Kaumoana v Auckland City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI 2014-404-000402 [2015] NZHC 269

BETWEEN

CORAL KAUMOANA

Appellant

AND

AUCKLAND CITY COUNCIL Respondent

Hearing: 24 February 2015

Appearances:

P Stokes for the Appellant
C Tamatea for the Respondent

Judgment:

24 February 2015

[ORAL] JUDGMENT OF WYLIE J

KAUMOANA v AUCKLAND CITY COUNCIL [2015] NZHC 269 [24 February 2015]

[1]      The appellant, Ms Kaumoana, challenges an order for the destruction of her dog made by Judge SEC McAuslan in the District Court at Manukau on 4 November

2014.  The dog attacked another person.  Ms Kaumoana was convicted of an offence under s 57(2) of the Dog Control Act 1996 after she pleaded guilty.  She was fined

$400.

[2]      When a person is convicted of an offence under s 57 of the Dog Control Act, an order must be made for the destruction of the dog, unless the owner establishes that there are “exceptional circumstances” relating to the offence, such that the destruction of the dog is unwarranted.1

[3]      One of the grounds of appeal is that the Judge erred in principle and took into account a fact which was in dispute.

[4]      The summary of facts  recorded that  the complainant, the victim, was  at Ms Kaumoana’s house for a family meeting.   She was leaving the house when Ms Kaumoana’s partner invited her into the garage.  Ms Kaumoana’s dog was in the garage.  The dog came up and sniffed the complainant.  The complainant sat down on a bed and the dog sat on the floor in front of her.  The complainant patted the dog and commented that it smelled.  The complainant bent forward to sniff the dog, the dog growled, and suddenly lunged up at her, biting her in the face.

[5]      Judge McAuslan recorded that there was disagreement over this summary of facts.  She noted that the summary said simply that the dog growled and suddenly lunged up at the complainant, but that Ms Kaumoana contended that the complainant pulled the dog’s head towards her, and it was only at that point that the dog lunged up and bit her.

[6]      Judge McAuslan was of the view that the difference was not such as would warrant a disputed facts hearing, and accordingly, she proceeded to consider whether or not the dog should be destroyed.

[7]      Mr Tamatea, appearing on behalf of the respondent Council, accepted that the

issue of whether or not the complainant pulled the dog’s face towards her is one that

1      Dog Control Act, s 57(3).

could have a significant bearing on whether or not there were exceptional circumstances in terms of s 57(3) of the Act.

[8]      I agree with Mr Tamatea’s view.

[9]      The law in this field is helpfully summarised by Heath J in Halliday v New Plymouth District Council,2 and by Katz J in Anand v Auckland Council.3  Whilst the use of the word “exceptional” in s 57(3) creates a difficult test for a dog owner to surmount, it is trite law…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kaumoana v Auckland City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 269
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Kaumoana v Auckland City Council, Ms Kaumoana appealed against an order made by the District Court, Manukau, for the destruction of her dog. This followed a conviction under section 57(2) of the Dog Control Act 1996, after Ms Kaumoana pleaded guilty to an offence relating to the dog attacking another person. The District Court Judge ordered the destruction of the dog and imposed a fine of $400 on Ms Kaumoana. Under section 57(3) of the Act, the destruction of the dog is mandatory unless the owner can establish "exceptional circumstances" warranting otherwise. Ms Kaumoana argued that the District Court Judge erred in principle by not holding a disputed facts hearing, as required by section 24 of the Sentencing Act 2002, and by proceeding on a factual basis disputed by her.

The central legal issue was whether the District Court Judge should have held a disputed facts hearing before making the order for the dog's destruction. Specifically, Ms Kaumoana contested the District Court's summary of facts, particularly the sequence of events leading to the dog attacking the complainant. The High Court examined whether the disputed fact that the complainant pulled the dog’s face towards her could be considered an exceptional circumstance under section 57(3) of the Act. The High Court held that if the complainant’s actions constituted an exceptional circumstance, it could significantly impact the decision on whether the dog should be destroyed. The High Court concluded that the District Court Judge erred in principle by not conducting a disputed facts hearing as required by section 24 of the Sentencing Act 2002.

The High Court set aside the order for the destruction of the dog and remitted the case to the District Court for a hearing on the disputed facts. This decision underscored the importance of following statutory requirements for disputed facts hearings in sentencing and disposition matters. The High Court's judgment emphasized the need to consider exceptional circumstances in dog control cases and to ensure procedural fairness by addressing factual disputes before making a final disposition.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established