Kaye v Norris Ward McKinnon Barristers and Solicitors

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

CIV-2009-019-1473 [2014] NZHC 2215

BETWEEN

ANTHONY PRATT KAYE and MORVA

KAYE
Counterclaim Plaintiffs

AND

NORRIS WARD MCKINNON BARRISTERS AND SOLICITORS Counterclaim Defendant

Hearing: 3 September 2014

Appearances:

Mr Kaye for himself
No appearance for Mrs Kaye
R D Butler for Counterclaim Defendant
P J Morgan QC as Amicus

Judgment:

12 September 2014

JUDGMENT OF PETERS J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Peters on 12 September 2014 at 2 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date: ...................................

Solicitors:           Norris Ward McKinnon, Hamilton

Counsel:            P J Morgan QC, Hamilton

R D Butler, Auckland

Copy for:           A P & M Kaye, Hamilton

KAYE v NORRIS WARD MCKINNON [2014] NZHC 2215 [12 September 2014]

[1]      By application dated 28 July 2014, the Counterclaim Defendant (“Norris

Ward”) seeks:

(a)      leave  to  file  an  amended  statement  of  defence  so  as  to  plead  an affirmative defence of accord and satisfaction (“affirmative defence”). Norris Ward allege the parties reached an accord and satisfaction on 1

May  2014,  following  face  to  face,  telephone,  text  and  email discussions  between  their  counsel  and  the  Counterclaim  Plaintiffs (“Mr and Mrs Kaye”); and

(b)an order that the affirmative  defence be determined as  a separate question.

[2]      Mr and Mrs Kaye oppose the application, although for reasons given below I

require confirmation of Mrs Kaye’s position and require this to be remedied.

[3]      Norris Ward commenced this proceeding against their former clients, Mr and Mrs Kaye, to recover a sum they alleged to be owed on account of unpaid fees. Mr and  Mrs  Kaye  counterclaimed  for  damages,  alleging  that  Norris  Ward  had breached their obligations to the Kayes.  Norris Ward have denied any such breach. Norris Ward discontinued their proceedings in 2012, leaving Mr and Mrs Kaye’s counterclaim on foot.

[4]      I commenced hearing the proceeding on 28 April 2014.  Mr and Mrs Kaye were not represented.  They closed their case on 30 April 2014.  On Thursday, 1 May

2014 I adjourned the trial to the following Tuesday, 6 May 2014.   At that stage, Norris Ward had at least two witnesses to call, being a witness of fact travelling from England and an expert.  Mr and Mrs Kaye had not called expert evidence but I had left open to them an opportunity to do so.

[5]      On 2 May the Court was informed the matter had settled, and shortly after that the parties asked to see me.   Counsel for Norris Ward and Mr Kaye (but not Mrs Kaye) appeared, the former seeking an adjournment on the basis of the alleged accord and satisfaction.  Mr Kaye disputed that any settlement had been reached.  I

granted the adjournment, on the basis that it appeared agreement had been reached but left open the possibility that Mr Kaye might contest the issue.  Since then Norris Ward and Mr Kaye have remained at an impasse as to whether a binding agreement was reached, hence Norris Ward’s application.   On 27 August 2014 I appointed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kaye v Norris Ward McKinnon Barristers and Solicitors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2215
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kaye v Norris Ward McKinnon Barristers and Solicitors, the High Court of New Zealand was tasked with deciding whether the law firm Norris Ward was entitled to amend its defence to include an affirmative defence of accord and satisfaction, and whether this defence should be determined as a separate issue. The Kayes had counterclaimed against Norris Ward for damages, alleging breach of duty, while Norris Ward had sought to recover unpaid fees. The law firm discontinued its proceedings in 2012, leaving only the Kayes' counterclaim. The central issue was whether the parties had reached an accord and satisfaction during discussions on 1 May 2014.

The court found that the law firm was entitled to amend its defence to include the affirmative defence of accord and satisfaction, as the discussions in question took place during the trial and both parties were involved. The court also considered the possibility of determining the defence as a separate question. While acknowledging that determining the defence separately might expedite the resolution, the court noted that the discussions were complex and involved both Kayes. Furthermore, the court was not convinced that the anticipated savings in time and costs would materialise, and given the proceeding was already part heard, it was in the interests of justice to complete it as quickly as possible. Therefore, the court denied the application to determine the affirmative defence as a separate question.

The court granted the law firm leave to amend its defence to include the affirmative defence of accord and satisfaction, and directed the Kayes to respond within a specified timeframe. Mrs Kaye was also required to indicate whether she wished to continue as a Counterclaim Plaintiff and whether she would take an active role in the proceeding. The court further instructed that costs were to lie where they fell, as the law firm had only partially succeeded in its application. Further directions regarding the resumed hearing would be issued following the filing of the amended defence and Mrs Kaye's memorandum.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established