Keil v Thompson HC Napier CIV-2007-441-303

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2007-441-303

HERBERT WILLIAM KEIL

Appellant

v

MURRAY DAVID GEORGE THOMPSON AND SHONA AVERILL THOMPSON

Respondents

Hearing:         21 June and 1 August 2007

Appearances: Mr M Wenley for Appellant

Ms K McNamara and Ms S Fraser for Respondents

Judgment:      12 September 2007 at 2.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF LANG J

This judgment was delivered by me on 12 September 2007 at 2.30 pm, pursuant to

Rule 540(4) of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

Solicitors:
Willis Toomey Robinson, Napier

Langley Twigg, Napier

KEIL V  THOMPSON HC NAP CIV-2007-441-303  12 September 2007

[1]      This appeal arises out of a boundary dispute between the current owners of two neighbouring properties situated in Jervois Road, Napier.

[2]      The appellant, Mr Keil, has been the registered proprietor of 2 Jervois Road, Napier since he acquired it in 1950.   Shortly after Mr Keil purchased his property a Mr Clifford London became the registered proprietor of the neighbouring property situated at 4 Jervois Road, Napier.   The respondents, Mr and Mrs Thompson, now own that property.

[3]      The present dispute has its origins in the period during the 1950s and early

1960s when Mr Keil and Mr London were the owners of the two properties.    At some stage during that period Mr London began using land on the southern side of Mr Keil’s property as a driveway to enable his trucks to gain access to the rear of his own property.   Mr London subsequently went so far as to lay a concrete driveway on Mr Keil’s land.    To stop any further encroachment upon his property Mr Keil later built a concrete block wall along the side of the driveway closest to his house. That wall has remained in place to the present day.

[4]      Mr London subsequently built a carport that encroached over the boundary between the two properties, and later replaced the carport with a garage.   That, too, remains in place today.

[5]      After Mr London sold the property in 1961, successive owners of 4 Jervois Road have continued to use the driveway on Mr Keil’s land as the principal means of gaining access to their house and garage.     They have also continued to use the garage notwithstanding that it encroaches upon Mr Keil’s land.

[6]      In January 2006 Mr Keil instituted proceedings in the District Court at Napier seeking an order requiring Mr and Mrs Thompson to cease their encroachment and to deliver up possession of his land.   Mr Keil also sought an order requiring Mr and Mrs Thompson to forthwith remove those portions of the driveway and garage that encroached onto his land.   In addition, he sought a declaration that he was entitled to erect a boundary fence on the legal boundary between 2 Jervois Road and 4 Jervois Road.

[7]      Mr  and  Mrs  Thompson  responded  to  Mr  Keil’s  claim  by  lodging  a counterclaim in which they sought an order under s 129 of the Property Law Act

1952 (“the Act”) vesting in them the ownership…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Keil v Thompson HC Napier CIV-2007-441-303 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NZHC 2108
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in this case arises out of a boundary dispute between the owners of two neighbouring properties in Jervois Road, Napier. Mr Herbert William Keil, the appellant, has owned property at 2 Jervois Road since 1950, while the respondents, Mr and Mrs Murray David George Thompson and Shona Averill Thompson, have owned property at 4 Jervois Road since 1997. The dispute stems from the period when the previous owner of 4 Jervois Road, Mr Clifford London, began using land on the southern side of Mr Keil's property as a driveway and built a carport that encroached on Mr Keil's land. Successive owners of 4 Jervois Road have continued to use the driveway and garage, which was later built on the encroached land. In January 2006, Mr Keil initiated proceedings in the District Court seeking an order requiring the respondents to cease their encroachment and remove the driveway and garage from his land. The respondents, in turn, filed a counterclaim seeking an order under s 129 of the Property Law Act 1952 vesting in them the ownership of all the land to the north of a concrete block wall that Mr Keil had built along the boundary. After a defended hearing, the Judge in the District Court dismissed Mr Keil's claims and entered judgment for the respondents on their counterclaim, ordering that they were to be vested with the ownership of the land on their side of the concrete block wall. The Judge also declined to make any award of compensation in favour of Mr Keil and directed Mr Keil to pay the respondents' scale costs in the District Court. Mr Keil now appeals to the High Court against the orders made in the District Court, arguing that the Judge exercised his discretion according to erroneous principles. The legal issues the court was required to decide were whether the Judge erred in concluding that it was just and equitable to make an order under s 129 of the Property Law Act 1952 vesting ownership of the garage in the respondents, whether the Judge correctly concluded that the re-laying of the driveway in 2005 did not amount to a new encroachment, whether the Judge had jurisdiction to vest ownership of the driveway in the respondents, whether it was appropriate in the circumstances to vest ownership of the driveway in the respondents, whether the Judge should have awarded compensation to Mr Keil, and whether the Judge should have awarded costs against Mr Keil. After considering the arguments of both parties, the court concluded that the Judge did not err in concluding that it was just and equitable to make an order vesting ownership of the garage in the respondents, but that the Judge did err in concluding that the re-laying of the driveway in 2005 did not amount to a new encroachment. The court also found that the Judge had jurisdiction to vest ownership of the driveway in the respondents, but that it was not appropriate to do so in this case. The court further concluded that the Judge erred in not awarding compensation to Mr Keil and in awarding costs against him. The appeal was dismissed in part and allowed in part, and the proceeding was remitted to the District Court for final determination.