was supported by the conduct of Kuehne + Nagel NZ in implementing the price fixing agreements, as well as the evidence from the United States Department of Justice plea agreement. The Court concluded that the conduct of Kuehne + Nagel NZ was in the interests of Kuehne + Nagel and for the benefit of the Kuehne + Nagel Network Group as a whole.

Secondly, the Court examined whether there is a serious issue to be tried in respect of each cause of action relating to the five alleged price fixing agreements. The Court found that there was a serious issue to be tried in respect of the War Risk Surcharge (WRS) 2001 Agreement, the United Kingdom New Export Systems (UK NES) Agreement, the United States Air Automated Manifest System (Air AMS) Agreement, the Italian Security Administration Fee (Italian SAF) Agreement, and the Canadian Advanced Customs Information (Canadian ACI) Agreement. The Court upheld the High Court's findings, which were based on the evidence of implementation of the agreements in New Zealand and the involvement of Kuehne + Nagel NZ in giving effect to the agreements.

The Court's decision relied on the principles set out in section 90(2) of the Commerce Act 1986, which attributes the conduct of a company's servants or agents to the company itself. The Court also referred to the decision in Giltrap City Ltd v Commerce Commission, which established that section 90(2) extends potential liability under the Act for the actions of others, for which they would not necessarily have been liable at common law. The Court applied these principles to the facts of the case, finding that there was a good arguable case for liability under section 90(2) and a serious issue to be tried in respect of the five alleged price fixing agreements.